Sarabeth’s was excellent. The good, service, location and people were outstanding. The desserts are amazing.
Thoroughly enjoyed my dinner here. The swordfish special was very good, probably the best swordfish I've ever had. Wine list is not extensive, but interesting, and pairs well with the food items. The entire wine list is available by the glass, using a special dispenser system to preserve the wine quality. A big plus.
Atmosphere is intimate and a welcome relief from the noise and crowds of Duval street.
Service friendly and attentive.
I enjoyed it so much, I had breakfast there the next morning (lemon ricotta pancakes were very good).
Great meal - fresh seafood innovatively prepared. Nice ambiance. We sat outside and it was very enjoyable.
Service was excellent and food was outstanding! All 3 of us loved our meal. 2nd time we’ve had a wonderful experience & food. We’ll be back.
Lovely outdoor patio and delicious Grilled Mahi and seared scallops. Thank You
Admittedly our last visit to Sarabeth’s was a few years ago, but we have very fond memories of a lovely location with upscale but unpretentious dining. This time we therefore saved our visit for our last night In Key West. The staff were lovely but sadly the food was very average and what was once a beautiful front porch has now been closed in a bit and it all felt a bit dark and dingy, compounded by faulty lighting on the night, and had plastic tables etc. We left, having eaten an okay meal, but not having had quite the special evening we had hoped for, despite the efforts of the very pleasant hosts.
The mosquitos in the dining room are not acceptable! Ruined the dining experience with my mother who was visiting from out of town, I was embarrassed to have taken her there. Perhaps outdoor dining would be better, just don’t think that I will take that chance. David
Great fried chicken on Sundays! Service was good, a bit pricey for fried chicken.
Ya'll...we had the best meal and the best time here! The ambiance is so nice and we sat on a patio with foliage all around. It is small, quaint, and the food is fabulous. Don't miss the shrimp and grits. Additionally, we stayed late (because we were having such fun) and the wait staff could not have been more friendly! I would give it 6 stars if I could as everything was above and beyond!
Wonderful locals restaurant. Scallop Special was outstanding.
Will be back soon.
Awesome dining experience, great staff and food! We will be back for sure
Delightful restaurant off the beaten path with great food. Had both breakfast and dinner.
Delicious food, great service! It’s off the beaten path so a nice, quieter pace than other restaurants. Well worth a visit! They say breakfast is their thing, but we had dinner there...so I can only imagine what breakfast would be like!
Perfect dining experience . Ambience and romantic . Service is outstanding!!!
Everything was excellent from the moment we were greeted!!
Nice outside seating with good food
The service was great, starting from the welcome. The food was excellent. I particularly enjoyed the scallops paired with sweet potato mash and spinach. It was a satisfying experience from beginning to end.
Sunday buttermilk chicken at Sarabeth’s. Most delicious.
The Thai Beef Salad was unique and wonderfully
memorable. Going back a second time. And
tomato soup with the garlic Parmesan bread is
a dynamic combination. And of course the Strawberry Shortcake never disappoints.
The food was wonderful. My wife and I split their seafood cakes and a salad and followed it up with a piece of orange bread pudding. The wine list was a good one so we each had a good glass of wine. Our waiter was knowledgeable and fun!
The food was excellent. The service was great. The noise level was low.
One of our faves in Key West. We both had the seafood cakes and loved them. The portions were more than enough and we left very satisfied
My favorite Key West restaurant. Have the tomatoe soup! Have the orange/mango bread pudding! Everything is just delicious.
We come to Key West often and like to go to Sarabeths on Sunday for the chicken.
Sarabeth’s has been our go to place for years. The food was not up to our expectations. The Goldilocks was fair and the yellowtail ok and the strawberry shortcake a real disappointment.
I'm a repeat customer. Love this place and will be back, but it was a little off this night. Still very good. Yellow tail snapper is amazing with an incredible presentation. One of my favorite dishes on the planet. Best tomato soup you will ever have. Disappointed that they discontinued the champagne cocktail from a year ago.
Beautiful outdoor dining.
Nice atmosphere, very good food, excellent service. Will definitely go back.
I had walked by Sarabeth's earlier in the day and th out it looked inviting, glad I reserved a table. I enjoyed the swordfish, very fresh and cooked perfectly so it was moist and flavorful. The lentils made an excellent accompaniment that paired well with the flavors of the fish. My only quibble is with the central coast pinot noir, which seemed heavy and thick for a pinot noir, though still drinkable. The service was excellent and, as a solo diner, provided the right amount of attention.
While vacationing in Key West we enjoyed a delicious meal at a good price point on a quiet neighborhood street. Loved it!
This is always our best meal in Key West year after year. Can't say enough about what a great place it is and unique menu. The very best.
Average but nice.
Super dog friendly. Outstanding fried chicken on Sunday night.
Outstanding food, service and ambiance. Shrimp and grits, whole fried snapper and the filet were amazing! Best meal in Key West! Looking forward to our next visit!
A really well thought out menu that takes advantage of all that The Keys offers.
Great restaurant many featured meals: breakfast porridge is fantastic. Sunday night fried chicken. Had the swordfish just wonderful.
Very accommodating outside and inside. Staff very pleasant and professional.
Loved the Key Lime mousse, light and delicious. My tuna was done just right.
It felt like we were eating in an abandoned bus station. Next to the back of a refrigerator. Outdoor dining looked nicer. Food was above average but not by much.
Restaurant in einer ehemaligen Kirche. Innenraum ungemütlich. Zum Glück Konten wir nach außen umziehen. Essen und Service waren gut. Außergewöhnlich Zubereitung des Fisches.