See availability for bonus point tables
Daily 8:45PM - 8:45PM
Local neighborhood restaurant. Owner greets every guest & makes you feel welcome and at home.
Good menu and Sunday Fried Chicken Special outstanding.
Just so great... outstanding, fresh and delightful .... food... service and location... we just loved it so much.
We loved Sarabeth’s. Milos met us out front and took us to our table. He took the time to explain the restaurants history. John, our waiter, was great. The tomato soup is wonderful and the shrimp and grits are great. I hope a lot of people check it out. Sorry we didn’t get to try the Southern chicken.
Love Sarabeth's - never disappoints! Very friendly and well educated staff, amazing food - I got the whole fish, which is flash fried and it was amazing!
Amazing, as always! Love this place and the staff ❤️
While there’s much to like about Sarabeth’s, the menu changes infrequently and the food was just decent on our last visit.
Our first visit to this funky neighborhood restaurant was a delight. The maitre'd is gracious and humorous; the staff are real people; the food is very good; the price is right. Reservations recommended as SARABETH's is small, and more than a few folks were turned away while we were at dinner.
Excellent. Lovely food. A local favorite. Especially Sunday with special fried chicken. Went twice on a one week vacation. Excelllt
An exquisite dining experience all the way around... Amazing appetizers, entrees and desert...
Thank you for a wonderful meal and experience.
Amazing! We had a party of 8 and everyone raved about their meal. The gentlemen serving us were friendly, informative and provided excellent service. We had a variety of appetizers, entrees and desserts. They were all delicious. We will definitely return.
Always great fried chicken on Sunday and Fried whole Snapper all days. Don't miss the Strawberry Shortcake. The best.
Really quaint . Good food . Enjoyed sitting outside . Calamari really good .
As always. Food was fantastic. Best restaurant in key west
Great staff! Delicious dinner. Shrimp & Grits were the best. A very pleasant surprise.
Tomato soup and shrimp and grits were sublime. Definitely worth the visit and will certainly go again.
Grilled mahi was excellent
My main issue with this restaurant was with the food. My son and I split the calamari appetizer which we enjoyed. But our entree was terrible. It was a special that was supposed to be fish with a mushroom corn sauce, but honestly the sauce just tasted like cream and flour. It was really not good. On the other hand, my daughter in law had the filet with broccolini which she enjoyed. Note to chef, if you make a special and it tastes bad, don't put it on the menu.
We were looking forward to our dinner based on reviews and reputation however we were disappointed with the overall experience. Service was good but limited and unimaginative wine listed and over cooked and under seasoned shrimp left us unimpressed. Highlight of the meal was starters of tomato soup and grilled Caesar salad. There are so many really great restaurants in Key West that I would not bother with eating here.
Fabulous meal! Great and friendly service! A “must stop “ whenever in Key West!! The yellow snapper is pure food joy!
We have eaten at Sarabeth's several times, and it has always been excellent. Great seafood. Good wine list. Great service. Would recommend it.
The Sunday fried chicken is not to be missed. Outstanding.
Service was a 10! Ed Pomphrey Rumson
A great dining experience
Fantastic place we totally enjoyed our visits!
We loved our dinners - shrimp and grits for me, and the snapper for my wife. And we’ll be having the tomato bisque for dinner tonight! We ordered two portions as take out
Totally enjoyed dinner. Highly recommend.
We've always loved it since it opened. Also knew Sarabeth's from the upper West Side.
The food is consistently superb, the wine we had was wonderful, a Pinos Gris from the Willamette Valley and the service was professional, attentive but not intrusive. And oh, the famous Tomato Soup; that soup continues to be a dream.
Sarabeth's is a consistent winner.
Been here before, this time we felt the chicken was a bit over cooked but it was very tasty. Our waitress was excellent. We were seated inside rather than wait a good while and that was fine on a warm evening. Interesting Ceasar Salad presentation.
Well prepared and interesting dishes. Service was good
Beautiful sidewalk restaurant tremendous service! Highly recommend.
Extremely accommodating, great service and both meals outstanding.
Charming interior decor with a very attentive wait staff. The food was excellent. Well worth the price.
During my last trip to Key West, we visited Sarabeth's on two occassions. We had breakfast and dinner there as well. We love how the chef incorporates local flavors into everyday dishes. Teh breakfast dishes are quite large. For dinner we enjoyed several local dishes. The seafood items are always fresh. I loved their local pink Key West shrimp. I highly recommend you make a reservation as there is always a waiting time due to the restaurant's popularity.
This was our first dinner at the restaurant and the food was excellent. My husband had the fish cakes and I had the salmon. Both dishes were exceptionally well prepared. The presentation was lovely and the portions generous. We had dinner at some of the most expensive restaurants in Key West this past week and Sarabeth’s food was as good or better and much less costly. We will be back.
Nice evening the pork chop was excellent.
Fabulous experience. Service excellent. Food to die for. Shrimp and grits with andouille sausage. OMG. Creamy tomato soup. Chocolate pudding. Great ambience.
What a great place just off Duval! I love Sarabeths and would eat there every day if I could. The staff is the best I have encountered anywhere in Key West, the food is phenomenal no matter what you decide to get and the overall service was just superb. Try the special, baked eggs, or lemon ricotta pancakes or shrimp and bacon omelet or the duck bacon Benedict...it is all so good. The soup and smoked mozzarella sandwich for lunch or the open faced tuna sandwich or the fish tacos...you really can't go wrong. They do an amazing dinner menu as well, try the snapper or shrimp and grits or grilled pork chop...I can't get over how many amazing things they have on the menu. I will be back, maybe even tonight!
We always have a great meal here. We try to dine here at least once each time we’re in Key West.
We always make it here for breakfast at least once time every vacation in key west
The Flower juice is amazing !!!