A recent lunch at San Pietro was as excellent and enjoyable as I have come to expect. The combination of wonderfully prepared food with a relaxed but very elegant environment makes it one of the most enjoyable Italian spots in midtown. One should be prepared that it is expensive, but it is truly enjoyable.
Very authentic and tasty place!
The food and service were all superb. Manolo, the Maitre D, did an entertaining and thorough job explaining all of the specials and he made us feel very welcome in this lovely little Italian restaurant. It’s a bit pricey, but we knew that and decided it was worth the splurge for our anniversary.
Outstanding service / experience. Never disappoints.
This restaurant is everything one would expect from a great Italian restaurant.
Marvelous restaurant, superb food and wine, lovely ambience, fantastic service. Only issue is $$$--I ordered a small pasta side, thinking it would accompany my (delicious)chicken parmigiano, and was surprised to see an additional charge of $22 when the bill arrived!! Nonetheless, this is one of he best restaurants that we regularly patronize when visiting NYC, and I recommend it often.
I recently had lunch at San Pietro after not having been there for a while. It was truly superb. The food was uniformly outstanding, the service very attentive and gracious, the ambience very pleasant. It is expensive, so you need to be prepared for that. If you are, you will find this to be an excellent place in all respects.
Best Italian restaurant in Manhattan. A rare gem.
Small portions and waiter was very pushy
Absolutely amazing. Enjoyed every moment. It’s a hidden gem where you feel loved and welcomed into someone’s Italian home . Will be making my next date take me again .
Excellent food and service ...maybe the best restaurant experience I’ve ever had in NY ......highly recommend!! So great !!
San Pietro is a wonderful, cozy, restaurant....You feel like you are in a little restaurant in Italy. Food is very good and service is old school which means excellent.
The food is always flawless and impeccably prepared! My favorite place in Manhattan for a business lunch!
Always great. Top quality Italian restaurant. Great food, great wine list, excellent service.
Delicious meal,very friendly staff and nice atmosphere.
Always a treat! Delicious meal. Very special.
Pasta was delicious. But the rest of food was just Ok.
One of the best Italian restaurants in NY. Excellent service. Terrific wine list. Wonderful people. Authentic and top shelf.
our waiter was fantastic--always the same homey experience
outstanding food and service nice people would recommend it to everyone
Way too expensive.
Very slow service.
Good food, over priced, but it is NYC?
Great location, friendly staff, impeccable service.
excellent evening - friendly staff who were attentive and most important outstanding food. highly recommend
Always consistent and excellent - which is why we keep going back.
This restaurant always delivery. Expensive but the best.
simply the best Italian restaurant in nyc, bar none.
Always top notch experience. Good and service 5 stars.
Always an enjoyable experience. Food is excellent and they make you feel very welcome.
We had a wonderful dinner here before a broadway play. Beautiful restaurant, top notch service, and a delicious meal...
First went here almost exactly 20 years ago - still fabulous
Overall very nice experience. Will go back for sure.
As good as it gets. From the crystal water glasses, the amazing service, generous cocktails and fabulous seasonal dishes.
It’s not inexpensive but worth every penny.
The best Italian Restaurant south of 57th Street😍🥂🍝
this is a great restaurant. Food and service are excellent. It is, however, very expensive. Despite, I never feel taken advantage of, because the quality of everything is so high.
A lovely evening excellent traditional Italian food
The service was excellent. Very attentive and friendly. Treat you like you are a regular. My food was very good but nothing extraordinary. The bill was high, even for New York.
Always fabulous food and service. One of THE BEST Italian restaurants in New York City.
A classy Italian restaurant. Will consider coming back.
Food barely adequate and overpriced. Server rude and unresponsive.
Excellent food and service. A little pricey, but it was very delicious.