Fifty feet from Carnegie Hall, near Central Park and convenient to all midtown hotels, the Redeye takes its name from the infamous late-night flight linking America's two cultural hubs. The flavors of the two coasts are fused in both the grand cafe's interior design and the bold New American menu.View Private Dining Details
I'm probably a fairly tough critic but the Redeye passed relatively unscathed. Drinks were good but a bit pricey. We didn't try the appetizers. The salmon with wild mushrooms was very good. The crab cake with shrimp was also very good though don't expect a very large crab cake. And the lobster lasagne was decadent. I particularly enjoyed the sautéed spinach which served all four of us nicely. The chocolate blackout cake was enormous. And the banana pie was full of big chunks of banana on a graham cracker crust and not overly sweet which was nice. The coffee was also good. Service was a bit on the slow side and lacked much attentiveness. Any of us in the group would go back.
Our server Craig was wonderful, friendly, informative & very professional. The calamari was delicious, the lobster & crab lasagne was alright, I prefer the vegan squash spaghetti & meatballs, & my friends enjoyed his fillet mignon. The desert was banana custard & there were cookies that were brought around. After dinner, 2 bottles of wine & desert I was beyond satisfied.
Live Music was GREAT and so was the food! Would go there again!
Right across street from CARNEGIE HALL - fun open atmosphere, great food and excellent service. Will return.
We lucked up on this gem because it was right next to our hotel. Group of six on a Saturday night. Excited that e could easily book a table via the app.
The staff was very friendly and attentive. Good options for a variety of food interests. The side dishes to share were amazing, especially the Thai peanut sauce Brussels sprouts.
The live entertainment deserves a huge shout out. Phenomenal singer with a great "playlist".
Highly recommended by all six of our group!
Consistently good! Great food and service in a beautiful dining room! Excellent steaks and American fare.
Excellent food and service! Make reservations as the restaurant fills up quickly. Seafood is fresh and tasty!!
Terrific all around...service and food were top notch...even when it was a full house noise was NOT an issue...will definitely return!
Always a good bet pre-theater for City Center shows
Dinner was great and so was the music!
Great food and wonderful wait staff. The game is always lovely as well.
Lobster roll skimpy and pieces of lobster tiny. Did not look like fresh lobster
What a wonderful meal and excellent service dining at Red Eye Grille prior to our Carnegie Hall concert. The table we requested was ready, we were greeted warmly at the front maitre d' station, our waiter Polo pointed us in the right direction for our meal choices. His service was excellent and my rib eye steak was cooked to perfection along with delicious pommes frites and tasty asparagus. It was so special seeing Richard, the General Manager, whom I recognized from years of dining st Cafe Fiorello..charming and welcoming as ever. Go to Red Eye Grille. It will not disappoint. The food and service are excellent.
The service and ambiance were excellent, but my miso glazed black cod had bones in it, and my son was delivered a ribeye instead of the filet that he ordered, which was given to another diner.
Great experience, will go again.
Made pre-concert reservations on one of the busiest nights of the year (Valentine's Day). This place never disappoints.
My guests and I enjoyed a wonderful meal, great service, from reception (champagne toast was a nice touch) throughout our dining experience. We were very impressed with the decor and energy, within the restaurant. We enjoyed everything about our experience, and would be happy to recommend you to friends and business associates, in fact I already have!
Great service, Great food and Great ambiance. Accessibility to area events, also highly favorable.
Top notch service and food! Loved our waiter, Alton! Great cocktails and dinner. A wonderful anniversary experience.
I’ve had a great time every time I’ve visited Redeye, particularly for brunch. Food and drinks are fantastic!
My lobster was small and bland. It was roasted so I did not expect it to be watery, buy it was
Great food & options
The food and service are always good at Red Eye Grill. I was happy to see more meat listings on the menu. I'm not a fish eater but my husband is. The menu change has made dining here a great experience for both of us. We don't live in the city but enjoy this restaurant and others from the group when we do visit.
More congenial than expected. I remember having a business meal here but a casual get together worked just as well. Our waiter was charming and efficient. Food was good, nothing too fancy on this occasion, but tasty.
Great business lunch spot. Excellent food and varied options.
Food was excellent, as usual. Seafood is always a good choice here. Service was a bit off this time around.
Delightfuas always. Lovely service and excellent food.
Wonderful Staff, from door to door. Gracious and obliging! Fantastic food preparation and presentation. Great dinner!
Very cliche restaurant on Broadway, but still fun. Decent food and good drinks. Piano player was great in the lounge.
Fyvmgreat food thanks..fyvmrfyvmfyvmfyvmfyvmfyvmfyvmgfyjsgfyjs