Each year my husband and I celebrate our anniversary and have dinner at GC Hotel. We had a wonderful time last night. Delicious food and great service!!

The staff, food and atmosphere were outstanding!

This was our 3rd visit to Red Salt and probably the best one. I cannot recall another Long Island restaurant that has such a calming effect on diners. All diners were appropriately spaced and ALL restaurant staff were wearing masks. As for the food, I have never had a meal that wasn't superb. Try the maple bacon as an appetizer. The steaks and seafood are great choices for entres. A variety of high quality side dishes are also available. As for the staff, they are all courteous and professional. You just can't go wrong by visiting Red Salt.

JC was an outstanding waiter and it’s the best tasting food we have had in a long time. The bacon with a touch of lemon and pickles was out of this world!! I had a Friday special 2lb lobster surf and turf meal. I really don’t want to post this review because then too many people will start going there but It’s too good to keep it to myself!!

Beautiful restaurant excellent food a great celebration experience

Another great night at Red Salt! Mary and Jose are the best. And the food was perfect as always. Thank you very much!

Terrible food and service we were so disappointed!! And it’s extremely expensive!!

What an absolute wonderful experience all around. Due to Covid hadn't been out very much. But decided to go out and celebrate my husband's birthday. What a wonderful experience. Will be back.

It was my first time here. I ordered the Cobb salad with shrimp and filet. The menu described heirloom tomatoes and they were cherry tomatoes. I live near farms so I know the difference. I eat heirloom all the time. The bacon in the salad was fatty and seemed uncooked. I was expecting toasted chunks. Our drink we ordered was an old fashioned. The bartender put no time into it at all and tasted like bourbon with a slice of orange and a cherry, no muddling at all. It just seemed very average to me and for a $40.00 salad I feel I was not asking to much for good tomatoes and bacon. The meat and the 3 shrimp that were in it were good, however the shrimp was very bland as well. Nice place to stay however, it looked like a beautiful hotel.

We had our anniversary dinner, the waitress was very pleasant, they gave us a free glass of champagne and a free dessert to share.

Romantic, classy atmosphere. Excellent food. Fantastic service.

Excelente food

Overall experience was very good. Food is delicious. Looking forward to many more beautiful nights here.

while I believe it’s nice and proper to expose children to a fine dining experience parents MUST control them. Unfortunately during our last two visits to the restaurant both times were marred by yelling and screaming children

The food was very good. Loved the dumplings and branzino. The waygu steak was very chewy. The waiter was polite and good overall, but it looked that there was one waiter for the whole restaurant and several bus boys. Most ESL. Nice ambiance. The wine list was decent but little selection. Only six reds.

This place is not cheap, and it is in the Garden City Hotel. I do wish that they would have a dress code. I saw three clowns at two different tables, dressed in Hawaiin Shirts and shorts. Shorts?

Great food, as always. And the staff is simply the best. Jose, Mary, always do such a great job. We love coming here!

Had a wonderful meal and good wine with my daughter and a friend! Had dined earlier in the week in BYC at David Burke and this didn’t disappoint.

This was our first time but it won’t be our last. We were celebrating our anniversary and enjoyed it very much. Our server was wonderful and the food was great. Would definitely recommend.

Great food. Everything was absolutely delicious. The restaurant has a very nice atmosphere. Staff was very attentive but not overbearing.

So disappointed, had been there many times before, and this was a completely different restaurant.
Cold appetizers amd possibly the worst steak I have had in years…. Unacceptable
Wow it was a disappointment…..

Very nice except too loud. Could not hear at a table of 4.

We were looking forward to this upscale dinner with friends. Started out on a great note with good cocktails and salad and the maple candied bacon was amazing! But the steaks we had were very disappointing. We had wagyu and sirloins. They were not very tender and mine had a vein through it. This should not be the case in a restaurant that charges $68 for a ribeye! Dessert was not memorable. So to be honest even though a beautiful space, I don't be think we will be returning.

The waiter was attentive initially but then disappeared. Out appetizers came out relatively quickly but the main course took much longer and the steak was raw. It had to be sent back. I ordered the chocolate sphere cake for dessert and it was so repulsive I sent it back and didn’t want anything else. I would say it’s completely overpriced and mediocre.

Very disappointing. Service was very good but the food was mediocre at best. The angry garlic 2 lb lobster was definitely not 2 lb, nor did it have garlic and totally lacked spice. It was sitting in a pool of bland oil. Can’t recommend this restaurant.

We started at patio bar where Jose made us the most refreshing cocktails. Great comfortable atmosphere out there but we decided to head into king bar where the famous Brian made us our favorite cocktails, the cucumber south side and the maple bourbon old fashioned. His hospitality skills are off the charts. We sat down for dinner and had such an incredible experience! Mary Francis is a top notch server and recommend such great options for every part of our meal. She was kind, friendly and over exceeded our expectations. The manager Brittney stopped by and was such a pleasure to take to. I can’t wait for my next experience here!

We had a Wonderful Anniversary Celebration ! Mary was so attentive and so thoughtful .... our dinner was delicious! Got a bit noisy at times...and we were seated in front of a serving table when they started to set up for Brunch I gather... that should really wait until the diners are gone.. However...being our first time dining at Red Salt we will return.... and soon.... thank you for the lovely Anniversary treats! Very appreciated!

We went for my birthday, I thought the food and decor were outstanding. The portions are moderate but of the highest quality. The service was very good as they were trying very hard but seemed a little rusty post covid. Will go back.

Service was good. Food was very good. Very impressed and glad I found a local place with class to eat.

Wonderful evening celebrating our 48th anniversary!

oddly at the big cash prices a good deal great food and fun

We had a lovely time… food was excellent…. Candied bacon a must!

Only critique is the dessert selection… not that enticing… the little chocolate squares were a better offering than their dessert menu.

Anniversary

Great experience! Loved the Maple Bacon appetizer!

For a hotel lobby restaurant the food and service were better than I expected. Both the appetizers and main courses ordered were very good and priced fairly.

Beautiful restaurant.. excellent service.. Mary was fantastic...

The bacon on the clothesline is still my very favorite. Everything was delicious. I was there for Restaurant Week and the selection was good with additional items on the menu for an additional price. The room is quiet and very private. I enjoyed my early dinner very much.

Love eating here! Always delicious & the wait staff is fantastic (JC & Mary). Never leave disappointed.

Staff and food exceeded expectations . Friendly and prompt service! Definitely and highly recommended

First time we tried this restaurant and it was amazing! Great for a special event. Food was so tasty. I am vegetarian and they catered to my needs in an excellent manner. I would definitely go back!

The ambiance, service and food were superb. Since we selected from the Restaurant Week menu, an 18% tip was added to our bill. Since we were not made aware of this, we tipped an additional 20%. Service was excellent but not for a 32% tip.