Prime House

This is my second time for brunch; while the menu is limited, there is something for everyone. With live Jazz in the background and good food, it is the a wonderful place to go. I will definitely continue to return.

Excellent prime rib, ribeye steak. Casual vibe.

Our meal was delicious. The NY strip was cooked to perfection. My king crab legs were perfect. Our server, Jose, could not have been nicer and he was extremely accommodating. We had so much fun. Highly recommend.

Really great food and the service was impeccable. Mike was really wonderful.

Everyone was excellent

The meal was great and the restaurant is beautiful .Loved the service i received from shabir ! He was attentive,knoweldgeable and fun to be with He really went above and beyond :) Enjoyed my birthday dinner!He made a perfect evening memorable

Loved the whole experience. Nice greeting when we arrived. Excellent service. Delicious food! Quiet. Couldn’t ask for more. Will be back soon.

There was an issue with their ticketing system, so some of the food tickets were going to the wrong section of the kitchen, so they were getting orders that belonged to a different section, causing delays. Service was OK. Wasn't the best experience we've had there.

Birthday celebration

I thought the Sunday brunch and regular menu options were great. Food was a little on the salty side in general but what I had was really good. I had the beet tower salad and prime burger with fries paired with a mimosa and beer. I would come again on a weeknight for dinner when it isn’t as busy. There was a loud catered event next to us. The service was excellent.

Recommended- good food, atmopshere and service

Excellent food and service! Would highly recommend!

The food and drinks were amazing. The service was just okay. Took a while for our server to greet us, bring us drinks, and waited over 20 minutes for our check.

I loved the food at this place, the only thing was we waited 45 minutes after our reserved seating time to be seated. The owner was nice enough to apologize but, some of my friends were extremely hungry so definitely didnt help.
The rib eye , wedge salad, the sushi rolls were excellent!

The food is consistently good and a great place to dine.

I already wrote a review for this dinner but somehow it’s not shown here…..
Food and service were excellent but portions could be a bit bigger….this is my 2nd visit and I intend to go back to Primehouse!

We went here for restaurant week, the food was great. We would love to return to explore the other menu options

Shabby was the greatest server!All his recommendations were excellent and his timing of the courses was spot on.We loved the crab cakes and the tomahawk ribeye was phenomemal.outstanding food and even better service.despite a very busy night

Everything was wonderful with the exception of the moth or insect that kept flying around me

Perfect for a date night.

I know we went restaurant week but, they rushed you thru the entire meal. When they took our appetizer dishes they took the bread plates bread basket. Not sure if they just wanted to turn tables over but I think that it is the kind of restaurant that you relax and enjoy your meal. They never asked if we wanted another drink (which took a long time, we had our appetizer before oour drinks. The food was very good but compared to the appetizer portion the entree was extremly small.Would I go back probably not

We went because it was restaurant week and we had never been. We were not disappointed. Great specials. We had the best waiter, Rob M. Took care of us with just the right amount of attention. We will definitely return.

The Prime House was wonderful from beginning to end! The restaurant is beautiful and the food was delicious! Highly recommend for a nice dinner!

I was extremely disappointed in my experience. For the prices, you would think there would be some sort of elevated service, quality of food, or ambiance. This was hardly the case. We were sat at a rickety old table which they fixed by shoving cardboard underneath, and there was food & trash all over the floors near our table. The food was subpar at best & I’m just thankful we did not spend a special occasion here and be disappointed… overall absolutely NOT worth the money. Will not be returning.

We made a reservation for my husbands birthday and we had a horrible table. They literally put the table in the middle of the walkway near by the door. The food was delicious and the drinks were great but knowing we were celebrating a birthday they could given more thought and consideration to the seating.

New for us to celebrate our anniversary. Our steaks were excellent. Bone-in ribeye was cooked perfectly and one of the best I ever had. Very active place but service was very good. We could have done without the dance tracks as background music.

Delicious mango sushi roll and mediterranean salad. The banana gelato is so yummy.
First time there but will definitely put this restaurant on my go-to list.

Food always delicious.

My husband and I are Garden City residents for 20 years. We have both been to Prime House on separate occasions. We decided to give Prime House a try for our date night this Friday. We both had a stressful week. We needed to forget the week we had and enjoy our evening and decompress. Prime House did just that. From the moment we walked in , the warm welcome, the escorting to our seats, the perfect selection of table. We both felt an immediate sigh of relief. It was going to meet our every expectation. And it did. Our waiter was attentive. The food was great. The rib eye was cooked to our liking. My extra dirty martini with blue cheese olives was the bomb. Date night with my hubby was fantastic . Thank you Prime House , we will be coming back.

we went for our 20th anniversary. I had made reservations with open table and stated it was our anniversary. when we got there we were greeted with happy Anniversary from the staff. shaber was our server and he was fantastic. He knew the menu inside out and was very knowledgeable abut literally everything on it. he was friendly and upbeat and just overall a super nice person. He made our experience wonderful. The food was also excellent. Our steaks were cooked perfectly to the temperature we ask for. everything we ordered was excellent. We had a wonderful time and we will definitely be getting back..

Primehouse is an amazing place to eat. the food was amazing. you have to try the spicy tuna nachos and Applewood smoke bacon. The service was impeccable. our waiter shabir was exceptional and elevates the experience to one that was truly special.

Our sever was absolutely amazing. we had a large group of 10 and were there at the height of dinner..... Iam so sorry that i did not catch his name he was from bangladesh.but he was so great with us and worked hard to make our experience a great one . Many thanks for a lovely night.

We waited over an hour for drinks. Our bill had items we didn’t order. Restaurant was not able to handle the amount of people. Terrible experience

Awesome place to eat. Everything is great . Definitely recommend

Food, drinks and service all excellent would go back and try brunch

Service was pretty bad. Manager comped a bottle of wine which was very sweet. 2 orders were wrong but we didn’t say anything because we were hungry. Overall manager tried to make it better which was nice but definitely not the best experience

It was a very enjoyable evening

from the moment we entered the service was outstanding. the young lady was clearing the glasses welcomed us. the host immediately confirmed our reservation and showed us to the our seats. shabir was an amazing server he made suggestions. patiently waited as we made decisions. the rest of the wait staff was attentive and pleasant. the food was pipping hot and delicious. we enjoyed our dining experience immensely.

reserved primehouse for my friend birthday on Sunday night and we were impressed with the ambience. food and service! we felt like royalty from the service provided by the staff! if I ever find myself visiting in garden city again. i will be sure to stop in to dine here again!

Food was perfect from start to finish. Had a comfortable booth table away from the crowd that made us all extremely happy.
The wait staff was impeccable and friendly. Price was a little steep but can’t say enough about the food so I’ll pay for what I received happily. Second time to this establishment and can’t wait to visit again soon.