Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY
*RESERVATIONS FOR "OUTDOOR TABLES" ARE FOR OUTDOOR TABLES*
Welcome back! The safety of our guests and staff remains our number one priority. We have recently installed a new Merv13 filter system that removes 85% of Covid particles to further insure a safe and healthy indoor dining experience!
Please note the following:
Reservations are required and must be made online or by calling. We currently can accommodate parties up to 6. Due to our limited waiting area, we have implemented a time restriction policy. Tables of 2 may stay for 90 minutes, tables of 3-6 may stay for 1 hour and 45 minutes. In accordance with government guidelines, you must wear a mask on site. We offer digital menus, contactless payment, disposable paper menus and single use condiments. Note we no longer serve shared items such as bread for the table.
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Contactless payment available
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
2 lb, steamed or broiled
Filet Mignon* **
filet mignon, mushroom duxelles, bordelaise, brie fondue, puff pastry
Steaks came out cold. They were cooked properly and were good cuts though. Food didn’t quite match up to the expense.
Service was solid.
Phenomenal food, views and service!!
We hit traffic on the way there and arrived after the grace time. Prime was still able to accommodate us, which we were grateful. From start to finish everything was great and delicious! We even had Mother Nature chipping in with a gorgeous sunset! Thank you!
Outstanding location, staff and food. Not a value by any means, but worth it for a special occasion as it never disappoints! The sushi rolls, steaks and lobster roll were big hits with out group. The desserts were wonderful and worth the indulgence
Go enjoy the views and wonderful staff.
Went out for our anniversary. Food is always good. Ate outside. Wish the weather was nicer. Michael was an outstanding waiter. Mistake was made on our appetizer. They brought us out extra. My only complaint is that they charge for bread. This used to be complimentary.
We were greeted by attentive young ladies and taken to a table immediately as we had a 4:45 reservation. Our server Julian O came right over introduced himself and made us feel very comfortable. Since we come to Prime on our anniversary June 13, every year we new the menu but he went out of his way to explain anything new and advised us of pricing and portion size for the two of us. We ordered crab legs on Julians recommendation. Outstanding and the beef Wellington also his recommend. Two glasses of champagne as a compliment was a great start and the dessert, Juniors cheesecake, Above and beyond. Thanks for a great experience.
Friendly place . Food is tasty and good in portions.
Wonderful outdoor experience. First rate service. Excellent food. Sushi rolls were a little average but all the other dishes were incredibly good.
We sat outside on the deck. Our food was delicious, the ambiance warm and inviting and the service was impeccable!
The view was stunning and loved the decor. But the food was terrible, incredibly salty and expensive. Would go back for drinks but not ordering $200 of bad food again let me tell you.
LOVE this restaurant have not had a bad meal here yet! The only thing I will say is when I booked my reservation there was no outdoor seating which was fine didn't matter either way but when we got there they did end up sitting us outside okay the dock is beautiful view but it was a chilly night if I would have known I would have brought a sweater and there should be heaters outside for nights like that also it did start to sprinkle a little I felt like people should have been on it and moving the umbrellas over to cover people.
We came for my fiancé’s 32nd birthday and it was perfect. The view is beautiful, montauk roll was delicious delicious, filet, brusselsprouts and mac & cheese, perfect! Matthew was great, awesome service. Perfect night out on the water.
Booked table inside. They put us outside and it started to drizzle and they told us we could leave and they would box up our food. they wouldn’t move us inside. Spent $320 to be eaten by bugs, drizzled on.
Will return. Their $24 lunch was wonderful. Beautiful, water front dining.
Prime is always a vibe, love coming here on a nice day - the ambiance is superb. Jonathan upheld a great level of service, and everyone else on the staff we came in contact with. Food and wine were good - we started with the spicy tuna roll, green salad, and hamachi crudo and followed with the burger, chicken sandwich and lobster roll. Everything was perfectly cooked and seasoned. It’s a staple for the friends and family, we will be back!
Food was made wrong, service was awful
This was our second time back to Prime. The first time I had left a not so good but fair review. I was then contacted by Michael Bohlsen, he sent a gift card to try Prime again. First of all, I was so impressed by that customer service! This second time... was excellent. The steaks (filet mignons) were cooked perfect and the sides (brussels sprouts and shoe string fries) were delicious! My husbands only complaint, is that we shouldn't be charged for bread...which I completely agree with. I think it is tacky, especially at an expensive steak house. It was a beautiful evening dinner on the patio. Everything was great. The staff, the service, our waitress, the food and atmosphere. It was a great dinner in a beautiful water front setting. It more than made up for our first dinner there. It was so kind of Mr. Bohlsen to do that. He truly stands behind his Restaurant.
Went for a 60th birthday celebration. The food, service and view were fantastic. Perfect for those special occasions.
Fantastic experience every time!
Very enjoyable—as always
Beautiful setting outside… great for a special occasion
The venue is in a beautiful setting. The food is expensive which one can expect but then it should be good
The lobster roll was measly, salmon was nothing special and the shaved asparagus was so overdressed with a vinegary substance it was inedible
They inform you a party of two has 1 hour 15 min
Why - so they can crank through more people
That is a huge turnoff and doesn’t line up with the price point for a relaxing experience
It was our wedding anniversary and we were well taken care of. Service wonderful, food delicious, just a delightful experience. Loved looking out at the harbor after dinner.
Perfect. A great meal.
An absolute gem on the North Shore of Long Island. One of the very few spots on the water and they execute at a very high level. The wine program is one of the finest on Long Island! Get the oysters!
Always a special dinner at Prime. In good weather, the view is spectacular. Waiters are friendly, yet professional. Prices are high, but the overall experience makes the expense worth it.
We were seated immediately since we had a reservation. Once seated, staff came to us and took our drink orders. I wanted to order some appetizers with the drinks, she said all food orders must be taken at the same time.....weird but fine... Got our drinks, ordered our food. Appetizers came really fast and waited about 20+ for our entrees. Steak came as is on the plate since the side are ordered and priced separately. Woman to gave us our steak had somewhat of an attitude and just rush the steak plate to us (kind of throwing it) maybe because the plate was hot? but it wasn't. My sister ordered her petit medium and halfway through it was rare... Oysters were great! Drinks are not refillable, so order with less ice.
Service was adequate. Didn’t see the server after we were served our food.
Michael was our server and they were very kind, thoughtful and mindful while we dined. All of the food was perfectly cooked and timed.
The food, service and dining experience were excellent! Prime never disappoints!
Birthday celebration ! They made the birthday special!
Great food, beautiful outdoor setting, good service. Pricey for lunch, but it's to be expected here.
The food and drinks were delicious but we were a bit taken aback when the waitress brought over two glasses of Prosecco for us, that we didn’t order, and then brought the check and stated “we discounted the Prosecco for you.” The waitress had asked what the occasion was earlier and we informed her it was our anniversary so when she brought the Prosecco she wished us a happy anniversary. Seems a little bit absurd to then charge us for it when we didn’t ask for it and we’d already ordered a pitcher of drinks, appetizers, and meals.
Our starters were outstanding. Salads and Burrata delicious! Steaks cooked perfectly! Love that they offered enhancements. We had the parmesan crust and truffle butter. The brussel sprouts and truffle fries are our faves! The Juniors Chocolate cake is a must!
Perfectly cooked steaks (& they know the subtle difference between medium & medium-rare!) , with superb service, at a beautiful waterfront location. What more could you ask for?
Food was good, place is nice, service could of been better, it took them 10 mins to bring water to our table on a hot day. The biggest problem was how hot it was in the restaurant, they need better air Conditioning!!! It was soooo hot in there.
You were out of Wings which I wanted for an appetizer but whatever we ate was great.
Outside was beautiful setting. We did have dinner inside because outside was not available. I believe the restaurant is overpriced, but nice experience.
Excellent service. Amazing food
We had a great anniversary dinner
Food is excellent/ ambiance is very good/ service is excellent
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY is rated 4.7 stars by 5681 OpenTable diners.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://shop.brgroup.biz.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.