Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar, Huntington, NY
Sunday : 11:30am - 2:30pm
Monday- Saturday: 11:30am-4pm
This is the first time I’ve been here in recent memory where they weren’t on their game
. Everything was just one off. It took them a while to seat us (6pm res) although not busy. Only 1 bread plate for a table for 2 . We ordered oysters (which were fresh and amazing) shrimp(1 was not great), crab meat cocktail (pretty tasty)tuna tartare( eh) sushi (pretty good) and a salad (very good) . Our server was nice , helpful,and efficient.
All in all underwhelming;which is highly unusual. Of course the view is a 10.
great food....great water front view...friendly, welcoming staff
fantastic place for a summer happy hour - watch the people and the boats go by
Rude valet parking lot manager. Our guests were 15 minutes late and they gave away our outside table . Waiter brought my order ,and my filet mignon rolled off the plate and onto the tablecloth. No apology from the waiter, he just turned and walked away.
Horrible inattentive service!!!!
Free desserts because of horrible service. No complaints made and they still knew how bad they were
Took a very long time to be seated despite having a reservation. Took almost an hour to receive our food.
Very good food but too expensive for us. My wife and I knew the prices going in, but we had a nice gift certificate to pay for a little more than half of our tab. The service was very good, and everyone one we interacted with was warm and friendly. We were greeted with "Happy Anniversary" when we checked in. I had noted it was our anniversary on my OpenTable reservation. The different staff that waited on us also wished us a happy anniversary. We really had a nice dinner, never felt rushed and we liked where we were seated. Overall it was a very nice special occasion experience.
What was outstanding about Prime were the service, quality of food, ambience. Our waiter, Ben, did an excellent job, and Kate, your maitre d' handled our reservation with class. While prime charges top prices, considering everything it was well worth the cost.
Beautiful atmosphere, but horrible service and beyond unaccommodating!
We were celebrating our 45th anniversary and wanted someplace with a view and exceptional food and service. Prime totally delivered. From the moment we arrived ,the hosted wished us a Happy Anniversary as did our servers. The food was exceptional. Very herd to find a beef Wellington on most restaurant menus and mine was perfection. The stuffed lobster with additional lump crab meat was delicious. Dessert was brought with a chocolate Happy Anniversary medallion on the plate and once again we were wished congratulations. Prime is the perfect venue to celebrate a special occasion and worth the price. As they say, you get what you pay for and definitely true for Prime. Would definitely recommend this venue.
A great atmosphere, great food and great service. You will not be disappointed
Never a disappointment. Great drinks. New oyster bar delicious. Service impeccable. Even The valets are a pleasure. Highly recommend. Worth the drive from anywhere.
A couple flaws with our orders but the service was provided with diligence. The food was delicious besides the lobster and lobster bisque we had. They accommodated my request of having a message written on a plate of dessert which I appreciated.
Thank you for making my daughter’s birthday very special! Most definitely come back.
Fabulous from start to finish. Excellent service & atmosphere
We really enjoyed our recent visit because we were accompanied by our 13 year old granddaughter.
Sarah loved her filet mignon! We enjoyed our dinners too. We cannot wait to return.
Jay, our server, was the best. His attentiveness was spot on yet never overbearing.
Food, service, wine, was absolutely perfect tonight. We all really enjoyed. Our favorite Huntington restaurant....we’ll always come back. Thanks again for a great night. The evening
Love this restaurant! Food is always creative and delicious. Our waiter Bist made my mom feel so special and was attentive. A++
On the pricey side. We only would go for special occasions. Outside seating was nice and bit cozy. We had filet mignon steak, which was made perfectly. It was crunchy outside and soft inside. The sides are big enough for two people. The aspergillus and wiped potatoes tasted great. We also loved the cheesecake. Sushi was typical and nothing special. Spicy margarita was good and not watered down. For the price it shouldn't be. Our waiter was super friendly.
First time for me and my partner. We definitely love it. great service
The steak was over cooked I was very unhappy. How can a steak house mess up steak??
Power lunch great for an early as afternoon treat. Grilled shrimp salad was delicious.
We had a simple but very nice lunch. The first two courses came out very quickly, but the main course took a while. Not a real problem. Service was very good and our service person was very personable. We enjoy coming here for lunch and will be back.
The view is amazing. The food is excellent but pricey. I would recommend the restaurant serve an entree with sides.
Shrimp cocktail was fresh and good size. The filet was cooked perfect. The service was “ok” and had room for improvement as we had to ask many times for drinks or other things
Surprised the service was lacking. Server difficult to understand. We sat for a long time before approached. I had bragged about my previous visits, this was embarrassing. The food was excellent. I asked for more rolls and the waiter said you must be finished with this. One roll remained. It was removed. . Will come again, but not happy with this visit. Others around us were getting more attention.
Birthday. They were so nice and gave my mom a card and gift certificate for her bday.
Great as always.
This was supposed to be a very special dinner for a special occasion. We were very disappointed with the service. Our server ( male Asian named Joe) greeted us and gave us our menus. His demeanor was that of a college frat boy. He came back a short time later and took our drink order. I asked him what the fish of the day was, so that I could decide on my dinner choice. He immediately stated “No I will let you know after I put your drink order in and I’ll go over all of that at the same time as other specials, when I come back”. I was simply apauled and embarrassed in front of my family and friends. First off, I couldn’t believe that he would speak to a customer like that and second just dismiss me. After he walked away, I reached for my water glass to take a sip and them put it down not realizing the table had a defect which caused my glass to spill completely on my husband. He attempted to get Joe’s attention, who was standing close by but he never came over. My husband had to wipe the table a chair himself as no staff in the area came over. Joe brings the drinks over and some were prepared incorrectly, (not a big deal) but waiter Joe gave us an attitude and basically took the rocks glass and just stained out the ice into a martini glass , instead of just getting a new drink. His service was extremely unprofessional and would not expect such a poor level of service in what is supposed to be an upscale establishment. Right down to the end of the night when he gave us drinks we did not order, half cups of coffee, and finally the wrong check.... We were very disappointed that our special occasion was ruined due to such below standards service!! Hope management addresses these issues.
Beautiful evening with a wonderful atmosphere and delicious food!
Went to watch the sun set while enjoying a good meal. The service (Bist was the waiter) was impeccable. The steaks were fantastic, along with the sides. The branzino, however, was inedible, hopefully just a one-off mistake.
Beautiful view but the way the table are set only one person can see it. Live band playing but noise level on the porch ( people so loud) couldn’t hear the music. Will go back but not sit on the porch again.
Delicious good but very expensive. Their steaks are fantastic, sushi melts in yourmouth, even the roasted chicken was great. This is a great place for special occasions and you need a reservation!
The food was great but a bit pricey for the portions you get. The waiter spilled a full glass of wine on my friend. He was covered in red wine from head to toe. I had to take my polo shirt off so he can wear it. The manager was made aware of the situation and she did the right thing by us. Would eat there again. 👍👌
Had oysters and steak...both very good...the double baked potato s a pile of cheese and sour cream on top of a half baked potato...soggy...drinks were good wine was reasonable. The bread is not crusty.
Excellent food and great atmosphere! Love the beef Wellington and the Brussel sprouts!
Overall I enjoyed my dinner with my family here. The pros are definitely the ambiance, the view and the service. The cons were some dishes (Montauk roll, beef Wellington and 2 lb lobster) were great and others (lobster shrimp wontons, filet mignon and creamed spinach) not so good. I guess I’d need to look at reviews more carefully next time before deciding what to order. Portions are ok and prices are a bit high.
Absolutely the best experience I’ve had there and I’ve had many, but our server Christian was on point from the beginning to the end. Personable, professional, completely knowledgeable and helpful with any questions we had on our order...Absolutely flawless. Will ask for him In the future for sure. We love this establishment, and it just keeps getting better! Ask him for his secret mashed potatoes, it won’t disappoint!
Dinner at Prime was delightfully wonderful - service was superb and the setting was perfect!
It was a wonderful dining experience on the porch. Our waiter was excellent being particular and attentive to one of us with a very specific allergy to food. Highly recommend the Power Lunch. Excellent value and large portions.
Yummy food and great ambiance. Staff was so nice! Went above and beyond to make my boyfriends 25th birthday incredibleeeee!