Prairie Star Restaurant & Winebar
Absolute lovely meal. The ravioli with squash is superb!
the dishes ordered were not of quality expected nor plated as one would expect. ordered the bacon wraped pheasant was tough and the larger breast cut was half raw was served in a bowl dish and glaze? or sauce was soupy into the napa cabbage and tasteless risotto not a good dish , my wife ordered the beef tenderloins cooked very well although very tough meat the side dishes fingerling potatoes and Brussels sprouts were literally black in color very unappetizing , however the wine choices is very extensive and difficult to choose but was the highlight of dinner
For the Wednesday special, everything was delicious and served just right, except dessert. We had warm bread to start, salad/soup, duck/lamb, and the squash pie. All were wonderful except the pie was cold. Would have been so much better warm with a dollop of whip cream or ice cream.
I was disappointed by the quality of the meal (both sides were barely warm). The dessert had come from what must have been directly from the freezer, it tasted like freezer and was extremely dry, we could not eat it. The server kindly removed the dessert from our bill. I was disappointed that we went there for our anniversary.
Our sincere apologies for your disappointment with your special evening at Prairie Star. The feedback has been shared with Chef Myles and the manager. I do hope you will respond to our private message. We would like to earn another opportunity for your business.
Prairie Star is one of my favorites. The current chef is awesome.
I've shared this with Chef Myles and it brought a big smile on his face. No better compliment for a chef than this! We are thrilled to have earned 'favorite' status and hope to see you again soon. Our sincere thanks!
Amazing food and service . This has become our special place to have our date night
What a pleasure to find such nice feedback! We are thrilled to have earned your 'special date night' status, and I have shared this with Chef Myles and the staff. Thank you so much! We will see you again soon!
Bobby was very cordial and efficient as were all the staff. Third time there and each has been a little better. Will definitely go back.
Thank you so much for taking time to leave a rating and feedback. We especially appreciate your thoughtful comments, and we hope you will visit again soon!
It was awesome! However what was supposed to be a quiet dinner romantic, turned out we got seated in the middle of a loud group party? But all else food was great and bar! We’ll be back again and again!!!
Thank you for the five star rating, and the very gracious feedback too. Most evenings you can count on a quiet dinner, and I'm disappointed your expectations didn't pan out that evening. But, so pleased the food was enough to save the evening! We appreciate you taking time to let us know and so grateful to hear you will be back.
Excellent food and service was very accommodating and professional, we weren’t rushed thru the meal and it was a very relaxing and delicious meal.
We are grateful to hear you enjoyed your evening at Prairie Star! I've shared your comments with Chef Myles and the staff. We appreciate you taking time to let us know we are meeting your expectations and do hope you will visit again soon!
Wednesday's "Wine two entrees; one shared dessert AND a good bottle of wine! The food is wonderfully prepared! And always delicious!!
On behalf of Chef Myles and the staff, thank you for the wonderful comments about the Wednesday Wine and Dine. The unique menu each week really allows Chef to utilize the best ingredients he carefully shops for. We really think it gives him a chance to shine, and is such a treat for the diners. Thank you again, and we hope to see you soon!
ended up with dinner on a night they were officially closed due to a number of big parties. in spite of that, we enjoyed great service and food and enjoyed an evening on the patio. great views. the shishito peppers and calamari were well cooked. the trout was well prepared, specialty steak and halibut were all great. lovely evening and felt special being the only ones to enjoy the beautiful views and good service.
Thank you for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience and our staff will definitely be happy to read what you wrote. We place customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the efforts of our entire staff. So thanks again for your kind words and we look forward to seeing you soon.
We've been many times but the Prairie Star has hit a low. Became sick from food after we left. Service seemed to be second string after a large holiday. Took very long to get food, which ultimately had some problems.
We were disappointed to find your feedback and thank you for bringing it to our attention. I hope that you will respond to our private message so we have the opportunity to further investigate your October 15th dinner.
We took our dear friends to enjoy a great meal!
Thank you so much for the five star rating! We appreciate you letting us know you enjoyed your evening with friends. On behalf of management and staff, thank you for choosing Prairie Star and we hope to see you again soon!
A wonderful dinner for our 25th anniversary. The beef tenderloin was excellent, as was the halibut. The peach crepe brûlée was heavenly and with the fabulous wine list we can always find a favorite.
Happy 25th! We really appreciate your kind comments, and have shared them with our team. On behalf of the entire staff, thank you! We are so grateful to find that you had such an enjoyable anniversary dinner at Prairie Star. Thank you for choosing Prairie Star for your very special celebration, and we hope you have occasion to visit again soon!
Wine glass cracked. Pesto pasta salty. Everything else fantastic. Can't wait to come back.
What a gracious way to leave a five star review! We love your attitude. I'm so pleased that everything turned out well--that you were able to take the glitches in stride & enjoy your dinner. I shared your feedback with management & Chef Myles, and accept their apologies for the pesto. Never be hesitant to let us know if we can replace a dish that doesn't meet your expectations. Again, thank you for your patronage & for realizing that 'things happen'. We do hope to see you again soon.
Birthday Dinner! Great food!
We really appreciate your kind comments, and have shared them with our staff and culinary team. Thank you on behalf of the entire staff. We are so grateful to find that you had such an enjoyable birthday dinner at Prairie Star, and pleased you chose Prairie Star for your very special celebration. Hope you have occasion to visit again soon!
My party arrived on time and was immediately seated. We had a magnificent view of the valley and the mountains. Our waitress/sommelier (Gerianne) was very knowledgeable about the available wines and which might be the best fit for each of us. We ordered our meals and were delighted with each of our meals. The meals were perfectly prepared and presented. Great wine, great food,great views, and great conversation with friends.! It doesn't get better than that!
I am so grateful to find that you had such an enjoyable evening at Prairie Star. We really appreciate your kind comments, and especially thankful that you mentioned Gerianne was instrumental in the success of your dinner with friends. I am sharing this with our team, and thank you on behalf of all. We are glad you chose Prairie Star also and hope you have occasion to visit again soon!
Nice restaurant .. food pretty good but not life changing
Thank you for taking time to submit your feedback. We appreciate your patronage!
Not good. Such a shame, beautiful view but unprofessional service and you really need to up your vegetarian game. My husband enjoyed the tenderloin.
We appreciate you taking time to share your feedback. I've shared your comments with Chef & management. I'm disappointed to hear you did not enjoy your dinner, but grateful your husband liked his tenderloin. The Fall menu is out soon & we hope you consider giving us another try. Chef has an Autumn Vegetable Trio | roasted butternut squash, organic mushroom risotto, three cheese stuffed poblano pepper, fried brussels sprouts, red chile oil , balsamic reduction & a new shiitake ravioli planned.
We moved from WA state and are used to wild salmon, looking forward to the Prairie Star salmon dinner. It was disappointing to find that "farm" salmon is used in a restaurant of your stature. The halibut dinner was excellent.
Thank you for taking time to submit your valuable feedback. I'm sorry to hear you were disappointed in the salmon, as freshness and quality are paramount to Chef Myles. The halibut is headed 'out of season' & will be coming off the menu in the next few weeks, so I'm glad you had a chance to enjoy that dish! Again, thank you for the review & for your patronage.
Wine Wednesday's are just wonderful. It is a great deal and the food is very good.
We are grateful to have you as a fan of the Wednesday Wine & Dine. It is so much fun for Chef Myles to create a unique menu each week, and it truly showcases the locally sourced ingredients he is able to procure. We appreciate the great review and hope to see you again soon!
We so looked forward t we’d wine and dine here. Made the reservation way in advance and enjoyed reading the weekly wed menus. Everything was great except the leg of lamb was not hot. Garrett -our server-was a champ and the desert chef was a knockout. Would definitely go back.
We are grateful to have you as a fan of the Wednesday Wine & Dine but disappointed to hear, though you enjoyed everything else, the lamb entree did not meet your expectations, nor ours. We appreciate your feedback on Garrett's service and your dessert. I do hope you will return soon, and please let us know what we can do to improve your experience.
We ate from the small plate menu. The items we tried were all very good to excellent. Our server Ally, was excellent. Very knowledgeable and attentive. She made very good suggestions. The only negative was the cocktails. The cocktail menu really needs some help. You can't have great food in a beautiful setting like this and have such a basic cocktail menu.
We are gratified to hear you enjoyed your evening with us, and thank you so much for the kind comments on Ally. On behalf of the staff and culinary team, we are pleased it was all to your liking. I have shared your nice comments with management and more importantly, pointed out your valuable feedback on the cocktail menu. It's good to receive realistic feedback that we can act upon and we thank you. We do hope to see you again soon!
Staff did a great job. The food was not seasoned well and a very limited menu
We really appreciate you taking time to share your feedback. I'm disappointed to hear you did not enjoy your food, but glad that our staff provided good service. Chef Myles will be bringing out the Fall menu soon and we hope you would consider giving us another try.
Perfect location to celebrate an anniversary. Chef Myles menu selection was exquisite.
We are honored you chose Prairie Star for your special evening. Thank you so much for the lovely comments and Happy Anniversary! I have shared your comment with Chef and he is appreciative as well. We would love you to return for your next anniversary, but more importantly, we hope to see you sooner!
The food, atmosphere, and music was fantastic. The service was terrible. We sat for 15 minutes before I had to get up and find someone in the bar area to take our drink order. Eventually the manager took our drink and food order. At that point we didn’t have a server assigned to us, so we were mostly forgotten. We loved the music and patio dining, though.
My apologies on behalf of management. I'm sorry the service marred an otherwise pleasant evening of music and dining. The Friday music evenings sometimes turn a little chaotic, and we definitely missed the mark. I have shared your valuable feedback and we will use it to improve. We appreciate your willingness to share your experience and hope you will give us another try in the future.
Mixed feelings about our visit here. Also, I hate the term 'microgreens.'
My husband got the beef tenderloin, and I had major food envy. He enjoyed his dish. I got the Alaskan halibut and I wish I hadn't. First of all, I guess the food runner was new and brought me the wrong plate - someone else's plate, who ordered halibut but had subbed the risotto for potatoes. I was really bummed because I was looking forward to the risotto and I had to track down a server to get a side of risotto; I did not want potatoes. Stuff happens, that's fine. My real problem was that everything on this dish was very lacking in flavor. The risotto and carrots were extremely bland and sad (I actually asked for salt, which I never do), and the whitefish was meh/fine. Everything was bland except the lemon vinaigrette - this was so bitter, salty, and honestly just gross. And I usually love all kinds of vinaigrette! I tried to scrap all of it i could off of the fish. The dish description for Pan Roasted Wild Alaskan Halibut is: fresh fava bean risotto • tri-color baby carrots • fermented lemon vinaigrette • local microgreens. When I asked the server where the greens were, he explained that microgreens was just a reference to the seasoning on the whitefish. Yeah, that is really their explanation.
Ugh, whatever. Look, if I'm paying over $30 for a plate and I order a nice wine with it, I know it's not a five star, crazy elite place but I expect to at least enjoy my meal. I hated this dish and ate what I could because I was hungry and we had a show to get to.
The shining star and redemption was the service. All the servers were really professional and kind - and I know the food taste is not their fault. They were aware that I didn't enjoy my dish and they brought us a dessert on the house to make up for it.
There are so many restaurants with really consistently great tasting food, I don't know that we'll come back and gamble with the quality/taste here.
We appreciate you letting us know about your evening and are disappointed your halibut dinner was unappealing. Sounds like we dropped the ball & were out of the green sprout garnish. I'm also disappointed that time limited your returning the dish for one you could enjoy. Your comments have been shared with Chef and management. Thank you for the kind comment on the service staff. We are sorry to miss your expectations, and we hope you will consider returning in the future.
We love the Wine and Dine at Prairie Star. Consistently good food and service. Ally was our waitperson and she is fantastic!
Thank you so much for your five star rating! So glad to find you are a fan of the Wednesday Wine & Dine. Those unique weekly menus really give Chef Myles a chance to shine with the fresh seasonal and local ingredients he purchases on a week-to-week basis. We especially thank you for your recommendation of Ally. We love to hear that our staff was able to make your evening even more enjoyable. We hope to see you again soon!
Really like the vibe
Thank you so much for taking time to review your evening at Prairie Star! We hope to see you again soon.
Patio was empty so we sat outside for a drink. Literally every table was dirty from the night before. Eventually moved inside for dinner and there were cobwebs all over the ceiling. Our poor server was the only server on staff working at least 6 tables spread all over the restaurant making for very slow service. Food was very dry and average at best. The whole place was just out of touch and out of date. Nothing like it was in its glory days.
We are so disappointed to read your experience at Prairie Star. It isn't in any way up to our standards and certainly not what you expected of us. Your valuable comments have been shared with management and researched in order to make certain the issues are all addressed in a formal manner. We depend on 'outside eyes' to help us do better. We extend our heartfelt apologies and hope you will consider giving us another chance.
The food was okay, but not on par with the atmosphere and pricing. It was the second time we have tried the star and it's menu seeks to aspire for something that seems out of reach of the current chef. Mac and cheese from couscous falls short of what a true lover of mac and cheese desires. The ravioli was just okay. The steak was good, but overall the menu underwhelms. The server was as nice/pleasant as we've ever had but the service was very slow and I was never asked how I enjoyed my steak until long after I had finished it as an example. The dessert of cheesecake was a sliver and presentation that was forgettable and came from a frozen package.
We were disappointed to read that you did not enjoy your evening with us. Your feedback has been shared with Executive Chef Myles and the manager. We do hope you will consider giving us another chance. The new winter menu will be out soon and we would hope you would find it more satisfying to your taste.
Food was very good; service was good; quiet atmosphere; they helped us celebrate our 55th anniversary which we appreciated with some nice desserts.
We are so honored you chose Prairie Star for your special evening! Bravo on the 55 years of marriage, quite an milestone. I'm glad you enjoyed your evening, and don't wait for a special occasion to return!
Always good food and a quiet atmosphere, it is a pleasure to dine at Prairie Star.
We appreciate your very nice rating and comments. We appreciate you and hope to see you again soon!
The service was good, though I'd like to see a few less tattoos on my server. Call me old fashioned, but it distracts from what the server's attempting to do for me. Great attitude and good service, though.
The food was the biggest disappointment. Though my steak was of high quality, it was cooked medium when I ordered medium rare. The potatoes were hardly seasoned. The asparagus was far too thick and woody. My wife's salmon was overcooked to the point that it was actually dry, which is hard to do with salmon. The rice was a strange decision for a pairing. I just didn't get what they're trying to do, I guess. I think you need to find a better executive chef.
On behalf of Executive Chef Myles and management, we are disappointed to learn you did not enjoy your meal. We hope you will consider giving us another try in the future and appreciate that you took time to let us know about your evening.
Perfect evening. Haven’t eaten there in years and it was just as I remembered. Excellent service by Jennifer. Food too, and being able to sit outside on the golf course and view the mountains, especially as the sun went down, was superb. New Mexico at its best
We love hearing 'perfect evening'! Thank you so much for taking time to leave such kind comments, and we will let Jennifer know she helped make your evening! We hope you will be dining with us again soon.
Great value at Prairie Star on Wed w/WIne & Dine option.
Loved watching the hummingbirds zip around as you look at the awesome view of the mountains to the east! Summer will be gone before we know it, so we plan on getting out there and checking this patio out in the next several months!
Thank you so much for your kind comments and we are pleased you enjoy the Wednesday Wine & Dine. The 10th Anniversary of the promotion is coming up next week! Needless to say, it has been a very popular choice for our diners. Thank you for mentioning the hummingbirds and glad you enjoy watching them. We have used 200lbs. of sugar this year since they showed up on April 16! They will be leaving in the next few weeks, but we hope to see you again soon.
My experience was very disappointing, for a resturant of this reputation. I and 2 friends went there on a Tuesday (Aug 27th). We were seated at 6:45 but our meals weren't served until 8 pm. I ordered one of their "signature dishes", the rack of lamb, which was comically undercooked, a small portion, and didn't include some of the things mentioned on the menu. Our waiter was missing in action.
We were disappointed to learn that your evening did not meet your expectations, nor ours. We have taken steps to identify the cause of the issues and hope you will consider giving us another chance in the future. Our sincere apologies that we missed the mark.
It was a very pleasant evening, our 54th anniversary. The view, service and food were excellent.
Bravo and Happy Anniversary! 54 years is quite an achievement! We really appreciate you choosing Prairie Star for your special evening. I'm so glad you had a memorable dinner and we hope to see you again soon!
The only reluctance in writing this review is that more people will find out what a great place this is . The wait staff is excellent, food delicious, ambience relaxed . This was our third time there this summer and can't wait to go again. Keep up the great work but don't tell too many people.
I can't think of a better recommendation! Thank you so much for the awesome compliments and your comments are being shared with the staff. We appreciate you! See you soon.
The venue is gorgeous, the view is amazing, and the staff are very friendly. Our food was over cooked and we had marginal service. One young woman, apparently under the impression were done with our meal, started clearing our table asking if I was finished with my drink. When I told her we hadn’t even had our main course yet she apologized and scurried away. It was still quite awhile before our food arrived after that. I doubt we will go back.
We appreciate you taking time to leave your feedback and it has been shared with management. I'm disappointed that your evening was not what you, or management, expects. We do sometimes miss the mark, and hope that you will give us another try in the future.