Prairie Fire Pie
Great food and cocktails! Wonderful ambiance! Our server was outstanding! Can’t wait to go back!
Best pizza in town! Great lasagna on Thursdays as well.
Thanks for your feedback Randy! We are so glad that you enjoy our pizza and lasagna. (*Lasagna Nite every Thursday) We truly appreciate your kind words and hope to see you back soon.
Legitimately one of the best pizza’s I have ever had. We will definitely be back.
We made reservations for my friend’s birthday on Valentines Day for 4 people. We waited for an hour after our reservation before we were seated. They seat multiple parties at the same table. Overall, the food for the price was decent. I’m hoping the wait was just because it was Valentine’s Day. Also when we asked the hostess what the problem was she said her manager basically told her to suck it up. The manager never did come speak to us or our table. I thought that was extremely unprofessional. Our waitress was very nice though. The food was decent.
Thank you for the wonderful review despite having to wait so long for your reservation! You would be correct that it was due to people lingering longer than expected on Valentine's Day. Though we are glad that people were enjoying themselves, I am sorry that you had to wait. Please send me you mailing address through OpenTable so I can treat you to a pizza on me for your patience and understanding. Truly appreciate your feedback. Cheers-Chef James
We had the meatball pizza and the mushroom pizza. Two words, so good!
We appreciate the four star review, thank you! We hope to see you back soon.
Best Pizza in Tulsa. Crust is made with extra care and love! Creative toppings. Don't skip the cauliflower appetizer.
Thank you for the feedback Jeff, we agree but are a little biased. :) We hope to see you back soon!
Group of six enjoyed drinks and pizza, fun atmospere
Thank you for joining us and we are so glad that you enjoyed everything! It is why we do what we do and love to hear when we are doing it right. Hope to see you back soon.
Very good meal, have already recommended to several friends...
Thank you for your feedback Steve, and your endorsement to your friends. We hope to see you again soon!
Fabulous all around! We had the wings, pizza, lasagna, limoncello cocktails and beer; we will return.
Thank you for the feedback Courtney, we are so glad that you enjoyed everything and we look forward to your next visit! See you soon.
Great food. We had a big party and service was great! Pizza is amazing and salads were fresh and crisp
Thank you for your feedback, we are so glad that you liked everything and hope to see you back soon.
Enjoyed our experience - staff friendly. Enjoyed the mushroom/onion pizza but was disappointed with the chicken pizza, as it was bland. The pepper sauces did help the chicken, give it some zing.
Hi Judith, thank you for your feedback. We appreciate the candid feedback because it helps us to make those little improvements that make everyone's experience better. Thank you again for your comments and we hope to see you back soon. Cheers-Chef James
We love prairie fire pies, great appetizers, the baby kale salad is a favorite and the pizzas are delicious every time.
Thank you for taking the time to review us, it is always nice to hear that we are doing a good job! Thanks again.
It’s our place to go in Tulsa, always great food and great service
Thank you for your review Andy, we strive for the best experience for our guests and are so glad that you enjoyed both the food and service. Hope to see you back soon.
My husband and I were very excited to try PFP, it's been on our list of restaurants to try since it opened. When we walked in, there wasn't anyone to greet us...for a long time, to the point we started walking around looking for someone. There was one bartender that didn't greet us and a staff in the kitchen but that was it. We decided to eat at the bar and every person that walked in after us had the same experience. They were wondering around trying to figure out what to do. It's a very small space, which I like, so it's very uncomfortable not knowing where to go or if you will be attended to. Our food was really good but customer service was definitely lacking which is why we probably won't go back.
Thank you for the review, we appreciate the feedback. I will pass your compliments on to the kitchen, I know that they will appreciate it. Hope to see you back soon.
We enjoyed sitting comfortably at the bar. The atmosphere is an uncluttered and modern open concept. Service was prompt and unobtrusive, professional. The meatballs were delicious, the fontina cheese app was the real deal, and the pizza was hot and delicious. I like that the crust was flavorful and not too thick. The cocktail menu was fun, too! We will be back!
Thank you for the feedback, we appreciate you taking the time to review us. Our crust is slow fermented (48hours) to give it outstanding flavor, so glad you appreciated it. I will definitely relay your comments to the kitchen, they work very hard to make sure you have great food. Again we appreciate your comments and hope to see you back soon!
Love it, my husband and I had a great time the appetizer and the pizza were amazing
Thank you for your feedback, we are always striving for an amazing experience and are so glad that we hit the mark for you! Hope to see you again soon.
Everything on the menu is amazing but the lasagna is struck the star!
Thank you for your review, we appreciate the feedback. Lasagna night (Thursdays) have become quite a hit, and we are glad that you enjoyed it. Come back and see us soon!
Best pizza in town!
Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate it. The kitchen works very hard to ensure you are getting the best product and I will certainly let them know they are doing a great job. We hope to see you back soon!
The restaurant is much smaller than Open Table and Yelp photos suggest. We sat at a long table designed for eight. We were a group of four, so we were placed with another group of four (which contained skateboarder/actor/photographer Jason Lee). Each group’s conversation kept to itself. We were not having to talk over the others at the table or surrounding tables.
The fontina and charcuterie appetizers were good, not great. The pizza was really good. We settled on two pizzas and had half of each was a different style. We had one red sauce with 1/2 cheese, 1/2 pepperoni and one white sauce 1/2 Oregon mushroom, 1/2 potato & egg. All were really good.
Thank you for your review. Your feedback allows us to make adjustments and makes us better for your next visit. I appreciate the detailed descriptions and we are glad that you enjoyed yourself, and your table company. :) Hope to see you again soon.
Pizza crust was perfect for my preference; lightly crispy, but not like a cracker. The Sauces were delicious. Staff was attentive, and the food was on the table without delay. My co-diner enjoyed several extraordinary cocktails.
Thank you for your review. We appreciate the detailed feedback which lets us know what we are doing right, and what we could improve upon. We hope to see you again soon.
We had a great time! Our pizza was wonderful ;) we will be back again
NYE with the family. Great experience.
Had Baby kale salad, Pepperoni & Oregon mushroom pizza, and Tiramisu mousse. It was all amazing!!
This is my favorite pizza place in Tulsa right now. And I adore pizza so that’s saying a lot! Their crust is EVERYTHING- it’s just so good! My husband loves their local (and affordable) beer list! Also, the fontina cheese appetizer and their homemade limoncello- absolutely wonderful! Love this little spot and we’re already looking forward to going back!
I really inventive wood-fired pizza restaurant. Service is really good and everyone loved the pizza he/she ordered.
Prairie Fire Pie does offer delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. Prairie Fire Pie also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (918) 895-8725.
Prairie Fire Pie is rated 4.7 stars by 26 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.