Permanently Closed - POMONA NYC
Get it delivered
We made the reservation three weeks before. On the night of reservation we showed up only to find out that the restaurant is closed for a private event. They should have given us the courtesy of letting us know that they are not able to honor the reservation but they didn't.
NO NO NO !!!!
Made a reservation for dinner for 5. Came to Restaurant on time only to find it C L O S E D !!
NO Note on Door.. just CLOSED... Spoke to a building representative and was told they were "Closed for
Summer". Bad bad show.... Paid for parking and a nice night out. Restaurant NEVER called us to tell us that Reservation was useless so found ourselves outside on a rainy night in Mid-town NYC with no reservation for dinner. Well done restaurant owners!! Sad story...
Made a reservation for 4. Had 2 Pulsd vouchers. Restaurant allegedly “closed for the summer” but they never notified me. Showed up for my reservation, the doors were locked, and no one answers the phone.
went there sat nite and the restaurant was closed for a private party. they didnt call me to say the restaurant was closed and so we wasted money going in for no reason.
I brought my husband and three teenage boys to NYC for their first visit. I had made a late-night reservation for after the Part 1 performance of Harry Potter. We took an Uber to the restaurant only to find that it was closed...so much for having a reservation. We never got an email, a text, nor a phone call. It was very disappointing.
I took my boyfriend to Pomona for his birthday. The staff was warm and friendly, the food was great and we had a good time.
Pomona is the best new resturant in manhattan its cozy chic wonderful service fabulous people and friendly staff
I highly recommend Pomona to everyone.
And when you finish dining enjoy the lounge downstairs for after hour fun.. I look forward to dining again real soon
The food and service was outstanding. I was really impressed all around. After we finished our meals we all had desserts that were out of this world. Sometimes we like to go out just for dessert and coffee and now we know exactly were we will be going, Pomona! We will be going back very soon even if it's just for a few drinks at the bar or for DESSERT!
First off the waiter didn’t know the menu at all... Then it’s my anniversary night and the manager comes and sits with some patrons literally right next to us picking at a plate of food..how rude...To top it off we had to wait another 15 mins to leave because the computer shut down not to mention it took 20 mins for someone to ask us if we were done and wanted dessert. Not good at all...
Very nice location and ambiance. Could talk easily. Good wine list. Delightful waiter. The halibut dish is out if this world!
I had the wonder chance to celebrate my birthday at Pomona and Savage Lounge. The whole staff was so accommodating, kind and professional from the moment I was greeted by security and the beautiful Hostess to the moment we left. My friends continue to rave about how incredible the food was. I was ecstatic when they paraded to our table with sparklers and the strawberry rhubarb sundae singing “Happy Birthday!” to me! It was nice to have something so special rather than the typical cake. Every bite, from the baked clams to the house made marshmallows in the sundae can without a doubt send you to food heaven! After dinner my whole group was escorted to Savage lounge in the back of the restaurant where we were setup at cozy table. The energy was high and the music kept us on our feet for hours! I would highly recommend to everyone! Thank you EVERYONE at Pomona and Savage Lounge for such an incredible night! ❤️❤️❤️
The atmosphere in the restaurant was enchanting and the music was very good and modern. Lighting was perfect and it gave you a good feeling. The food was delicious 10/10 would recommend!
Tried the Mac and cheese and it was delicious. Tuna tartar was so good only problem was didn’t have enough chips but my waiter was so kind and got me another batch!
The food was fabulous from the starters to the entrees. The drinks were great and did not skimp on the alcohol. Each person at my table had something different to drink and I even asked the bartender to create something not on the menu and was pleased. I will say the portion sizes are tiny! My table was grateful for the appetizers because although the entrees were delicious, they were gone in minutes because there was so little there. I had the lobster fettuccine and joked that there were four strands of pasta. Overall, wonderful restaurant and highly recommended!
Excellent food! Definitely coming back to check out the lounge after a nice dinner!!
Great food, great atmosphere. Definitely coming back with more people. Thank you!
Very nice place and food. A very quiet place, ideal for a romantic dinner!
The food was NOT good. Shrimp was over cooked! The steak hs too much pepper! The decanter has a hole and wine spilled everywhere. We were given another bottle, but what a mess!
They do not have black napkins so they gave me cocktail napkins to put on my lap..smh. There were not many people, actually it was just us and yet I had to pour our wine. Eventually, they realized and handle it accordingly! It was an expensive dinner, wine was great!! We ended up eating someplace else, later in the evening. #dissapointed
Simple ingredients well prepared and subtley delicious food. Attentive service, quiet ambience. A pleasurable dining experience in an attractive low key venue.
Great Place!! Food was delicious! my friend wanted more of her pasta and my Salmon was so tasty!
The lounge was fabulous!! Sexy decor, Beautiful people, I will definitely be back!!!
I love restaurants where management cares and makes sure everything is going well!
Great restaurant. The food is amazing. Chef Marc is so creative. Everything on the menu is delicious. Derek and staff are so efficient and professional. Love this place.
The service was nice, however food quality, ambiance, and value was significantly lacking. Really unfortunate if you know to compare against Beautique
Extremely underwhelming dinner location near the Plaza/Central Park area of NYC. I assume most individuals who dine at this establishment are not interested good service or a fun experience. The majority of employees were stand-offish and rude.
There are hundreds of dinner options in NYC -- Strongly recommend avoiding this one.
Eric, Thank you for taking the time to send us your honest feedback. I am so sorry to hear your experience with us was anything less than perfect. I would love to speak with you personally about your visit and where we could have been better. Please feel free to reach out to me directly at (212)753-1200. I hope you had a wonderful holiday season, Leigh
Steak overcooked and lobster app was not good. Was loud as well. Carmen our waitress was amazing!
Thank you for taking the time to give us feedback. We take honest comments from our guests very seriously as we are always looking to improve. I am thrilled to hear that Carmen took great care of you! We always try to do our best and hope that you will let us prove this to you during your next visit! Happy New Year! Leigh
Every dish was absolutely wonderful. The service could not have been better. Only downside was that the prices were a bit high, given the relatively small portions.
I cannot stress how AMAZING our experience was, they were so so nice, every single staff person, and accommodated my mother by bringing up a table from downstairs because she couldn’t use the stairs. I don’t know any restaurant in NYC that would do something like this. THANK YOU, a million times over, for making our night! And... the food was DELICIOUS. EXCELLENT EXCELLENT EXCELLENT!
Cnem, Thank you so much for the kind words. It was our pleasure to have you and your mom dine with us. Please feel free to reach out to me directly should you ever want to join us again. We would be thrilled to have you, any time! Happy Holidays!! Leigh 212-753-1200
Great meal - the space is from a bygone era but enjoyed the meal and we had excellent service.
First try of this new spot and really enjoyed our meal. Food was high level.
Our waiter was rude and ignored us for 25 minutes before allowing us an opportunity to get a drink order in. Food was good, a little pricey for what it is, but definitely delicious. The restaurant was half empty and was blasting club music which I thought was a bit odd. However, the quality of the food made up for the few downsides. The filet was outstanding, drinks are unique and delicious, and baked alaska is great and comes with a "show" if you enjoy your food being set on fire!
Dear Elizabeth, Thank you for taking the time to give us feedback. We take honest comments from our guests very seriously. I am so sorry to hear your experience with us was anything but perfect. We always try to do our best & hope you will let us prove this to you during your next visit. I am glad to hear you enjoyed your meal. Please feel free to reach out to me directly should you like to join us again. I hope you have a wonderful holiday season! Leigh Kodzoman leighk@pomonanyc
From the moment we arrived, we felt like honored guests. The staff is friendly and professional, and we felt especially-well-taken-care-of by our server, Stacey. The dining room is spacious and attractive, the lighting just right, and the music isn't too loud. The food was very good, especially the Caesar salad, and (surprise!) the bread and butter served before the meal was truly superb. We shared three small plates and had the seafood stew for two. The stew was good but a little bland... but thankfully not-at-all over-salted, which we both appreciated. Best of all, though, was the service. We look forward to returning.
We are beyond thrilled that you enjoyed your time with us & we love hearing about our guests' favorite dishes! Thanks so much for taking the time to write us. We look forward to seeing you again very soon. Happy Holidays!! Leigh
We ate there and enjoyed it so much, we went back the next night! Great staff and so attentive all the way around! Food was delicious.
Lisa, Thank you so much for taking the time to send us feedback. We love that you joined us 2 nights in a row! We hope to welcome you back again soon. Happy Holidays! Leigh
For only being open for 5 weeks this place hit all the marks. Exceptional food and service. Would go back anytime I’m in town
Thank you for your kind words. We would be thrilled to welcome you back the next time you're in town. Please feel free to reach out to me directly the next time you would like to join us. Happy Holidays! Leigh 212-753-1200
Great food and service!
Thank you for the kind words, Tim! Happy Holidays! Leigh
Overall great. Not fantastic and pricey. Quiet around 6pm on a Saturday.
Loved the vibe and atmosphere
Food was really really good.
The mushroom/chestnut soup was to die for
The turkey dinner left me stuffed and it was like being at home
The mashed potatoes were fantastic
The pecan/cranberry tart was just enough n not overly sweet at all
Thank you Chef Michael, Raschid and Alex for making me feel like I wasn’t celebrating Thanksgiving alone
I’ll be back!
Diana, Thank you so much for joining us on our first Thanksgiving celebration! We love hearing about the dishes that our guests' enjoyed the most. Looking forward to seeing you again soon! Happy Holidays! Leigh
This was only the restaurant’s second week in operation, but they definitely have it together. Impeccable service, perfectly presented cuisine, and a warm welcoming ambiance all come together to make for a great dining experience.
Our waiter Mathew had an in-depth knowledge of the menu and wines, which is really a testament to the chef’s rapport with the staff when you think about it.
Scott, Thank you for the kind words. We are so proud of our staff and all of their hard work and will certainly share your sentiments with them. We are looking forward to serving you again soon. Happy Holidays! Leigh
This gem came up on Open table and we're glad we went. The atmosphere is comfortably familiar with a modern twist. The service was great, attentive, professional, knowledgable. The food was exquisitely prepared and elegantly presented. There are vegetarian offerings as well as steak and other proteins. Each item we were served was truly delicious. Make sure you try the duck fat tater tots and cocktail shrimp. Two drawbacks...there is no disabled access and it was very dark in spots, including our table. A small light on each table, a battery operated candle for example, would have been most welcomed. We had to use our phones to read the menu. Awkward. Bathrooms are beautiful.
Thank you for taking the time out of your day to write to us. We're really proud of our staff and all of their hard work. We're happy they could exceed your expectations & will certainly let them know!
Terrific new spot. A lucky find. Great food, genial hosts, just right music. Can't wait to share with more friends. Come now while toy can still get in!
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. We're so happy to see that you enjoyed your time with us. Looking forward to having you back soon!
Could not have been more pleased. Gracious welcome, meal delicious especially the four gras slider and the duck burger. Telling all my friends!!!! Very special?
Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a kind review! We love hearing about our guests' favorite dishes.
Permanently Closed - POMONA NYC is rated 3.9 stars by 42 OpenTable diners.