We enjoyed the food, everything tasted fresh, well priced, great service.

Excellent food, service, and value!!

server’s not get attention for our table.
indoor temperature was cold

The food was tastefully presented and well prepared. The service was most attentive. It was a most pleasant dining experience.

Good food and great service. We had a lovely time. Plenty of room between tables

The service is always top notch. All the food made from scratch. Always delicious.

Excellent dinner, service.

We had a wonderful pasta appetizer with grilled octopus. It was fantastic.

Always our favorite. Wonderful food and amazing service!

Wonderful dinner!

Experience was great! The food was so good .. I definitely wanted to go back again!

Abbiamo preso i calamari fritti,ma non sono stati cucinati bene,poi i primi erano cotti bene,ma c era un uso spropositato di aglio,tritato ovunque,è un peccato perché potrebbe meritare molto di più,lo chef non è italiano sicuramente visto quanto aglio usa

Good Atmosphere and friendly service. Good food with reasonable price

Great little Upper West Side Italian restaurant. Manager and staff were very attentive and the food was great. Really loved the cheesecake for dessert!

Excellent. Wonderful experience!

Excellent food , great Christmas dinner!! I recommend

Excellent as always.

Excellent food and service; never disappoints!

great great great

Since we are regulars, Peter and his staff are extra nice to us! The food is always prepared to our liking and we always enjoy eating here! Their wine list is adequate and we always buy a nice red wine with dinner! I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the neighborhood!!

Met up with some relatives for dinner, and it was a great choice. Ambiance was very nice, with tables spread apart for comfort and safety. Everyone loved the food (I had a seafood pasta special which was terrific; my cousin said his filet mignon was excellent) and the desserts were yummy! My only objection was the prices, the bill seemed a bit high.

I came a little bit earlier than my reservation but they still were able to seat me right away. From the moment I sat down until the end of my time, I had a blast. It was just me before heading to The Nutcracker but it was a highlight of my day. The sangria was amazing, the Parmigiano was on point, the waiters (not even just mine) made sure I had everything that I needed for my meal, and the host knew my name.
10 out of 10 will definitely come back to Pomodoro Rosso.

Excellent outdoor dining experience. Great food and attentive service. Heated covered outdoor seats

Service was outstanding. Food was excellent, but the attentive service was far beyond what is normally found. Will be going back.

Also, many great choices on the menu, so want to try a few more items.

Sadly, no one seems to be checking on things in the kitchen. Both fish dishes were overcooked, to the point where the snapper special ($35?!) was grey and tough and the salmon (also pricey) was just tough and bad tasting. The service, as always, is efficient and polite; the welcome is warm; the ambience is nice, especially for Covid-era, and we just wish the food was as good as it needs to be for a return visit.

Long wait for the food - but it was delicious as always!

Excellent meal! The pasta was perfectly cooked and the chick parm was outstanding. Service was attentive and warm. We will be back!

Everything was really good except the veal which was very dry. My friends' meals were perfectly fine

Food was very very delicious. Specially we love pizzas. Pasta dishes were excellent also. Service was very attentive. We would happily go back there and recommend highly

We went to Pomodoro last evening with friends which was the first time in the Covid era. Although we’ve been there many times and always enjoyed a wonderful meal, we were a bit skeptical given the challenges that NYC restaurants have had during the pandemic.
We were so pleased to see that Pomodoro is as good as ever! Bravo!
The food was excellent and the service was timely and gracious. Could not be happier that this old favorite is thriving and continuing to be a wonderful place to enjoy an evening out!

I enjoyed dining here last night. The food was excellent as was the service. The outdoor dining was well ventilated and heated in the portion right in front of the restaurant although it was not well ventilated in the portion set off from the restaurant. We were able to move to the more ventilated portion which was fortunate since the are we were originally seated at did not feel safe to me. I would advice that a way be found to provide more open air ventilation to the other section as well for those of us not willing to die just to get a good meal.

Great food, great service, good prices-what’s not to love?!!!

Great food, great service. Friendly environment

As always, food and service is amazing. I truly enjoy dining here.

The food and service was excellent. The manager was very visible and kept everything running well between the outdoor and indoor dining. We went for pizza but will definitely be back for their finer entrees.

Delicious! Can’t believe this restaurant has been in the neighborhood so long and so have I, yet this is my first time here! It is a “new” favorite.

I highly recommend the veal stew and pasta. Exceptional.

Lovely dinner as the food was delicious, atmosphere pleasant and safe and service was truly outstanding. Thank you.

Good neighborhood restaurant where indoor dining is especially nice now with gauzy curtains separating the tables and careful checking of vaccination cards. I just wish they would not overcook the seafood in the papardelle with seafood--the lobster was dry and tasteless, and the shrimp was small and mushy. For over $30, this just isn't careful cooking or caring purchase of ingredients. Warm, caring service, and good sauces on the pasta.

Not my first time here and it is always excellent! Thank you! Attentive friendly staff, delicious food, wonderul ambiance.

Charming place!