Celebrated granddaughter’s birthday with a party of 6. The wait staff couldn’t have been nicer! The manager went out of her way to make the dinner special! My granddaughter said it was the best birthday dinner ever! We are very appreciative to the folks at Pomodorino Rosso and highly, highly recommend it to anyone!
Wonderful staff, service and excellent food!!
Just dinner with friends
Great neighborhood place.
Food was good but there was a weird smell in the bar.
Food was great and the service even better. Highly recommend!!!
The restaurant was very good, we had excellent meals. The service was a little slow, but it wasn’t the waitress’s fault, it looked like there was only one waitress for the entire front of the restaurant.
Great service and food.
Everything was awesome as usual!
My favorite restaurant!
Food and service were terrific.
Always friendly service and very good food.
Local for us which is a real plus!
Extensive wine and drinks menu but food menu is limited.That being said the food is fantastic and so was service.
Treated well-even turned down air conditioning til it filled up.
Food very good-prices have increased though.
Great local place!
Normally we love, doing Arosa it’s one of our favorite spots last night unfortunately it was not my first Cosmo for $16 was not good second one there was an improvement my chicken cutlet Parmesan was tuff. my husband steak was tiny and my mothers shrimp and Alfredo sauce was very small and tasteless this is very unusual $192 before tip for this meal was definitely not worth it what a sad disappointment
We always enjoy eating there. It we especially enjoyed the outdoor dining tonight.
This is a great neighborhood gem. Food is always well prepared, scallops I ordered were cooked to perfection. I highly recommend.
Food quality very good with the exception of the shrimp in the "Risotto Giorno" which had an iodine flavor. Noise level very high.
The food and service were great (Anthony and the rest of the dtaff were frita d very attentive!)
The only criticism I would give is that the background music was loud and not appropriate for dinner. (Rap music, really?)
You can never go wrong with the nightly specials that Antonio puts out.
We were all satisfied with our meals. I had the branzino stuffed with shrimp and crispy vegetables with a brandy sauce. So good!
It has been a little bit since we've visited but glad we made this our choice for dinner. Great atmosphere and ownership is very attentive to the client base. We were a party of 4 and everyone loved their meals....For me the Connecticut lobster roll can't be beat....scrumptously buttery and fresh. Looking forward to our next visit.
The food here is fantastic. Had a baked clam appetizer and the halibut entree and both were excellent. The atmosphere is warm and friendly.
Food always delicious but last night service was awful. After waiting 45 minutes for a waiter we had to ask for one to even take our drink order. Waited a long time for our dinner. No one refilled water and our waiter never checked on us or explained the delay.
Antonio keeps coming through with fresh and great tasting dishes.
Food wasn’t that good and it took forever to get the food. I would never go back and not recommend this place. Horrible.
Food was great but waiting 90 minutes for an appetizer and over 2 hours for the entree is too much. We were compensated with 2 free bottles of wine which was very fair. I'll definitely go back because of the food and the way management handled the long wait.
I gave Pomodorino Rosso a fantastic review for last Sunday evening. Everything was so good we came back with another couple.. This is now REVISED for LAST NIGHT, Friday.
What started out great, indoors, at 6PM, got so loud by 7PM my ears were ringing & the restaurant was not even packed. The food, drinks & service were still great but we will have to rethink about returning because of the noise level.
GREAT MUSIC ON ITALIAN NITE !!!
FOODS ALWAYS FANTASTIC.
What a wonderful find. Never new they existed & took an Open Table chance. WOW. We normally eat in Manhattan & that's ususally hard to compare but Pomodorino Rosso is excellent.. The wait staff service is fantastic. We'll be back..... Don't tell anyone it's that good because it'll get too busy... LOL
Food was filling and hot. However, service from the kitchen was slow and food was a bit bland despite adding the shredded cheese and black pepper. We ordered two Carni dishes and one Antipasti. The breading on their breaded dishes needs to be seasoned to give the flavor. Most likely will not dine-in again unless it’s for pizza or pasta because it seems that’s their big hit items.
Great food, ambience and staff always plus very interesting specials
Awesome food, great atmosphere! Would definitely recommend!!
One of our favorite spots. From the minute you walk in you are always greeted with a smile. Food is always excellent. Great wine choices. So reasonably priced. All are so very friendly.
Food is excellent and service is great. We’ve been here multiple times since our first experiences. Def a local gem.
Delicious food, timely and friendly service. Prices however are expensive for the meal and wine. Thank you
Everything was great. The food was amazing and the service was very attentive without being smothering.
Excellent food and service. Great place to dine
The waiter Joe was charming and pleasant. He even nonchalantly found out my moms name to sing Happy Birthday to her with our dessert. The food was absolutely delicious and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience.
Very nice evening.
This was my 3rd time there but it was my 1st time with my family. The waiter was not attentive at all. He did not explain the specials to us, instead he handed us a sheet of paper with it for us to read. But the table of 10 was given the full run down. I guess he was working on his tip over there. I asked for my lamb to be well done but it came out still running blood on the plate. I sent it back only to have it come back out burnt on the outside and still very red on the inside. I took it home and re-cooked it the next day. I had been raving about this place to my husband but we were so disappointed. The previous times I went with my girlfriends and now I realize it made a difference.
Pomodorino Rosso offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 812-6171.
Pomodorino Rosso is rated 4.6 stars by 167 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.