Great food, ambience and staff always plus very interesting specials
Awesome food, great atmosphere! Would definitely recommend!!
One of our favorite spots. From the minute you walk in you are always greeted with a smile. Food is always excellent. Great wine choices. So reasonably priced. All are so very friendly.
Delicious food, timely and friendly service. Prices however are expensive for the meal and wine. Thank you
Everything was great. The food was amazing and the service was very attentive without being smothering.
Excellent food and service. Great place to dine
The waiter Joe was charming and pleasant. He even nonchalantly found out my moms name to sing Happy Birthday to her with our dessert. The food was absolutely delicious and we couldn’t have asked for a better experience.
Very nice evening.
This was my 3rd time there but it was my 1st time with my family. The waiter was not attentive at all. He did not explain the specials to us, instead he handed us a sheet of paper with it for us to read. But the table of 10 was given the full run down. I guess he was working on his tip over there. I asked for my lamb to be well done but it came out still running blood on the plate. I sent it back only to have it come back out burnt on the outside and still very red on the inside. I took it home and re-cooked it the next day. I had been raving about this place to my husband but we were so disappointed. The previous times I went with my girlfriends and now I realize it made a difference.
From the welcome at the door to dessert it was a great experience. Anna, our waitress, was very attentive. We love it here. It’s our new favorite restaurant
Great service great food loved it
It was a perfect Vday dinner with awesome food, great drinks, amazing service & nice ambiance. Will definitely visit again 😊
Hostess on Valentines day was rude....everything else was great, but she gave a bad impression when we got there and we almost left. We won't be going back there.
Menu is limited. I did not enjoy my chicken dish. It was cold.
I love love love this place!! It is a hidden treasure nestled on the cusp of VS and FS .. food is delish, staff awesome and atmosphere outstanding.. I recommend you try for yourself❤️
Great place to hang on a Thursday night with the Ladies. Or any other night!
Service super friendly.
Drinks were awesome
Food very good.
I had a 5:00 reservation for tonite. I was there and restaurant was not open. I called restaurant, no one answered phone. Place was dark, no lights on. We waited approx 10 minutes and left. Extremely disappointed no one called to say they were not opening for a 5:00 reservation!
Everything was great from the time we stepped in the door till we stepped out. In all aspects. Keep it up!!!
Love the place. Not only is the food and service great, but management has figured out how to consistently ensure a relaxed, fun and no-aires atmosphere.
Food was very good, different twist on traditional Italian Fare. Service was very good, wait staff and personnel very attentive and obliging. Overhaul enjoyable dinner.
Food was delicious and service outstanding. Dined with a group of 6 and split many appetizers and every one was great. Perfect place for a group as it is rather loud with many groups so no risk of bothering other patrons. 1st time dining here but will definitely return.
Didn't realize there was a Holiday Menu, and in comparison to the daily fare, it was somewhat limited. Still our goto restaurant for great eats!
Very enjoyable evening with friends. Highly recommend Pomodorino Rosso!
Great food and staff!! Really enjoy dining at Pomodorino Rosso
The specials were absolutely delicious! Fall comfort food done perfectly.
First time, and won’t be the last! Amazing staff, delicious pasta.
Great food and service!!
The staff and food was great as usual. Never disappointed when I dine there. Always interesting dishes and I love the decor.
Can’t wait to go back
AGAIN we were THRILLED with our dinner at Pomodorino Rossi-....only thing missing was CAROL!! Loved our choices that we selected with the help of Joseph- appetizers were outstanding.....baked claims and a apple salad.....we love to share so that everyone gets a little of EVERYTHING!
Dinner selection was on POINT! Shared the Sword Fish, chicken with pasta dish and a all time favorite.....SCALLOPS! Restaurant was so busy with great conversations going.....everyone super friendly....even ANNA our waitress last time came over to see how we were doing!
If you have not go to Pomodorino Rosso...go....and expect to go back over and over again!
My husband thought Skirt steak was fabulous. The ziti Alla Norma was ok not great bland.
I highly recommend this restaurant. Excellent food & service.
Super friendly staff.
We really enjoyed our food and the special service from our waitress Amy. It has great ambiance and you can dress casual or dressy. A nice place for friends to gather or even a larger party.
Delicious food and friendly service...tons of daily specials!
Excellent atmosphere, excellent service, excellent food. Nice not to be rushed from table. Looking forward to going back
Love the food never had anything I didn’t like and the service was wonderful
This was a fantastic meal. Service and management are extremely friendly. Have been twice and both times felt the food was exceptional. Great sangria.
One word....DELICIOUS!!! I have only been to Pomodorino Rosso once since they opened last year.....I am a big fan of the sister restaurant UVA Rossa which is not far on Hempstead Avenue in Malverne which I love and frequent often! Last night me and my partner was in the mood for brick oven pizza. We got there and was greeted with big smiles by the hostess who promptly sat us down at the time of our reservation....from start to finish we LOVED our meal...or should we say EVENT! Our waitress Anna was tentative to our needs...going over the specials one by one with detail.....the bus service was on top of it for sure....pouring water- cleaning our table at each moment that needed to be done.
We started with meatballs stuffed with zucchini- went on to the special pear salad and our main course we shared what we came there for...a fabulous salad with a ball of truffles in the middle.....it was a taste of heaven for sure!
We left there saying ...when are we going BACK!
It was not just a meal it was a EXPERIENCE- TRUST me....its a not to miss restaurant on the south shore of Long Island!
My husband and I have eaten at this restaurant several times over the years that it has been open. Generally the food has been good, but this last time we were very disappointed. We both ordered the scallops special which we had had just one week before. Sadly, the second time was a deal breaker. The fregula, which had been toasted the week before, was soggy and tasteless. Guanciale, which had been in the dish the week before, and was mentioned by the waiter in the description of the dish, was absent. The restaurant was fairly empty and the chef was not in the kitchen but was socializing with the other staff members. Clearly the cooking had been left to someone in the kitchen who was either too lazy to prepare the dish properly or did not care. I even mentioned to the waiter that the preparation was not as expected or described and that we had had the dish just one week before. No apology from management. No explanation. The hostess and the chef were too busy with each other to pay attention. I won't go back.
Always a great meal! The drinks r great. Bartenders so friendly. My favorite place by far for everyday dining!
Pomodorino Rosso offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (516) 812-6171.
Pomodorino Rosso is rated 4.7 stars by 136 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.