Pizza Man - Wauwatosa
Every pizza we serve is made with fresh, often local ingredients, including our handmade dough and a variety of fresh toppings. Pizza Man is a family-friendly restaurant and offers plenty of vegetarian options, as well as takeout and delivery services.
Book your next event with us
Callyn was our waitress and did an extremely and amazing job with our table.
The experience was great and we will come back in the future.
We went to dinner and had a great time. Our server was so nice! We enjoyed our food and drinks!
When we checked in for our reservation, the hostess told us our table was being set up. 20 minutes later we were seated in a dark corner. During the wait I asked her if there was any where to sit...she waived her hand towards the bar (which was totally filled with people)... and waived her hand and,said you can sit on the bench. The bench was,filled with people.
In the dark corner we had to use the phone flashlight to see the menu. We ordered a glass of wine, that took 20 minutes to arrive at our table. We ordered cheese bread appetizer, and we were told we could order a 6 piece or a 12 piece. We ordered the 6 piece.....again over 20 minutes to get the order.....then there were only 5 pieces all of which were strewn in the basket, sticking together. After about another 20 minutes, the waitress stopped to ask how it was. I told her there were only 5 pieces and the basket was a total mess. We sent it back.....the waitress was haughty about our refusal to have the bread...but she took it away and I asked her,to remove it from our bill. In a few minutes, she cam back and stood behind us and said loudly “I took it off you bill. “
The Margarit pizza was delicious.
It’s interesting that when finished eating they take away the pizza pan, but,leave the pizza bracket on the table....it’s in the way. We ordered dessert and it was delicious....but the the darn pizza bracket was in the way....never removed from the table.
Bill was expensive for a “pizza joint”
Our experience was awful and we will not be going back. All the workers,had a terrible personality. Not what we expected after reading reviews...we just won’t go back there,again. (Pizza was very yummy however).
Great pizza & service, as always! A little pricey but I think everyone knows that going in.
Thank you for the five-star review. Be sure to visit us on a Wednesday for our Buy One Get One Large Pizzas for dine-in. Cheers!
Thin crust is way to thin, not much topping put on pizza.
The food quality is not premium for the prices one would pay. It can be quite noisy and packed during peak hours, and the food delivery to the table could take longer than desirable.
We love going to pizza man. Pizzas are consistently good and so is service. Very kid friendly too.
They have the standard sausage and pepperoni pizzas, but also some amazing non traditional pizzas. The white pizza is my favorite.
DonnaM, we appreciate the review. The white pizza is one of our favorites! We look forward to seeing you again soon.
I enjoy Pizza man! The food is good. The staff were nice. My only complaint is there are several rules for BOGO Wednesday: dine-in only, only large thin crust pizzas, no pan crust, no doing 1/2 one kind and the 1/2 another kind on the same pizza.
We had a great time! There were $20 wine bottle specials, which we purchased. Our waitress provided great service and recommendations.
Thank you, LynneG, for the review. We have ongoing $20 wine bottle specials weekly so make sure to stop in soon before they are all gone! Cheers!
Nice ambiance, decent food, but slow service and high pizza prices.
Thank god we had a reservation but our ticket was lost so huge delay For our food but were compted desserts
Food and service was great. Pizza was slow to arrive but they stayed in touch and gave us a discount, which was appreciated. Highly recommend.
The fans were a little chilly...sat in the booths by the glass windows/South side/parking lot . Other than that amazing !
It was a Saturday night and our food took over 30 minutes. The ribs were underdone. Part of the rack was falling off the bone...the other part I had to wrestle with. Our waitress seemed irritated and short with us. Everyone has a bad day but it was borderline rude. Nothing like the old pizza man I remember.
Great pizza as always. Our server Rachel was awesome.
Thank you for the review. Rachel is one of our rising stars here at Pizza Man. We look forward to your next visit!
Great pizza! And wine.
MrDepot, thank you for the review. Make sure to stop in on Monday for our 1/2 off bottles of wine!
The restaurant was not busy but for some reason our service was very slow. It took over 20 mins to get our drinks. We had other plans after lunch so had to tell our server we needed to be out by 1:00. Food ended up coming out quicker than drinks did. Can’t imagine how long it would of took if it was busy!
Consistently good pizza, which is what brings us back. Popular spot, sometimes difficult to get in without a reservation during prime weekend hours, So it’s more helpful to plan ahead rather than to just pop in.
AndreaG, we appreciate the review. We look forward to your next visit!
Our family has made dinner here after a movie our Christmas Eve tradition. It has never disappointed.
The food was fabulous and our waitress was fantastic! Looking forward to next year!
TSMfruit, we appreciate the review and are excited to be a part of your tradition! We look forward to seeing you again, soon. Cheers!
Food and service is always great here. Highly recommend!
JoeK, we appreciate the review. We look forward to your next visit. Cheers!
Very slow kitchen. Server was great but was so busy doing multiple jobs. Front. Serving. Bar tending etc. We felt bad for her. Food wasn’t as good as it normally has been. Pizza dough super thick.
Great place to share a meal w/friends. Pizza was very tasty and served was friendly. Look forward to returning and trying some of their entree selections next time. Half off bottles of wine special on Monday was a plus!
Thank you, for the review. Be sure to check us out on Wednesday for our BOGO on large pizzas and our new wine menu!
It looks like the wine list has changed for the worse.
Absolutely recommend. The thin crust pizza is delicious! Entire family loved it, and we'll be back again.
Thank you, susanb, for the review. We can hardly wait to see you and the family again!
Messed up our order, which would be fine if our server had explained the situation. Went about an hour without our entrees or an explanation while tables seated after us ate and left. Will not return.
Thank you so much, Robin!
We had 4 different pizzas. They were all very good except the chicken pizza was not so good. My neice and
Split the pizza and both thought the chicken had greasy look and a odd taste. If you took the chicken off the pizza was good. But we would go back just not order the chicken pizza.
Thank you, bobo, for the review. We appreciate the feedback regarding the chicken. We look forward to your next visit!
Great food and service. Wasn’t happy that some of our guests were locked out while we were paying the bill. When asked why we were told they were now closed. We had a group of 15 and that’s not very professional.
Everybody gets the thin crust, but you should try the pan pizza sometime. It’s excellent. Also, I’d like to see a few more beers on the beer list, it’s pretty pedestrian.
It was our anniversary and we were sat right next to the bathroom - super romantic. Our server wasn’t very attentive and it was just a disappointing experience from the start. Wish we would have gone somewhere else.
Good fast seating....
Overall, we had a nice time at Pizza Man. The pizza was a little underdone and a little over priced.
Server was nice and attentive. Food was great as usual
Thank you for the five-star review. We look forward to your next visit!
We had a very nice experience at Pizza Man Friday night. The host recognized me and knew my name! Also the server we had Emily was very pleasant and we enjoyed her.
Excellent wine... but pricey.
Pizza orders weren’t correct after taking a long time.
First crust was burned.
Brought new pizza rectifying issue.
Always very good. Service was great
Thank you, jorgejohn, for the review. We look forward to your next visit.
There for birthday, no recognition for that. Wine selection was large if you wanted a bottle, poor if you only wanted a glass. Paid $40 for bottle of Cleto Chiarli Lambrusco only to find out later that it is priced locally between $10 and $15. My wife enjoyed her Wild Boar Ravioli; however my father’s Spicy Meatball Pizza was lacking. The menu said the one of the toppings is spicy giardiniera; in actuality, there were just some cut-up jalapeño peppers. I ordered spaghetti, not spaghetti and meatballs. I was brought and had to pay for spaghetti and meatballs even though I brought the mixup to the server’s attention. Usually go to Maggiano’s and it was a mistake no to last night. Pizza Man is fine as long as you only want a regular, though overpriced, pizza. Cannot recommend them for anything else.
Amanda P. Was a terrible server. She brought beverage for 8 out of 9 guests. Had to go to bar to get glass of wine after 20 minutes, then magically server appeared with glass of wine without any apologies. She brought out 3 racks when we asked for an additional rack she snapped at us saying there was enough racks for 6 pizzas like we were a bunch of morons. We will not be back for our once a month family gatherings. We also had to split our own bills which was not the easiest as the bill is hard to understand.