Pizza Man - Oak Creek
Every pizza we serve is made with fresh, often local ingredients, including our handmade dough and a variety of fresh toppings. Pizza Man is a family-friendly restaurant and offers plenty of vegetarian options, as well as takeout and delivery services.
Book your next event with us
Valentine's Day Special Menus & More
Treat your other half to our heart-shaped pizza (or any menu item) for Valentine's Day, and we'll treat you to a 375ml bottle of Segura Viudas Brut Cava! Reserve your table today, because this kind of love is fleeting and only available on Friday the 14th. ❤️🍕🍷
Friday, February 14, 2020
Variety of different pizzas should satisfy everyone in the family. Was seated immediately and had excellent service. Food also came quickly and was tasty.
Michelle, thank you for the great feedback! I'm glad to see you had a great experience, and we look forward to seeing you again soon!
Some of the best thin crust pie in the Milwaukee area.
Scott, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review! I'm glad to hear that you love our pizza! Be sure to stop in on Wednesdays when we do buy one get one free on large thin crust pizzas. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Great ambiance, & the menu had something for everyone.
Joelle, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. I'm glad that you enjoyed the ambiance and food. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Great!! Love this place! We go with 4 kids and always enjoy!
Thank you for dining with us and leaving the great feedback! I'm happy you and your family enjoyed your visit. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
I used to attend the original pizza man when I lived in the area many moons ago. I gave this new location a shot hoping the food was just as good. Service was excellent, food was as good as I remembered and I loved the heavy wood atmosphere of the location. What a great experience
Thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. I'm happy to see that we lived up to your memory of the original Pizza Man. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
I rated noise level high as a positive. I brought a 5 year old, and was glad it was nice and busy/loud. Helps to make people with younger kids comfortable. Service was excellent, as well as the ambiance. Unfortunately, the pizza wasn’t as good as I’d remembered at the old North & Oakland location. That being said, pretty good. My expectations probably were too high. I’d go again.
Efficient, tasty, and not too pricey. Love the ambiance of the restaurant at night.
Troosh, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review! I'm glad that you enjoyed your experience, and we look forward to seeing you again soon!
Careful what drinks you order. Ask what the house wine costs per glass per type and how much a 1/2 or full carafe is. Usual 1/2 the cost if its bar wine but not here. The waitress didn't tell us the difference. Too young I suppose to realize people like to save money sonetimes.
John, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. Training the staff on wine is definitely something that I'm passionate about. I apologize that this knowledge was not extended to you when you dined with us. We put a lot of time into our wine list and selecting the best glass offerings. Because of this, we do not have any "house wines." If you do love wine as much as us, a great day to come in is Monday for 1/2 price bottles. Hopefully we see you soon!
I love the eggplant and their pizza is one of my favorites :) There was an issue where our pizza list toppings in the oven so we got to keep that and they brought us a whole new one too which was very nice.
Laura, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. I'm glad that you had a great experience! We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Delicious pizza! Yum, it's the best with a very thin crust which is what my husband and I love.
Barbara, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. I'm glad you had a great experience. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Wonderful food and service! Can’t recommend this place enough!
Betsy, thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. I'm happy to see that you enjoyed your experience. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
Good Food! Good Service! Good Specials! A favorite restaurant for me!
Thank you for dining with us and taking the time to leave a review. We look forward to seeing you again soon!
I love pizza man so much, but this location always seems understaffed!
The gluten free pizza was great
Not on tuesday 1/2 off night.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................!
Thank you for the 4 stars. Wednesday is our buy one get one large pizzas, Monday 1/2 price bottles. If you live in the Oak creek area the Current Magazine put out by the city Oak Creek we have a buy one get one half price pizza coupon on page 4. We do also have them at our host stand
I would recommend Pizza Man - food and service excellent - only next time I will request a table rather than a both - would have been much more comfortable - booths are very narrow - little room beyween you and the table.
Thank your for the review Im sorry your seating was uncomfortable we can move you to a table at any poin in your service to make your dining experience pleasurable
Very unusual night for Pizza Man, they were not that busy. We reserved a reservation for 45 minutes from when I opened opentable app and was seated instantly. Food was great like usual, people sitting inside and outside which made for a quieter experience than usual but always a great experience. Our waitress Alex was great and very friendly. We had spent the day at the state fair and this was a welcoming dinner for our trip back to Kenosha.
So disappointing! Over priced and over cooked food, and very slow service. We won't be back.
Excellent lunch special.. $13 for 1/2 med. Pizza, salad and beverage.. we come here often and never are disappointed!
Staff was very friendly and professional. Pizza was fantastic, service was outstanding.
We went at about 3 p.m. so it wasn't busy yet. Our waitress was very friendly. Had 0 issues. Never have had any issues here. I do enjoy their food, but I do feel they are overpriced. This time I got a cauliflower crust pizza ( I can eat the regular crust but I do like the cauliflower crust as well), no sauce, but instead rubbed with garlic and olive oil and OMG it had an amazing taste! I recommend over the sauce. My other topping for this trip ( as I do like to change it up and try new things) were mozz cheese, pepperoni and caramelized pineapple. Holy cow! Good! On a side note: this place has an EXCELLENT lunch buffet.
maybe - my food was not very good taste wise. I certainly wouldn't order it again
Industrial decor. I really liked it. Immediately greeted by hostess and seated. It took a bit for the server to arrive. Could’ve had a better attitude. Apps came out quickly. Cheese curds were awesome as well as the Cesar salad. Wednesday is BOGO large specialty pizza, that was great! We had a thin crust pizza man pizza and it was very good. No Miller Lite on tap, tho.
Needed to find our server on two occasions as the group ended up being 6, 3 hours for a dinner seemed long. I will consider other options for future business meals.
The food was excellent in presentation and taste. The service was very slow. It took over 30 minutes to receive ordered appetizers, and had to ask runner about the status or the wait would have been longer. Had extensive wait on several occasions where waitress did not check on us for drink refills. Total 1 hour and 40 minutes for family dinner for three, mostly due to slow service.
It could’ve been an off nite, but took over an hour for 2 pizzas.
It’s an ok place. Not up to the original though. Our pizza was carelessly made. Many of the vegetables were clustered and not spread evenly around the pizza. There was also quite a bit of “empty” crust along the edges. Would I go back? Probably not for pizza. There are much better options in the South like Ann’s, Ricardo’s, Transfer, Tanino’s. It wasn’t busy when we were there so that’s not a reason.
Great pizza and service!
Service was pretty slow considering they weren’t busy
Using Open Table was so quick and convenient.
Everything is tasty.
Arrived early for reservation, seated immediately on overflow type area even though booths were available on main dining. Waitress took drink order and return with 2 cans of beer. Never offered glasses and barely said 2 words. Pizza arrived under cooked, cheese softened but not melted bubbly. Crust crisp but no browning
Very disappointed with experience. Restaurant not crowded at all for Friday night which I now can understand since service and food subpar.
My husband and I love Pizza Man in Oak Creek! Always great food and good service. The spaghetti and meatballs is his favorite! Tuesdays are trivia so if noise bothers you, I would go a different night, but sometimes its fun to hear the questions!
Good food crust on pizza was great, waitress was great I'll go back again
I was disappointed. For having “pizza” in its name, I expected more. We got a special pizza with Brussel sprouts and less than half the pizza had brussel sprouts on a piece. And the other options were boring at best. We would have been better off going to mod pizza down the street.
Third visit, second miss for us. Toppings were sparse on the pizza, we were charged $3 per kids drink, total of 4 ordered, be we never pay additional anywhere else. Waitress barely showed up, apologized once for not being there, but it was not that busy for a Wednesday BOGO of the pizza. We were just here a month ago to celebrate a birthday and things were 4 star because the pizza was better, we were not charged for the extra kids drinks and what kept the service going was one of the managers, but he was not working on our third visit. Not sure if we will go back, even for the BOGO.
Food great as always but for pan wait is 40 minutes and Pizza cane or wrong. Asked for no onion. Waitress said 'I don't like them either' and that was that....no apology or compensation.
Pizza Man has the very best variety of pizza's and toppings. We like eating there because each of us wants to create their own pizza. On this particular visit we had an excellent server named Mackenzie. She was very friendly and seemed genuinely glad to take care of us. She checked in with us at the right times and made sure that everything was to our liking.
I would highly recommend Pizza Man in Oak Creek and ask for Mackenzie to be your server.
Service was poor. The hostess seemed like we were an annoyance. The waitress asked us to order before we even opened the drink menu. My dates diet Coke came out right away, my spotted cow beer 5 minutes later. It was somewhat busy, but by no means swamped. The pizza we ordered was ok. The red onion was raw ( maybe forgot to add it until the end?), It should have been cooked. Skimpy basil. Great crust. Management needs to step up. It's not 19-22 yr olds fault if they aren't trained properly.