Pizza Man - Milwaukee
Every pizza we serve is made with fresh, often local ingredients, including our handmade dough and a variety of fresh toppings. Pizza Man is a family-friendly restaurant and offers plenty of vegetarian options, as well as takeout and delivery services.
Book your next event with us
Always enjoy coming to Pizza Man!! Food is always amazing. On this particular occasion the host was very accommodating! We got a drink at the bar and the bartender was very helpful, friendly and warm. Unfortunately our server was not very inviting or friendly. She seemed as though she did not want to be there. We all could see her standing off to the side with a look of irritation on face.
I will be back again, because I love the pizza there and always have had good service in the past. Just hoping the next time I have one of the better servers again.
They were busy and the noise level was very loud. Our server was nice but we had to remind her twice to get the drinks people at our table ordered. She brought 4 of the z6.
Very disappointed... we were rushed by our server to make our drink and food order, but then we waited way too long time to receive anything. My drink from the bar took 10 minuets (okay) but my sons non alcoholic drink took over 20 minutes to get to the table ... For one pizza and an app we were at the restaurant for almost an hour and a half- and we ordered almost immediately after sitting down.
This is a very nice place, and the food was delicious, but the service we had doesn’t make the price tag worth it.
We went to pizza man for our daughter’s 18th birthday. We had a great time. Our waitress was friendly and was checking on us to make sure everything was ok. The food was delicious! We’ll be back
Love this place, food and drinks were outstanding. Service was on the struggle bus a bit.
The pizza was great. Service was extremely slow but they were busy. Beer had wrong line fed to tapper. Will go back if in the area again.
The manager of the Pizza Man is wonderful and allows us to special order. He was off the night we were there and our special order was not very edible. Also, the fried eggplant strips that were a special that night were overdone and dried out.
It was eh. Food was good, and was presentable but the overall atmosphere and area was bleh. Would forget in like 2 days
Best mozzarella sticks in Milwaukee! Pizza was delicious. Thin crust was perfect!
Overall a good experience.
It was busy and delicious and slower than usual.
We had a great time.
On our farewell visit to Milwaukee, we just HAD to visit Pizza Man one last time. They didn’t disappoint. Food as great as ever, comfortable surroundings, close enough to the original place’s ambiance. I’ll miss PM!
Great location with access to the Downer Theatre.
Food is always awesome! Atmosphere was great - it was a little chilly for outdoor seating, but they turned the heaters on, but kept the roof open and it was delightful. The waitress was also top notch!
We waited over an hour for our food and then it was cold.
The pizza is consistently good, the wine selection is incredible. This is a good stand by restaurant that never fails.
We went in for an anniversary dinner on a Friday night and the team at Pizza Man made us feel so special! They delivered the best service and our food/ drinks were perfect. I don't think we have ever received this kind of service anywhere else. Thank you so much!
So sorry to say this but I go to Pizza Man regularly with my grandkids, a place that was perfect for them, and I was totally disappointed last night. First, I made a reservation on Open Table, and did get seated. It was a Friday night so the place was busy. Arrived at 6:15. The waitress was a cute kid, trying her best in a crowded restaurant. She served the kids in a large glass rather than kiddie cups. Point 1 if you have kids: request kiddie cups. Point 2: we order two salads and the pizza at the same time. The salad came out in time but the waitress didn’t put in the order for our pizza until after the salad came out although we gave her all the orders but neglected to tell her that since we have kids to put both orders in at the same time. Point 3: the place is busy so we are now waiting one hour and ten minutes since we arrived. No waitress, no pizza, antsy kids. We decide it is time to talk to the manager who tells us there are four pizzas ahead of us, busy night. He did offer bread to keep the kids quiet. If the kitchen is so backed up, tell your clients. We would have walked at that point but the garlic bread did the trick for the kids.
The waitress proceeds to take the salad off the table and puts down two pie holders. We wonder, did she order us two pies instead of one? One of earth’s mysteries , let’s see.
Meanwhile she dumps salad remains from someone else on the floor near the garbage can and proceeds to walk on it, as does another waitress until someone, thankfully, has the sense to tell her to sweep it up, at this point it is almost comedic but so sad. 1 hr. 20 min.
The pizza finally comes, one, not two. She apologizes for taking up out table with two pie plate holders. We eat and rush out. Do you want dessert she asks? I could write a comedy routine with this entire experience except that at this point we vow not to ever go back to Pizza Man.
Management, I understand it is hard to get good help but you have got to train your people.
Didn't have the pizza, so can't rate them. Spaghetti dinners tasted like they came out of Chef Boyardee cans.
Excellent service! Amazing food! The place was packed and our food was quick and delicious! We definitely be back!!
I remember the original Pizza Man at North Avenue, which was one of the best restaurants in Milwaukee. This visit was my first since the original burned down. I was very disappointed. We started with the Escargot - this was okay, but was not the incredible escargot of the past. One of the snails had huge pieces of sand (grit) in it. I had the lasagna, which was mostly melted cheese. The meat was sausage links laid on top of the lasagna dish. My husband had spaghetti and meatballs, and he found it lacking as well. The entrees were heavy on fat (very greasy) and over-salted. The tomato sauce was boring, and we could not detect much in the way of herbs or spices.
The food was completely AWESOME!!!! So fun too! The restaurant was very cozy and had an awesome bar.
Brussels sprouts salad was delicious, but the lemon vinaigrette tastes just like olive oil. The thin crust pizza was just ok. Everyone loved the calamari.
Our order was not accurate and several items order didn't come. We had to walk around to find the waiter and ask for them. The table next to us got the wrong pizzas. Everything seemed off at the restaurant and it wasn't even busy. It ended up costing $90 for three pizzas, a beer and a glass of wine. It never used to be like at Pizza Man.
Great salad and pizza and awesome service. Only downside as it was very cold in the restaurant.
Food and service very good. Very noisy at front window
After having a terrible experience at Pizza Man, the manager initiated a conversation and wanted to know what happened and what they could do better. I appreciated the request and desire to improve. A few weeks later, I made an impromptu reservation and hoped for the best. The manager recognized my name from the reservation and went out of his way to make sure that our dinner and experience was superb. The food and the service were great! Thanks.
Great service! Better pizza! Loved sitting out on the patio in summer!!
Always a good time, good food, and great that they have half off wine on Mondays :-)
Nice place before movie with friends
Busy night at Pizza man, food was fresh and outstanding, wait too long. Super good pizza
We ordered 1 large thin crust pizza and it arrived to our table 1.5 hours later. The pizza was taken off of our bill and the server was very apologetic so it made up for the overall experience.
Thin crust was awesome. Specialty pizzas were great. Street parking around the neighborhood sucks but there is a parking ramp across the street and they do validate.
Always love the deep dish on Monday. We wish it was offered on more days.
Our server (Brandon?) was fantastic!!
Our server was very good and attentive. The food was good and served hot. I would have preferred more pasta options that were meat-free and I thought the prices were high for pizza, but the food was very good.
Great food. Great drinks. Super service. Made for a memorable family outing.
Although our pizza took a bit of an unusually long time to come out, the staff apologized and took off a portion of our bill for the inconvenience. Something a lot of other restaurants won’t do! Our waitress was super nice and we loved the food. Great vibe too!
Food was good
Ordered house wine and the waiter took liberties and gave us the most expensive wine, he admitted that he should have asked us which wine we wanted. In stead of paying $8/ glass, we paid $14 per glass. I think the waiter should have not assumed what we wanted. The intent of house wine is a standard moderate price wine. Very disappointed
Our waiter was slow to respond to needs of table such as providing water refills. he rarely came to the table to check for other needs such as checking if we got our appetizers and salads (we did not receive one salad), checking to see if needed refills on other drinks (when did, brought wrong beer than what was ordered and had to wait a long time again). Flourless chocolate brownie cake was barely baked - almost all raw batter with edges slightly set. Very disappointing service (which has never happened before but have never encountered this waiter before) especially since it was a graduation celebration.