Baklava Ice Cream Cake
slow roasted lamb shank pulled off of the bone, house made gnocchi, carrots, onions, spinach, feta, fennel puree
Australian grass fed range lamb, feta, onion, lettuce, tomato, tatziki
Mediocre at best ... neither here nor there in terms of cuisine. Worse Baklava and Mezes of my life, name is misleading!!! Poor customer service on the part of management.
To enjoy the happy hour menu one may ONLY inside at the bar. This seems absurd in Covid time.
We always find our way to Pita Paradise at least once during our vacation. Easy vibes. good food. Nice portions for hungry kids. And DO NOT skip dessert. baklava icecream pie oh my YES!!!
The staff was very attentive, friendly, accommodating. Seating outside was comfortable with plenty of spacing between tables. The food was very good, nice size servings.
Food is always fresh and delicious
Service was phenomenal! A bit pricey for the portions, but nothing that will keep me from going back again. The fish, lamb, and hummus were incredible!!!
Great food! Wonderful waitress.
I have eaten here many times in the past.
COVID dining was 100% odd at this restaurant.
I have a list of allergies my waitress would not take the list so many anaphylactic allergies I was not 100% comfortable.
My dinner was served they had to take it back I told the person delivering the meal that delivered my I had to bring back my dinner and she took my list to the chef.
New meal was perfect.
My suggestion is if you are so afraid of taking an order along with my list of serious allergies you should not be a waitress working during Covid.
I did notice she also was extremely cautious with other tables and their dinners were also incorrect.
My meal finally came back 100% delicious.
Just amazing all the way around! Highly recommended eating here if you have the chance!
Thank you!! We truly appreciate your amazing review!!
Pita Paradise it’s always a great experience mahalo for being open and providing as safe a Covid protection plan, one that every restaurant should follow.
Much appreciation!! Yes, we are here for our community and want to ensure our customers feel safe dining with us!! We will continue to maintaining a safe environment for our employees and patrons!
We love Puta Paradise! The owner catches the fresh fish in the morning and then it's perfectly cooked on the evening. We love it so much we ate here twice last week
Great to hear this!! We appreciate your continued patronage!! We really keep our fisherman busy!!
Our server was beyond spectacular!!! Best service ever. Our meals were very promptly served & very delicious! Bravo Pita Paradise. One of our new faves!!
Always a delight to dine on the patio. The food and service are always excellent.
Food was delicious and our server was amazing!
Food was not good. The drinks, service and ambiance was good. I’ll only go back for a cocktail in the future.
I love this place and everything it has to offer. The prices are a bit high but worth it. I am especially proud of this place as they have been able to hang in there and that is due to the due diligence of safety measures.
I was particularly disgusted with the yoga studio teachers above Pita Palace. When you walk in there restaurant there are very explicit rules stating the need and use of masks. All people are asked to put masks on when servers approach your table, and you are reminded of this when you are seated. These “Yoga “ supposed healers for some reason completely ignored the rules and blatantly put that server and this establishment at risk. I complained as did other people. Unfortunately the server had to be polite and ask them to put them on, at which these stupid women replied,” oh, we were just talking about that”.
Cudos to this server. I and many others will support you. For anyone reading this review this is a safe place to eat with conscious workers. Can’t keep stupid, selfish people out.
Pita Paradise has fresh and wonderful tasting food... Always!
Great atmosphere also.
Dined for lunch and the food was excellent as always. I had the lamb gyro and we shared the appetizer platter and baklava ice cream for dessert. Would highly recommend all three dishes.
We enjoyed our dinner & our time spent. Thank you🤗
Thank you for the great review! Hope to see you again soon!
It was girls night out! It was a first time visit for my girls & they loved it! The server was good, the food was terrific! The ambiance was nice & it was not loud but just right. I think we were loud.. We all enjoyed ourselves very much. Thank you👍🏼
We are so glad you enjoyed yourselves! And there’s no such thing as too loud if you’re having fun! Greatly appreciate your review! Thank you!😉
We thought this was a very nice restaurant. The menu was very small or limited though.
Thank you for your review! We strive everyday for great customer service and great food as always! We do have an extensive lunch and dinner menu! Join us again we’d love to change your mind about our menu options! Mahalo😊
Happy 10th Anniversary!!! Hope you had a great time dining with us!! 🥂 Cheers!!
I've written a review of Pita Paradise before but I wanted to review again because I'm grateful their doors are open during this nutty time and want to give them a little love. I especially like restaurants that are working to make it a natural and welcoming experience, which they did. We sat on the patio which feels very nice and secluded with all the bordering plants. We had the Caesar salad, which isn't typical because Pita puts their touch on it with cucumbers and tomatoes and it's really even better than the standard. Also had the veggie pita sandwich which is delicious. But the pièce de résistance was the Baklava ice cream cake which my husband and I basically *gently* fought over. Service was good and friendly, and when a couple of other tables filled in, you could pretend things were normal.
We greatly appreciate your wonderful review and your support during these times!
First time for two of us but came highly recommended by the rest of our party.
Chris our server and bartender was friendly and very attentive. Kept our drinks ordered and food served hot and fresh. Will definitely return.
Mahalo! Hope to see you soon!
Always outstanding food and service, I highly recommend!
Thank you for grand review! Greatly appreciate the support!
ambience is outstanding; they celebrate good seafood...need two choices for dinner; Italian dishes disappoint. Nice place and we want them to survive restaurant's disaster here without visitors
Thank you for an awesome review! Please try us again if ever in town, we’d love to change your mind about our Italian dishes!! “We will survive” 🎶
Delicious food and drinks!
We can’t wait to come back!
We can’t wait to have you back!😉
It is a treat to dine in again. The food is excellent as is the service.
Thank you! Much appreciated! It is great to serve you again!
Very respectful of COVID social distancing. Felt safe being in a restaurant again.
Thank you! We adhere to all CDC guidelines! Your safety is our safety, we wouldn’t have it any other way!
We eat at Pita Paradise about every month or so. We have NEVER been disappointed with the food or service. The ambiance is comfortable, whether out on the patio or inside. Our favorites are anything with the lamb (like the Lamb Salad or a Gyro) but everything is fresh and so ono. They get super fresh fish from their owner who goes out fishing and supplies his own restaurants. I highly recommend Pita Paradise!!!
Thank you for the amazing review! We greatly appreciate it! Can’t wait to see you again!
Food was bland and average...I grew ip on Greek food! Our server was polite but didn’t seem like she wanted to be waiting on us! Really wanted to like this place but it was a disappointment. Nice setting but it stops there. Worst meal of our two weeks on Maui.
I’m sorry to hear this! We pride ourselves on our food and customer service! Just a few days after your visit the State of Hawaii went into quarantine. Please try us again if you are ever on island, we’d love to change your mind about us!
The dinner menu is just ok. There is not much choice if you are not into the one fish special of the day which has been sword fish. The lamb pasta was not good and the lamb Kabob was plain and uninspiring.
Nice happy hour with food discounts
Good food. Good value. Quaint and cute. Would recommend
We order drinks, wine and meals. After waiting 25-30 minutes, we received in the following order: the wine, the meals and finally our drinks ! We refused the drinks that we expect to receive in first place, quickly after ordering them !!!
Great food. Fair service
We usually love Pita, but are afraid that since they have started a sister restaurant about a year + ago that they would begin to ignore this one and quality would go down. Just a little, and only recently we have noticed a bit of a decline. But they were short staffed so that could have been the issue. Fish was not as plentiful as usual. They need to change up the menu a little. Same for years. We are local, so we notice this more maybe than others. Still a favorite of ours. Love the fresh fish kabobs and the Mediterranean salad, the mushroom appetizer is excellent with pita. The gyro is great too!!
Pita Paradise offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (808) 879-7177.
Pita Paradise is rated 4.4 stars by 278 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.