Pietro's Italian restaurant was founded in 1932 by brothers Natale and Pietro Donini. While ownership has changed hands, the recipes and traditions that the brothers created have lived on. New York City has no shortage of Italian restaurants, but Pietro's stands out from the crowd. The dedication to excellent service and cuisine is what attracts both tourists and residents.
Authentic Italian cuisine is what you will find on the extensive menu at Pietro's.
Incredible food, old school vibe, great staff. A hidden gem in midtown
We enjoyed everything about Pietro's. Foodand service were great.
We have been going to Pietro's for years and alway enjoy going back. We had the steak for 2 this time, and it is very good, but in general we like their veal and pasta dishes. The salads and tiramisu were delicious. I wish they had better wines by the glass. For the quality of food they serve, their wines could use a make over.
Our service was very good, accommodating and engaging. We all thoroughly enjoyed our dinners and I had plenty to bring home. I definitely would recommend it.
Stale old Italian Steakhouse, not an Italian in sight.
The steak was sliced in wrong direction - with the grain, not perpendicular.
Disgraceful for a $$$ very expensive piece of meat.
Bread from a bakery that is reminiscent of a 1950's cotton wool white bread. Fried onions very greasy.
Service iffy at best.
Food is always excellent as a service
The food is always on point. It’s not going to be the most fun night of your life but that’s not what this restaurant is for.
Amazing food, large portions, old school Italian
Mostly local patrons but were tourists and were treated just as nicely as everyone else. We were given perhaps the best two-top table in the house. Wait staff was attentive but not overbearing. Food was well- prepared and portions were generous. We had a special beet salad and veal Marsala. Great evening.
Wonderful food & service!
We have been going to Pietro’s for over 40 years and still love it❣️My filet mignonette was cooked and seasoned to perfection❣️Whenever we feel like having steak, Pietro’s is our “go-to” restaurant❤️
Fabulous!!!! Best Shrimp Mariana, veal limone, and Caesar salad in the world. Also best NY strip I ever had.
One of my favorite restaurants!!
Pietro’s is fantastic. Food and service is top notch.
Fantastic as always!!!!!
Great to have Pietro's back in it's old school glory. Unbeatable veal parm is as good as ever.
Awesome as always
Food was amazing and service was excellent. Restaurant decor could use a facelift. Prices are high but tolerable as the food quality is excellent and the service is superlative.
Food and staff was amazing. Really good authentic Italian food.
Dining at Pietro's is a always a spectacular experience! First, the food can't be beat. Best Caesar salad in the city bar none! Italian classics and steaks to die for and gigantic portions to boot. We always start out with the Lyonnaise potatoes made fresh to munch on. To die for! So Happy they are back in full force!!!
I was very surprised about the cost of an off menu item. I would have preferred that the waiter should advised us.
Wait staff very friendly. Excellent traditional Italian food.
Food was outstanding as usual!
The wait staff was exceptionally polite and food at Pietro’s was delicious!
we went here bc we heard they did a great job inside social distancing and we were not disappointed. we ha e a grea table for 4 in the corner , everyone was well spaced snd we all felt totally comfortable, the owners were great , food was delicious and we will be back very soon . it was our friend s a first time eating indoors and although they were reluctance they were very happy with everything
Veal Parm and Ceasar Salad are Some of the best i've had
One of our fave restaurants for over 35 years! Great ownership as well as very experienced waiters and of course the food is 1st class! Always consistently very good!
Consistently delicious and great service
Had some friends visiting from Long Island, who wanted a classic Italian meal. Pietro’s never lets me down. Sautéed clams, cesar salad, chopped salad and chicken parmigiana with sautéed cherry peppers are all done extremely well! Great cocktails made by Raymond!!
Best Chicken Parm in the World!!!
Service and the food was excellent, aside from the NY Strip which was just ok. The veal parm. was outstanding and the clams casino terrific. Overall, a very solid meal.
Always a good choice. After many years still the best in the neighborhood.
Overpriced.....cocktails very expensive and wine as well. Portions not very big
Great food as always. Fun vibrant crowd. Such a great New York vibe. Love this place
The food was not great for the price point. I had the chicken Parmesan and it was over cooked and the side dish of vegetables was sting beans that seemed to have been microwaved.
Best restaurant in NY. Outstanding food and service. Chopped salad, cottage fries, broiled shrimp and steak are outstanding.
Old school but still as strong as ever. Best parm and caeser in NYC!
Perfect dinner as usual!!
The best veal in town
Friendly .. fun old New York feel
always consistent, always welcoming and superb food.
Pietro's offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 682-9760.
Pietro's is rated 4.8 stars by 123 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.