Catello's Mozzarella Bar
Outstanding! Food, service and atmosphere were amazing. Cannot believe it has been 3 years since last visit. Will return soon.
Lasagna Bolognese was ample in quantity, good temperature but seemed to be shy on seasoning. Content of serving seemed a little too smooth; expected it to have more texture.
Salad - excellent. Wine - delicious.
Everything is delicious... wine, cheese, bread, pasta, dessert! Fantastic experience for a special occasion or just date night.
Very nice portion size. Lasagna was delicious. Love the homemade pasta.
This restaurant will not disappoint you! The food is authentic Italian from start to finish.
Katja is an incredible server— friendly, professional, and knowledgeable regarding the menu.
Everything was outstanding!!
The best authentic Italian I’ve had in the U.S. This place is a true gem!
Literally the best Italian food i've ever had. We most definitely will be returning.
Thoroughly enjoyed our dinner
My fiancé and I love going to Catello's! Authentic Italian food and atmosphere, great for a date night or just any night out. The staff is very professional, quick, and polite. Katja always is eager to assist in any way she can. I highly recommend Catello's
What a great find! my friend just moved to Fort Wayne, so our group was looking for somewhere between Indianapolis and Fort Wayne to dine. We were thrilled with this find. Very authentic!! They make their own pastas and cheeses! Everything was awesome!!!
Good place... nice and cozy...I would visit again...
Great spot. Very small. Very friendly. No complaints. Will go back.
Love this restaurant! Ready to go again! Amazing food
First time and can’t wait to go back to try something else
Catello's offers the best pasta, and the best Italian food I've ever had in my life. This is my new favorite restaurant, knocking places like Ruth's Chris and Salt on Mass Ave out of the top spots.
The restaurant is quaint and cozy with a warm and inviting ambiance. If weather permits, sit outside. Inside is lovely too, but the noise level creeps up a tad. The wine selection is excellent. The server and assistant server are both wonderful.
The food...the food is where the magic happens.
This is the place for authentic/incredible Italian food and amazing service!!
As usual Katja provided impeccable service— offering terrific wine selections in addition to delicious food options.
We love this restaurant!!
Our first visit and definitely not our last. Food and service were both awesome!!
Was pleasantly surprised. Our waitress was right on, very perceptive and informative. I am from PTown originally and it is nice to know that you can have such a good time taking a lady there. Good Job all. Food was killer!
Food was amazing. Best Italian food I ever had. Will definitely be back .
We enjoy Italian food. This was our first visit. The style of this establishment’s pasta preparation is not something that we have had before this visit. It was very al Dante.
Delicious food, great atmosphere, and excellent service!
Unbelievable food, service, and atmosphere. Wow! I highly recommend. Best Authentic Italian ever. I had the dinner special ravioli... to die for. This Pistachio tiramisu was also one for the ages. You are missing out if you don’t come here!
Unfortunately there was a table of women screaming the whole time. if not for that the experience would have been perfect.
We celebrated our 22nd anniversary at this lovely restaurant. The food, music and ambience was wonderful! Will absolutely be back!
This was our first time @ this lovely authentic Italian restaurant— and we were delighted!
Katja was our server and she was outstanding— incredibly familiar with the menu.
Both of our meals were simply delicious!
It’s a bit of a drive— but we will definitely return. Our meals surpassed our expectations! Wonderful menu and equally excellent wine list!
Thank you for an outstanding meal and dining experience!
It was a lovely evening. We celebrated my sister and brother-in-law 6 year wedding anniversary. The food was excellent and the wine was highly recommended by our waitress. The evening was topped off with a special greeting from Catello! We were so excited to hear about the growth of the restaurant. I can’t wait for our next dinner.
Small quiet gem of a restaurant. Food is hands down some of the best I have eaten even at higher priced restaurants. Everything is very fresh and you can tell is handmade. Thought and care has been taken to generate the menu. Would highly recommend and will definitely be back.
Great ambiance. Amazing staff. Delicious food. Wish they had beer and vodka.
I love this restaurant! It was our third time there and each has been a fabulous experience. I can’t wait to go back!
We had a great table outside and along with enjoying the great food and wwine, we also enjoyed the warmth of the sun!
This is now my go-to restaurant.
I am italian, movede in the states not long ago, and i think this is one of the best italin restaurants you can find that really follow our tradition and culture.
Take the Pistachio Tiramisù, it’s outstanding.
Located in downtown Pendleton, it is a quaint location for very good Italian food. The food is prepared by a chef that knows exactly how a dish should taste. So simple with ingredients, yet so complex with flavors. Highly recommend. Favorites were the sliced FRESH cheese and meats, ravioli funghi, and probably the table Best was the Fruitti de Mare dish. There were a couple of misses on food. Service was second to none! Very friendly and knowledgeable about the dishes
This place is always excellent. I typically go with one of the specials, you just can’t go wrong! Highly recommend! It’s small so don’t forget to make reservations.
The food was delicious and expertly prepared. Their homemade cheese and pasta are to die for.
Great food but the service was horrible. Also the noise level made it hard to hear the conversation from the person across from me.
Catello's is a very small quaint italian restaurant, which make you feel like you are
not in Indiana but a small place in Italy. Food is excellent and service is very good.
All pastas and cheeses made in house as probably everything else.
We went on a Monday evening and was surprised by the amount of people there. After eating there, I understand why. Love the ambiance of the restaurant and the food was superb! Staff was kind and efficient. Fabulous dining experience.
Incredible food - good wine - knowledgeable and friendly staff. Their cheeses are phenomenal!
Service was very good and food was excellent. They make their own pasta and cheeses. The only thing I would change is to offer more adult beverages for those who don't enjoy wine.
Catello's Mozzarella Bar offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 498-5906.
Catello's Mozzarella Bar is rated 4.9 stars by 295 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.