Catello's Mozzarella Bar
Every experience at Catellos is perfect. Cozy atmosphere, wonderful service and food to die for. Every food item is FRESH. Pasta is home made and so he the cheese and all sauces. If you want authentic Italian you won't be sorry!
I would 100% recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a fantastic dining experience.
I think perhaps they were a little short staffed because we had one server to the whole dining room. Never once did we feel neglected or forgotten. She was a rock star.
Great food in a very intimate setting in downtown Pendleton. Definitely Some of the best Italian dining in the area
Best and most authentic Italian spot in Indiana! Catello is a master artisan! Can’t wait until they open their deli and gelato shop next door!
I have been here a few times now, last being with my 13 year old son. Even he loved it! We love everything about this restaurant, we will be back many times!!
First trip back since the pandemic and it is still as good as ever
Wonderful, absolutely some of THE BEST Italian food in central Indiana! Try it!!!!
Amazing service and outstanding food...the best Italian you will have outside of Italy!
This is real Italian restaurant with great Italian food. Great service. Highly recommend it.
We had a very nice dinner at Catello’s. Food was excellent, we are looking forward to returning and trying more of the menu. Service was very good and pacing was nice. For something akin to dinner in Italy, give this place a try!
Outstanding food, clearly made with care and pride. Cute setting, very cozy, and they are working on a significant expansion. The fettucine al filetto is wonderful. Best gluten-free pasta I've had in a restaurant, by the way. This restaurant is a gem of our small town.
First time there and we loved it! Amazing food, great wine, quiet lovely atmosphere. We will definitely go again and probably even bring our teenage boys, they would love the seafood choices and pasta variety.
Second time I've been there. Staff is fabulous food was wonderful and enjoy the Father's Day with my dad. Very nice evening.
Best Italian food in the state!
Device was awesome. All food cooked well. Lemon cake was outstanding
My wife and I took our guests from Arkansas for dinner, which we had enjoyed on one previous occasion. He is a retired Fed Ex captain and had eaten Italian food in Italy on many occasions. He and his wife very much
enjoyed the food taste, ambiance, and the wine!
To be highly recommended ... we are world travelers and lived close to Italy for many years and visited the country often. This restaurant in the most authentic far and wide and leaves all other "Italian' restaurants in the shade.
As usual, great food quality and great service . This is real Italian cuisine!
Outstanding from beginning to end! Simply love Catellos!
What a wonderful surprise. Cheese appetizer and pasta was amazing. Everyone should visit. A touch of Napoli in Pendleton - who knew. Was well worth the 45 minute drive.
The most adorable little itilian restaurant! The food, service, and atmosphere is fabulous!
Delicious meats and cheeses, pastas and sauces - be sure to leave room for dessert!
Amazing great food very authentic. Will make this my go to place for Italian food.
Very nice restaurant however was seated in of the door so when people walked in from 28 degree weather, it kind of killed the mood. The cheese plate was very disappointing. My entree was awesome and so was the dessert.
Great food and wine, but dont be in a hurry.
Best unknow restaurant in the Indy area. Incredible food and staff!!
Food was very authentic and tasted amazing. Very small place with limited seating, so you better have a reservation.
We couldn’t have loved this little spot any more! Excellent service! Excellent food! Excellent wine! We can’t wait to go back!
Couldn’t have been happier with the entire experience. The food was outstanding and the prices were below what I expected for authentic Italian food in Indiana! We will definitely be back!
Best Italian restaurant I've ever been to. Everything is made fresh, the people are very nice, and the service is quick.
Outstanding food. Good for intimate group conversation.
Great food. Owner friendly and service was good. Quaint place, small a a little noisy for our tastes but we’ll definitely go back.
The food is so fabulous, clearly made with skill and love! Prices not something I could afford every day, but definitely worth it! And besides, the servings are such that there was sufficient for next day's lunch! The mingling of flavors was wonderful, and everything so fresh! The manager is gregarious and welcoming. We will return!
Amazing service we were waited on by the head chef very friendly man would definitely recommend. Food was amazing this is our second time coming the head chef always ends up having special deals and was not disappointed food was great!
Always Great. Never actually ordered off the menu since the Specials are outstanding. Like to see what the chef comes up with that day.
Excellent authentic Italian fare. Wife had the lasagna and I had the spaghetti fritta de mare. Fresh made pasta and high quality ingredients. Highly recommend.
Great wine dinner on Jan 21!! Love how the staff interacts with the guests!
The ambiance is top level!!
Great food, good atmosphere. If you want authentic Italian food, this is the place to go!
Catello's Mozzarella Bar offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (317) 498-5906.
Catello's Mozzarella Bar is rated 4.9 stars by 252 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.