Catello's Mozzarella Bar
Excellent food with quick service. Burrata appetizer was absolutely fantastic.
Great as always. Never a bad meal
The only reason I gave it a 4 instead of 5 is because of the prices. We would come more if it wasn't quite so expensive.
Fabulous food and fabulous service. Bring many of our friends there. 5 STARS!!!!!
Authentic southern Italian food, lovely decor and ambiance. They only have about 10 tables so don't assume you can just walk in on a Fri / Sat night. The dining manager - Raffacle - was so personable and helpful . They have a nice wine list with good values or the high end choices too. Great time and great food!
We all enjoyed our food here. Hard to decide as there were several great choices. Homemade pasta and mozzarella were really good. Service slightly slow but we enjoyed having a leisurely dinner. It is pretty tight and a bit tough getting in and out of table seating, but cute. Would return.
Food was excellent, service top notch. I met my daughter there for lunch.
The homemade style of authentic Italian food is second to none. Outstanding!
Food was delicious! Service was great! Had a great time!
The food and service were both excellent. In fact, while we were enjoying our meal, we were discussing when we’d return and what we’d eat the next time. It’s a lovely place.
Great food. Authentic. Impressed. Appetizers were very good. Entree was superb. Strawberry custard Dessert was delicious. Definitely will return.
We LOVE Catello’s! We have been there for several date nights and we are always blown away by the incredible food. Everything is made fresh. And Chef Catello will come out to your table to greet you!
Fabulous!! Just fabulous!! Would recommend to one and all. Having been to Italy the whole meal is a great experience and so very good. Service is exceptional as well.
Wonderful fresh food. Great service! We had such a good time. We had appetizers, wine, main course, and deserts. For a couple it was $100 without tip.
You will definitely want to have a reservation as this amazing restaurant is very small. It is well worth the effort to get one! The most authentic Italian with delicious daily specials.
Very impressed with the quality of food and service. Wine was good and food was outstanding!!
Great service and incredibly delicious food. Inviting ambiance and great choices on the menu.
Excellent meal with excellent service. Highly recommended.
New Year’s Eve was a scam, a 5 course with nothing good to eat, regular menu would have been a lot better I am sure !
Everything we’ve had at Catello’s is wonderful! The service is exceptional and the atmosphere is great!
So good and never a disappointment
My husband and I had such a wonderful experience! The food and service were excellent! This was our first experience with authentic, fresh Italian food and cannot wait to return for another date night! Save room for dessert, the cannolis are delicious!
We drove from Indianapolis because we had read so much about the restaurant and it definitely lived up to the reputation. The food was amazing, from mozzarella, and buratta to the cannoli at the end. Great service, great food equals great experience. We will be back
Food was very good, atmosphere was very authentic, will return, service could maybe be a bit faster but no complaints.
This was our 3rd time at Catello’s and while I WILL be back again, I was a little disappointed in the service and food this time. My mushroom ravioli came out after a rather long wait and when it came it was half mushroom ravioli and half ricotta and spinach which. Was a little disappointing but still delicious.
So besides slow service and unexpected food, still a delicious meal and like I said, we will be back.
Great, authentic food in a small, quaint setting. Everything we ate was delicious.
Love this place! Have been 3 times already.. it never disappoints! Food is amazing and I love the Super Tuscan wine!!
The food is authentic and very tasty. The service is always first rate as well. It's one of our favorite places.
We did a Sunday evening office Christmas part with 18 people and everyone loved it. Many in the group had not been to Catello's previously said they were definitely going back, and soon. From the friendly greeting as we arrived to the handshake and goodbye, the service was excellent. Nearly everyone had a different menu item and all were impressed with both the taste and the portion size. Both the fresh and aged cheese and meat trays were completely consumed and everyone remarked about the fresh, homemade mozzarella. As I mentioned, we'll be back!
Impressed by all aspects of our dining experience. Authentic Italian cuisine. Will definitely return and highly recommend
We discovered this restaurant by accident, and we are so happy we did! The food was absolutely superb, and the service was great. A little hidden gem, we are already ready to go back again!
This IS Italy in Indiana! You can’t get any more authentic than this! Homemade cheeses and pastas! Top notch service too! Always MEMORABLE!
Wonderful atmosphere, the food was wonderful and the dessert was divine. I would highly recommend this place. I can't wait to go back.
They were incredibly rude. Horrible customer service. Won’t be back
Excellent food and service!
This was the absolute best meal I have had for a long time! The mozzarella was to die for! All of our meals were delicious. The wine list was awesome too!! I can’t wait to go back!!!
Intimate and relaxing . . . fantastic food and service.