Step outside of St Thomas and into Tuscany when you dine at PESCE iTALiAN. Offering the best in fresh In-House made Pasta, as it is made daily at our live action pasta station! The PESCE iTALiAN menu reflects the culinary sensibilities of the Italian people: rustic yet sophisticated.
Creative blends of herbs and spices, with a fusion of fresh ingredients and local seafood adds a contemporary twist to the elements of creating phenomenal Italian cuisine that has proudly served the East End of St Thomas for over a decade. Of course, another building block in creating the perfect experience is the friendly, dedicated staff that is knowledgeable of the beautiful relationship between food and wine – served with the warmth and hospitality of the Italian people. Our Wine Spectators Award Winning List is sure to offer many options to pair the perfect wine with any of the Italian delicacies on menu.
Food was AWESOME . Prices and portions were great. Will go again.
One of the best restaurants in St Thomas. Food was amazing we also ate at RAW the night before that was also good but by far Pesce was exceptional
This is one of the absolute best Italian restaurants I’ve ever eaten in. The food was amazing. Well prepared with great flavor. The service was awesome. Great wine and cocktail list. It’s a “must eat” restaurant when visiting St. Thomas.
Both my order and my wife’s order were fantastic and easily enough for two meals. The caesar salad was very good. We like to think we know a bit about Italian cooking as we are from St. Louis and regularly eat on the “Hill” which is a historically Italian neighborhood known for authentic Italian cooking and the food at this restaurant was on par if not better than what we could get in St. Louis.
Outstanding food and service.
Perfect. I proposed here
Rishi was really professional food was really good
Amazing scallops appetizer and the pasta is delicious! A must try restaurant in STT!
Great Food! Great atmosphere, but the service was very poor. Kudos to the hostess and busser they went out of their way to help after seeing the poor service from the server. Overall Great restaurant but they should definitely look into their servers.
btw my servers' name was Robin...
The food was incredible. We had pasta dishes (shrimp Alfredo and Shrimp carbonara)
The dinners were delicious. I had truffled pappardelle with shrimp and it was delightful. Service was good. It’s a bit on the pricey side, but that’s the case for most restaurants on St. Thomas. It was an enjoyable evening.
Great food. Grat menu. Service was a little slow for a tuesday. Men's room sink was art work. But bathrooms are small. I would definitely go back.
Amazing food and service. Would go again
The food was delicious, but the service is beyond poor and some of the waitstaff just plain rude. It is a shame because the food is great. Unfortunately this has happened again and again - every time (5) I have visited this restaurant over the last 3 to 4 years.
Had a few issues with service. But we straightened it out. Server wasn’t really paying attention. We tried three dishes. My husbands Parm was maybe a 6 on a 1-10 scale. However, the mushroom Pappardelle was definitely excellent. We decided to try dessert. Creme Brûlée although the Crusted sugar top was done excellently the Brûlée was watery. It was our Anniversary and I told the restaurant on “remarks” on reservation but no mention.
I guess that part doesn’t work. The pasta was good but. It the homemade pasta we are used to in NJ.
Great food and place a for a date.
The only reason I gave less than 5 for service is because our server didn’t have his mask on properly. Everyone else in the restaurant (customers and employees) respected the mask mandate on the island but our server had his mask extremely loose where it didn’t cover his nose at all and was very ill fit on his mouth. To the point where when he was explaining things to us we were uncomfortable with him standing and us being seated.
Everything else was fantastic. I would go there again. The food was outstanding.
Straight to the point Italian dining. The ambience was amazing, staff was very catering and friendly. The Lemoncello/Tini be careful though. Very sweet and medicine like. But overall amazing place.
Absolutely superb. Super friendly staff and nothing rushed.
Food was OK. Service was great, but food took way too long
Never disappoints!! Always good!!
I decided to come here based on reviews from a travel group via Facebook. The menu was not overwhelming which is something I love! They provided warm bread and dip that my son absolutely loved! We also had bruschetta that was very good! My 11 year old really enjoyed the Chicken Alfredo, and lava cake for dessert. I had fish stew that was on special. It was pretty good! Our server was attentive and wasn’t too over the top. I also appreciate when I’m able to enjoy my meal without having to be interrupted too much. I would recommend coming here again. It was nice!
Welcoming atmosphere. Fun cocktails, good wine list, appetizers and salads were excellent. The roasted beet salad was wonderful. The fish entrees were very much enjoyed, especially the salmon. I wanted the snapper picata, but they were out. The Italian entrees were lacking. Veal was heavily breaded and overcooked. Asked for Cappellini instead of spaghetti, got spaghetti, also overcooked. Chose not to stay for dessert.
We had an issue with our reservation at another restaurant so walked-in hoping for a table. The restaurant was booked but they were very gracious in trying to help. Within 30 minutes they were able to accommodate us and we had a fabulous dinner with excellent service. Highly recommend for authentic Italian cuisine.
Delicious meal and great service! We really enjoyed the flatbread special and the chocolate lava cake was amazing!
The food, wine, and atmosphere was amazing! Would definitely recommend!!
Below average food, good wine list but they don't have even 50 % of the list . good service. I'm not interested in going back
Without a doubt our favorite restaurant so far, in St Thomas. Food, drinks, ambiance & service were all 5 star. And to make our opinion more valid, we are Italian. The calamari, eggplant, marinara sauce, as well as the cocktails, were all on point!
we ha a nice evening and dinner- food was great, service was a bit slow at 7:00 pm
Good ambiance, attentive servers and yummy food!! Would definitely dine there again!
Very good food and very good service. Getting seated takes a few minutes and the restaurant is a little warm. Other than that, we dined here twice during our week long trip and both experiences were great!
One of the best places we visited on St. Thomas. The food was outstanding and the service among the best. From the delightful hostess to the friendly and attentive server. Kids and adults enjoyed our visit. Highly recommend.
We are on vacation and this was a request by one of our group. The restaurant was understaffed and the menus had been paired back considerably. The food was good but took hours to complete the meal and though we asked at the beginning for a check per couple they didn’t do that and struggled with splitting the check.
Great service and food was great! Chicken parm was amazing!
Amazing food !!
Great food and our server Will was amazing.
The fresh pasta was delicious and the service was excellent. Could not ask for a better Dinning experience in RedHook!
Service was fantastic. very friendly and accommodating.
Pesce Italian offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (340) 714-7874 ext. 13.
Pesce Italian is rated 4.3 stars by 509 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.