- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Coconut Tres Leches
White cake soaked in three milks, toasted meringue, toasted coconut flakes
Had brunch for the first time! Absolutely amazing. I couldn’t decide on what dish we wanted so we tried a bunch of things on the menu and one thing was better than the next. HIGHLY recommend. The eggs Benedict and churro waffle are actually heaven. Margarita are fantastic. Can’t wait to come back!!
Great place, delicious food, wonderful service. Eduardo was our waiter, did a wonderful job!
We were told to take our dessert to go because Open Table analytics said we were at the table too long.
The food was delicious and The service was great.
Always a great experience! Can't stop coming back for more
This has to be the best new spot on main st, the service is immaculate as well as the food, and don’t even get me started on the drinks. The owner was very friendly and came over to our table to ensure everything was great and me and all my friends definitely look forward to becoming regulars here!
We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your experience with us! We look forward to having you here again!
Carolynn was our server, very genuine and personable! Good was amazing will definitely come again!
So happy to hear it! Cannot wait for your next visit!
Is a weird mixt of Mexican food and don't know what else ,Mexican restaurant is not ,the rice had a strong garlic taste and black beans ??my food was half ok and the rest not good and COLD .Very expensive and little portions,and not good food.
Beautiful restaurant food was good, only real issue was not one person was wearing a mask in the restaurant not the hostess waiters bartenders etc
Everything was amazing. Food was delicious and the drinks are great! Good atmosphere. We had a great night out.
We love to hear that! Hope we see you at Pecado again very soon!
I went with my husband to celebrate his birthday, and we found a new favorite spot! The food was great, and the drinks were excellent (I definitely recommend the Paloma!). I had the enchiladas suizas, and my husband had the carne asada tacos. The churros were the best we’ve ever had! Our waitress was very nice and attentive. The noise level is high, but this didn’t bother us at all, but might not be ideal for those who like a quieter dinner. Great new spot in Bayshore, we will definitely go back!
Thank you so much for dining with us! We hope that your husband had a wonderful birthday and that we see both again soon!
My husband and I went here for dinner & bumped into some of our friends. The staff was beyond accommodating in seating us all together with short notice. The food was incredible! We had the 40 oz. tomahawk steak special. Best steak we’ve had! We will definitely be back again.
I hardly ever take pictures of my food. Tonight I kinda wish I did! We went to Pecado in Bay Shore! Awesome experience! Our server was Carolann and she was one of my favorites EVER!! ❤️The food was off the hook! We tried the wings and the plantanos for Apps..😋so good! Hubs had the enchiladas and I had shrimp tacos..my mouth is still watering thinking about how good they were and he loved the enchiladas! Of course we had to have dessert.. he ordered the Tres Leches( heavenly, if you go you HAVE to try it 😍, I got the churros..also very good. But truth be told I want to steal my husband’s dessert! Cannot wait to go back! My new favorite place! Ian was the best host! ❤️ — at Pecado Mexican.
My in-laws enjoyed it a lot! Happy to hear. One of my favorite restaurants in Bay Shore village.
We are ecstatic to hear that! Hope we see you all again soon!
Went there in NYD for mine and my father’s birthday and got treated with the utmost respect. The drinks were amazing and the food was even better. Can’t wait to return soon!
Thank you so much for joining us! We hope to see you again real soon!
Everything was great! We came a little early & we were seated right away. Food was amazing & drinks were made perfectly. Definitely will be coming back!
Glad you had such a great time with us! Can't wait to have you here again!
Amazing food the barbacoa tacos we’re delicious, food was hot, service was impeccable. Finish your food and someone was there to take it away. Will definitely be returning !!
So happy to hear you enjoyed your experience with us! Cannot wait to have you back!
Great food. Great Service. Nice place Will definitely go back.
Thank you so much for stopping by and for the review!
Amazing food!! Clean and beautiful open space! Great staff and the owner was personable and inviting. Will go back here so many times. We loved every moment!
We appreciate the review! Come back and dine with us again soon!
Great food Great Service Fantastic drinks. We will definitely be back
So happy you enjoyed your experience with us! Can't wait for your next visit!
Food was great! Bartender was awesome! We will absolutely be back!
That's what we like to hear! So happy that you enjoyed your time here at Pecado! Come back again soon!
Service was really nice, food came out right away and the drinks were awesome
Excellent food, service & cocktails. Owner came by to see how everything was going & I congratulated him on a great experience.
So happy you enjoyed your time with us! We hope to see you walk through our doors again soon!
Great food and service. We enjoyed our night out at Pecado and will definitely be back. Thank you!!!
We love to hear this! Can't wait fo your next visit!
We went once and I’ve returned five or six times in the last month. The food in this place is incredible, the service greetings and drinks are stupendous. We eat out a lot and will come here time and time again. Best of luck to this new restaurant in BayShore.
We are so thrilled to have you as a returning customer! We look forward to more great times with you in the future!
The food was very good and the drinks were strong. Definitely a good place to eat
Thank you so much for visiting us! We appreciate the review and hope to see you again soon!
Birthday dinner for large group
The food was delicious and the service was incredible, almost on the verge of too attentive but not quite at that level. It was a Wednesday so it was slow, but still appreciated the attention and quick service all around. Drinks were delicious as well.
Got the Mahi Mahi for dinner, wife got enchiladas mole, queso fundido and elote as appetizers. Everything was very good or great, would definitely recommend. Prices are a tad high, particularly for the drinks and apps than entrees, but at least you get bang for your buck!
We are glad you enjoyed your time with us! Come back again soon!
I brought my girlfriend here for our two year anniversary. I found the atmosphere and decor very appealing as did my girlfriend. Staff were super helpful and positive vibes flowed throughout the evening. The hostess greeted us with a “happy anniversary” when we arrived and when we departed. Our server Danielle was absolutely wonderful and helpful ensuring we were provided the best customer service possible. Food and drink were out of this world awesome and delicious. Great vegetarian option for my girlfriend and I enjoyed the chicken fajitas. Definitely a plus in my book and we will definitely return here.
We are so thrilled to hear about your experience with us! We can't wait for you to come back to give more of our dishes a try!
Best food I had in so long! Everything was amazing. The carne asada melts in your mouth and the coconut tres leches was the best cake I have ever had!! Def coming back :) & kid friend is a plus my toddler licked his chicken quesadilla and rice plate clean. Thanks for a great experience!
We are so happy to hear about your experience with us! We cannot wait for your next visit!
Food was really really good. My husband and I rarely agree on restaurants because I am a vegetarian and he basically only eats meat. Match made in heaven… this restaurant had stuff for both of us and both our appetizers and entrees were outstanding. We will definitely be back. The only small criticism either of us could make is that the beer selection isn’t great and the margarita was mediocre. Don’t let any of that deter you from going though. You will not be sorry.
The food was sub par. Ordered a steak burrito and it was just ok. There was only 1 server for the entire restaurant which made service very slow. Waiter was very pleasant and friendly when we interacted with him.
Excellent service and delicious food!
We are thrilled to hear this! Come back again soon!
Everything was great! From the music, to the wall decorations and everything in between, it was great. Food and the cocktails are beautifully prepared and served in generous portions. The staff attention was immediate and very accommodating. We will def return.
Thank you for visiting us! We are thrilled to hear about your experience! We hope to see you again soon!
As a mexican/American and having lived in Mexico for a few years, this is truly delicious, authentic food! The owner is also a very genuinely nice guy. The wait staff is so sweet and attentive. What a place!
We love to hear it! Thank you so much for coming by, we hope to have you back here again very soon!
Service was very good. Drinks were tasty and food was enjoyable. I would return
We appreciate the review! We hope to have you back here again soon!
Food is super fresh and delicious. Guacamole, prickly pear Mojito and warm stuffed Churro will blow your mind! Would highly recommend.
Thrilled to hear it! Come back again soon!
Our food came out 5 seconds after we ordered it, then was told my manager to leave because other people had to be seated. The server was nice and attentive though. I would not return. Felt very rushed.
Second time dining here! And the food never disappoints! Can’t wait to go back and try more things on there menu. Drinks are also fabulous
Always a pleasure having you here! Thanks so much for your continued support! We cannot wait for your next visit!
Great meal. Wonderful service by Eduardo and really good drinks. Will definitely come back!
We could not be happier to hear this! We hope to have you back here again soon!
Pecado Mexican offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (631) 992-7717.
Pecado Mexican is rated 4.6 stars by 109 OpenTable diners.
Pecado Mexican does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://pecadomexican.cardfoundry.com/giftcards.php.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.