Paul Martin's American Grill - Westlake Village
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 5:00PM - 6:00PM 8:00PM - 9:00PM
Mon - Thu 5:00PM - 6:00PM 8:30PM - 10:15PM
Fri - Sat 5:00PM - 6:00PM 8:30PM - 11:00PM
Good Food, Very nice cordial and attentive service
Decent wine list by bottle as well as glass
Great place to meet friends. A bit noisy for a quiet dinner. Food very good, service great, good ambiance. Would recommend for group meals.
Have been going for years! The food started off great, good quality and good flavor. Now it’s very average. They need to switch up the menu a little too. They’ve been serving most of the same dishes for years and the menu is limited as it is. I notice it is not as busy as it used to be. Manager please take notice!
Thanksgiving dinner menu was impressive but the food quality wasn’t that good. Food plate was too hot too touch, but the actual food was not that hot. Stuffing was too salty and overcooked. Needed more hot gravy and it took forever to get it. We were there later, at 7:30 pm, and place was not busy. The turkey tasted more like a turkey roll and not freshly sliced off the roasted bird. Too much salt in everything. Dessert was ok but no need for caramel sauce as it was too sweet. We’ve been coming to this place since they opened as we live very close by, but we were disappointed tonight.
Pros: Very Friendly & accommodating attentive staff especially for having to work on a holiday. Everyone was extremely nice which made it work. Thanksgiving dinner: delicious green beans, mashed potatoes, yam/sweet potato’s, fabulous onion soup (they ran out of the mushroom which was disappointing), salad, delicious cranberry sauce, special pear martini was excellent. Cons: Turkey very, very salty with no special seasonings could have been far better. Bland but salty. Gravy bland. Dressing/stuffing just ok made with brioche which was odd. Pumpkin cheesecake entirely too sugared and sweet could not eat. No gluten free options which is out of date/touch with other similar restaurants. Music played in this establishment was extremely annoying especially for a more elegant meal on a holiday. Ambiance is very nice but somewhat ruined by the poor choice in music.
Thanksgiving dinner was delicious. Service was great. Signature cocktail pear martini was amazing!My husband had traditional Turkey dinner and I had Halibut. It was nice to have choices on the holiday. Great experience we will be back
Best Thanksgiving meal. Enjoyed every bit and I feel was very reasonable. Would go back.
Food and wine delicious excellent service including Ari the manager goes above and beyond to give the most gracious service and dining experience
Wow, thank you for the kind words. We will definitely share your experience with Ari. Thank you!
Limited wait staff to take care of entire restaurant. Dirty dishes on tables throughout restaurant, while manager seen walking around on his cell phone Seems like this location may be closing soon ... that was the vibe!
Excellent service and the food was fabulous!
Gift card promotion has a 24 hour waiting period before you can use it. They do not tell you that when you purchase it.
Nice wines-by-the-glass selection. Lovely, efficient and capable server. They were out of 3 of our top menu choices. The restaurant is noisy due to all the hard surfaces and number of tables/proximity to the bar. But the food was very tasty, especially (and surprisingly) the vegetarian quinoa bowl.
We go here all the time. Love the cocktails. Food is good and comes out on time.
I normally do not like cauliflower but the roasted cauliflower appetizer that my wife ordered was great. Enjoyed the rest of the meal.
Restaurant was half empty yet after 15 minutes of waiting at our table no one bothered to ask us about drink or even bother to say hello when we were at a front booth. The waiters and waitresses walked by us several times when we would try and get their attention for water at a minimum. No one came so we got up and left letting the host staff know that no one came. They tried to see if we would wait but by that time it was just time to move on. Luckily Mastro’s had a table available down the street which had hands down awesome service unlike Paul Martin. We have dined at this Paul Martin well over a couple dozen times over the last 4 years but will not be back. The food is never consistent and the service is always hit or miss as proven tonight. We will not be back despite the great location. So long.
I am a vegan person and very picky. However their food exceeded my expectations.
The meal was very good. Easy to get to and parking was fine. Service was excellent. Pricing was a little higher than I like but fine for the type of meal. It was a little bit of a wait for the dinner but since everything is made fresh it is understandable. Overall a very good experience.
Went for my husband’s birthday & it was a wonderful experience. Our waiter was incredibly nice and attentive and the food was excellent. will definitely be coming back.
We had a wonderful dinning experience 10/27/19. The service, food and hospitality were excellent. My thanks to the staff for making the evening great!
We have dined here for many years and always enjoyed our meals. This time the meal was just mediocre. The halibut was bland and the sauce was also bland. My wife originally ordered the halibut tacos for $21 as shown on the menu but was told that there was a surprise up change of $4. I objected that the dish would not be as clearly shown on the menu. She opted to take the halibut entree on the menu. The house salad was also mediocre. We spent over $90 for our meal and expected more for the price. The service was satisfactory and the server was friendly but too busy to be more attentive.
The steak and the bacon wrapped shrimps were uncharacteristically salty during this visit so the dinner was a disaster even though the server was excellent. Not sure if I want to go back again ever.
Wife loved her brick chicken. Calamari was salty. I asked for my burger medium but got well done. Fries were salty too. Banana cream pie was bland.
Amazing! Everything from the food to the service was outstanding. We can’t wait to go back!!
As usual, the food and service were excellent
Lovely dinner The food was outstanding. However, I ordered the blackened ribeye and it was not quite cooked to how I ordered it. It was positively raw inside. I sent it back and they gave me a new steak which was cooked the exact same way. I ended up taking the raw-ish ribeye home and cooked it for dinner the next night. Very yummy!
A bit pricier than before
Starting with the positive, our server was excellent. However, the Margarita was mostly ice. Food was room temperature at best and burnt in the outside - we expected better for a $50 steak. Ambiance was poor, we had to get re-seated, as the table was unstable and chairs too low, to the very back booth. We used to go here regularly but it seems the quality overall has dropped. Disappointed!
Food was generally good. My wife thought her salad was a bit over dressed.
Overall all I thought everything was nice.
Good service, good food very good place to have dinner
I dined with an old friend and we had Graciela S as our server. Right from the start she was sharp and unfriendly. When we asked about a special she was rude, she was pushy and short with us the entire meal. After the meal, she just walked by and put our bill on the table, not even offering dessert or saying a word! This was my friends first experience at Paul Martins and I doubt, she'll return. I've dined at your restaurant several times and I know this isn't a usual experience, so I'll try again, hoping not to be seated in her section.
great food, great service, great company. overall wonderful experience.
Good for everyday dining or special occasions. We met our investment advisor here for a meeting too! It’s where our kids told us they’d be having their first baby. Love this place
Our pre-movie dinner was terrific! Our delicious food arrived in plenty of time for our movie at the nearby theater. The server, Santiago, took care of every request with a smile and the greeter, Dino, found us a quiet booth so we could all catch up after not seeing one another for awhile. We had a great experience and will come again soon.
Portion of salmon to small. 6 small leafs of spinach. Not worth the money.