I sort of forgot about this all-time classic and we loved everything. We will be back for sure. Wonderful experience delicious food awesome service and inside is super romantic

Solid choice in Scottsdale. Seated immediately. Salmon dish and braised short ribs very good. Service attentive without being bothersome. Definitely will be a repeat.

My first visit to Paul Martin’s! The food and the service were both excellent!!
Had a wonderful time!!

We ordered the deviled eggs appetizer. It was amazing. The best French dip I have ever had...hands down. To top off the evening...the butter cake...to die for. Courtney was our server. He was awesome, quick, kind, and attentive. My birthday was very enjoyable. We will be back...we will recommend.....looking forward to trying different cuisines.
Thank you again,
The Weatherbie's

The server pulled the plate from my side before my dinner date was even close to being done. As a place who fancies themselves as being above average, everyone knows you don’t pull a plate until the lady is done. It’s as if they forgot basic manners in dinning. Overall the food was on par, nothing to knock your socks off. It’s average for a Friday dinner but nothing to drive across town for.

Everything OK as normal. A bit loud near the kitchen....Blackened hallibut special was great.

Always a great place to dine with good food. Thank you.

Excellent service, delicious food, great ambience!

First time there and Steven was a great server! Definitely made my first experience one to remember will be going back again!

Stacy was fantastic !

Never had been there before. Buddy and I couldn't decide between 2 different chicken meals and decided he'd get one and I the other. The wonderful server split both dinners for us on separate plates. That's five star service. And, both dinners were awesome!!

Waiter didn't come back to check on us or fill water glasses. Good was good and friendly staff.

Our server Brandon is a shining example of the excellent service you receive at Paul Martins. The door and drinks were (as always) excellent. The effort the staff places on customers and cleaning after customers makes this a extremely safe place to go

Good restaurant but nothing special and over priced for the basic service and food offerings available at lower scale restaurants.

Great food. Josh was a great waiter. We'll be back for sure.

Very disappointed! Ordered drinks and then appetizer and enjoyed all. However, after waiting 30 minutes for our entrees, we left because no one cared about us not receiving our entrees. Manager on duty did nothing to address the issue or fix it. Unfortunate, since we were celebrating a birthday and, although we enjoyed Paul Martin’s in the past, we will not return. Walked across the patio to Blanco’s to have dinner, which was yummy!

Poorly cooked and overpriced

We have eaten there many times and enjoyed it. This time they were very slow and my wife’s food (salmon) arrived cold. Meanwhile we shared my food waiting for a second serving for my wife.
The food itself with the second serving for my wife was good, but the the whole pace of the dinner was wrecked.
All in all very poor service and great disappointment.
Paul Martin Fleming would be embarrassed.

Excellent! Anthony and Courtney are incredible!!!

My husband and I were in town to visit our sons who recently graduated from college. We are from San Diego and did not know too much about the restaurants in the area and where to go for a nice dinner. We found Paul Martin’s on OpenTable. We made a Valentine’s Day dinner reservation. We were about 20 minutes early as we thought it was would be very busy. The host smiled and found our reservation. Since we were early he offered us a seat at a high bar table. We went to the bar to have a drink while we waited for our table. The bartenders there were very friendly and helpful. We were moved to our table on the patio area timely. The heater was just the right temperature so as not to be too hot or too cold. The server was friendly and attentive. My husband and I both ordered the ribeye steak. It was soooo good! I think it was 10oz but it was seriously amazing! The manager greeted us and several tables ensuring we were ok. It was an overall fantastic experience. If in the area again we will certainly be back.

Great experience, anytime I have the chance I will absolutely visit Paul Martin’s!

Valentines dinner
It was busy but the service was great. Manager came over twice to check on us. Food was fabulous. This was our first time here. Would definitely go again.

We had the special which was the surf and turf. Deviled eggs for the appetizer and the filet. Everything was fabulous, truly one of the best meals we have ever had. Amazing service and fun atmosphere !

Server was great.

A friend and I enjoyed a nice night on the patio.
Steve, our waiter, was attentive and kind. He was sure to check in but did not rush us. Loved the deviled eggs sans bacon . Greens were fresh and delicious. We both enjoyed a sea bass encore that was simple yet perfectly tasty.
Thanks Steve. You are a sweetheart!

Food was outstanding and enjoyed the moment/time there on Valentines Day

Great meal and ambiance. We ask for Courtney - he is a tremendous server.

Great Valentine’s Day dinner!

My kids and I was very happy to be at Paul Martin's the staff was very friendly the food was delicious. I'm planning to back there for my birthday coming pretty soon.

Good service and a very good meal.

The deviled eggs were really good but the food was just okay. It didn't make such an impression that I would be running to go back unfortunately. We didn't seem that our server paid too much close attention to us having to depend on the managers to get us boxes and also our check. More than likely will not be back.

Great food & atmosphere at good value. I had the fried chicken & my wife had the salmon. Both were fantastic.

Was delicious great place

Solid food but nothing exceptional. American Grill distinction is accurate: no unique flavors or twists on comfort favorites but reliable and good

It was Valentines weekend so was understandably busy but we didn't care for the rushed service.
The quinoa (I added chicken) was bland, my husband's salmon was good not great, however the mushroom soup was delicious. Overpriced wine by the glass. We really enjoyed coming here for happy hour in the past and sitting at community tables where service was always great. Maybe that will come back some day. In the meantime, think we will dine elsewhere.

Great service and outstanding food! We had a great night out and were surprised for the restaurant to check my Open Table stats and surprise me with a birthday treat a week early. Top Notch!!

Burger and seafood dish were overcooked.

Always a great meal. We have eaten here many times and have always loved it. Food and service always excellent.

It was a valentines day dinner. We made reservations and got there about 20 minutes early unfortunately the main inside dining was booked so we were assigned a table at the overflow area which didn’t have the ambience of what we were used to, we are returning patrons and enjoy eating in the individual booths which are cozy. Service was great and the food was delicious as usual.

file:///var/mobile/Library/SMS/Attachments/72/02/C0DDA370-1EA1-47D3-AAB8-99CAFDAA07D1/IMG_7488.JPG

Excellent service but food was average or below. Salmon dish was $35 or so, tasted like something frozen and portion size was small. On a few spinach leaves. Very disappointing. So many great places in Scottsdale, skip this one.