Paul & Jimmy's Ristorante
Get it delivered
Mediterranean Sea Bass with Fresh Herbs
Spaghetti alla Carbonara
Pancetta & Onions In Cream Sauce
The frutti de fare appetizer was very fresh and delicious, followed by the classic creamy burrata! We also thoroughly enjoyed our main pasta entrees very much! All of the staff was friendly and courteous. We even had a chance to meet the owner! A fantastic experience overall!
Paul & Jimmy’s is the perfect spot to enjoy a superb Italian-American meal. You can’t go wrong here! Everything is fresh, incredibly tasty, and always cooked on point. This is a top spot for us and we always look forward to our next visit!
A gem of a local restaurant. A great family owned vibe and the chef is the owner's son. The restaurant has been there for 50 years and my wife's family who lived nearby used to go there regularly. I am surprised I never knew of the place although I have often eaten in the area. I will definitely use this place for dinner with friends and family.
Love this place! Delicious food and wonderful atmosphere
Very good food & service. The food quality is consistently good. The ownership sets a very professional tone and everyone that works there follows that lead.
The waiter was scatter brained but the food was really good and the ambiance was solid!
I think we all would have enjoyed it more if it wasn’t so noisy. We couldn’t hear each other speak.
Food was good. Service could use a little help. Seemed to have waited some time before our order was taken and then again when we waited for the bill.
Fabulous food and friendly service!
Fantastic great service great food, highly recommend for the best Italian food !!
Great food, great ambiance, great service.
Excellent Christmas Eve Dinner! Would definitely recommend for families with children!
Always a great meal , great ambiance....Enjoy! Been there a number of times over the last couple of years and always the same, Excellent...
Great local place with excellent service. Loved the appetizer selection that is on the chalkboard when you walk in. Fantastic marinara sauce! Now I know why there were jars for sale near the hostess table. On the critical side: meatballs needed breadcrumbs and seasoning. The carbonara had way too much cream and not enough pancetta. I would return but stick to menu items that have the excellent red sauce!
Why didn’t I get points for December 14,2019?
It was so crowded and noisy that I should get double points for putting up with the worst meal we ever had in Paul and jimmy’s.
Please credit the points.Thank you
Always a good bet !
Family holiday dinner
The food was terrific, as was the service. I’m not sure I would return at prime time as the noise level was deafening. I could hardly hear the person sitting next to me let alone the one across the table.
I will consider returning either earlier or later but not at 8 pm.
Fantastic service, great food. Can't wait to go back.
Such a great find! We had a cozy little high top by front the window, back in the dining room was louder- but a happy loud! Food was amazing, traditional pastas, so yummy! Can’t wait to go back! Thank you!!!
The food and the service both were excellent, as usual. Unfortunately, the noise level became uncomfortably high. Next time, we'll go earlier and hope for a quieter experience.
We always love coming to Paul and Jimmy’s. The food is always great and everyone is so friendly and attentive. We were entertaining out of town guests that evening and they loved it! We’ll be back again soon.
Each time we come to Paul and Jimmy’s we are never disappointed. The food is amazing and the service is excellent! Definitely one of our favorite restaurants.
Consistently great experience for the holidays.
We have been coming for years.
Had a wonderful dinner with a variety of courses all delicious! Love this place!
Great food and great experience! Love the place! It has nice decorations and I love the menu! It's a really nice place! You can bring your BFF!
We had a baby shower and we loved everything about this place. The food was excellent and we can not wait to come back for dinner.
Warm,inviting and delicious neighborhood gem!Best minestrone we have ever had....including Italy!
Excellent variety of choices on their menu and also a very nice prix fixe !
It was a great dinner with friends. Couldn’t have asked for a better restaurant! I will return next time I'm in New York.
Great dinner for family with young kids.
Haven’t been here in a long time. Did not disappoint. Great food and service.
Great place to eat ! Awesome food ! Great service I’ll be back 😊
Love this spot. Old school authentic dining
This is a classic Italian restaurant that makes you feel right at home when you walk in. Amazing service and fantastic food make it an overall wonderful dining experience for all ages. The aperol margarita is a must as is the gnocci. We will definitely be back!
My husband and I celebrated my birthday with daughter and her family including 2 young grandchildren. We enjoyed the food, service and ambiance, was perfect for the occasion.
This restaurant is a regular with our family - we have been coming to Paul & Jimmy's for a long time and we still love everything about it. A neighborhood gem! Whenever we have guests from the area or out of the town this is where they want to go for lunch or dinner.
A hidden gem