Papa Luigi's Pizza

Fresh From Our Garden

Salad Dressings: Italian, French, Ranch, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Parmesan Peppercorn, Creamy Italian, Greek, Caesar, Fat Free Ranch, Fat Free French.

• Mediterranean Salad8,50 $

  A bed of fresh lettuce topped with a boneless grilled chicken breast, tomatoes, onions, feta cheese, Greek olives and Greek dressing. Served with garlic bread.

• Grilled Chicken Salad*8,50 $

  A bed of fresh lettuce topped with a boneless grilled chicken breast, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives and mozzarella cheese. Served with garlic bread.

• Chef Salad8,50 $

  Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, mozzarella cheese, mushrooms, green peppers and pepperoni. Served with garlic bread.

• Italian Tomato and Onion Blend*6,50 $

  Frank & Josie's Favorite! Fresh tomatoes, onions, oregano, olive oil, vinegar and Italian spices. Served with a bread basket.

• Shrimp Salad6,50 $

  Fresh crisp lettuce topped with fresh shrimp, tomatoes, cucumbers and onions. Served with a bread basket.

• Caesar Salad6,50 $

  Fresh romaine lettuce with imported parmesan cheese, croutons tossed in Caeser dressing. Served with garlic bread.

  • With grilled chicken or shrimp8,50 $

Sides

• Bread Basket3,50 $

• Beer Battered French Fries3,50 $

• Crinkle Cut French Fries3,50 $

• Broasted Potatoes3,50 $

• Baked Potato2,75 $

• House Salad3,50 $

• Soups

  • Bowl3,25 $
  • Cup2,25 $

• Pepperoncini1,50 $

• Mixed Vegetables3,25 $

• Red Sauce

  • Small1,25 $
  • Large2,00 $

• Tartar Sauce

  • Small1,25 $
  • Large2,00 $

• Garlic Bread2,00 $

• Side Caesar Salad4,50 $

• Cole Slaw

  • Small1,25 $
  • Large2,00 $

• Barbecue Sauce1,25 $

• Extra Dressing1,25 $

• Meatball2,50 $

• Chicken Breast3,50 $

• Hand Breaded Veal Filet3,50 $

• Italian Sausage Patty3,50 $

• Pasta with Papa's Signature Marinara Sauce or Garlic Butter Sauce3,25 $

• Alfredo Sauce

  • Small2,25 $
  • Large4,50 $

• Extra Portion of Cod3,00 $

Appetizers

• Garlic Bread

  • With Papa's Signature Marinara sauce3,50 $
  • With cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce4,50 $

• Mama Maria's Buttery Garlic Bread4,50 $

  Our homemade bread smothered with 100% butter and baked to perfection.

• Sicilian Garlic Bread5,50 $

  Our famous garlic bread prepared with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce, fresh tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and Italian seasonings.

• Pizza Bread5,99 $

  Open faced Italian bread with mozzarella cheese, Papa's Signature Marinara sauce and one topping of your choice.

• Mozzarella Sticks5,99 $

  Tory's Favorite! Served with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Breaded Mushrooms5,99 $

• Buffalo Wings6,99 $

  Our original lightly spiced, lightly coated & sauce free jumbo chicken wings.

• Breaded Calamari7,99 $

  BESTA AT FESTA ITALIANA! Hand cut, fresh, tender calamari lightly coated and deep fried until golden brown.

• Jalapeño Poppers5,99 $

  Choice of cream cheese or cheddar cheese.

• Sicilian Eggplant6,99 $

  Voted # 1 in southeastern Wisconsin! Our fresh cut, hand made deep fried eggplant served with lemon wedges and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

  • Half order4,99 $

• Breaded Cauliflower5,99 $

• Chicken Platter Combo10,99 $

  Includes Original Buffalo Wings, Chicken Tenders and Cheese Bread. Served with ranch and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Mac-n-Cheese Bites4,99 $

  Pockets of creamy macaroni and cheese, battered and fried to a golden brown.

• Eggplant Combo7,99 $

  A classic combination of our fresh cut, hand made, deep fried famous eggplant, paired with our cheesy garlic bread served with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Onion Rings4,99 $

• Chicken Tenders5,99 $

• Toasted Bruschetta5,99 $

  A wonderful blend of fresh diced tomato, red onion, garlic, basil and Italian seasonings, toasted together on Italian bread with melted mozzarella cheese and sprinkled with parmesan cheese.

• Papa's Combo10,99 $

  Sal's Favorite! Breaded Mushrooms, Breaded Cauliflower, Mozzarella Sticks and Jalapeño Poppers. Served with ranch and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

Jumbo Buffalo Wings

Sauces: Thai Chili, Spicy BBQ, BBQ, Medium, Hot.

• Bone-in Wings

  Jumbo wings cooked to perfection served plain or tossed in your choice of sauce.

  • 8 Wings6,99 $
  • 12 Wings9,99 $
  • 16 Wings12,99 $
  • 24 Wings17,99 $

• Boneless Wings6,99 $

  10-12 tender chunks of all white breast meat breaded, cooked to perfection and tossed in your choice of sauce.

Thin-N-Crispy Pizza

10" Gluten-free Cheese Pizza $11.45. Toppings: Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Broccoli, Jalapeños, Green Olives, Canadian Bacon, Pineapple, Pepperoncini, Anchovies, Bacon, Ground Beef, Shrimp, Chicken.

• 10" Gluten-free Cheese Pizza11,45 $

• Cheese

  • 8"9,45 $
  • 12"11,45 $
  • 14"12,45 $
  • 16"13,45 $

• Topping Price

  • 8"1,00 $
  • 12"1,25 $
  • 14"1,50 $
  • 16"1,75 $

• Hand Tossed Crust

  • 8"1,00 $
  • 12"1,25 $
  • 14"1,50 $
  • 16"1,75 $

• Thick Crust

  • 8"1,25 $
  • 12"1,50 $
  • 14"2,00 $
  • 16"2,50 $

• Extra Sauce

  • 8"1,00 $
  • 12"1,25 $
  • 14"1,50 $
  • 16"1,75 $

• Extra Cheese

  • 8"1,25 $
  • 12"1,50 $
  • 14"1,75 $
  • 16"2,00 $

Specialty Pizzas

• Papa's Veggie Pizza

  Cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and black olives.

  • 8"10,65 $
  • 12"15,65 $
  • 14"16,65 $
  • 16"17,65 $

• Pocket Pizza7,99 $

  Mozzarella cheese, Papa's Signature Marinara sauce and one topping sealed inside a folded pizza crust and cooked to perfection.

• Papa's Special*

  Cheese, sausage, mushrooms and onions.

  • 8"10,95 $
  • 12"14,75 $
  • 14"15,75 $
  • 16"16,75 $

• Papa's Deluxe

  Cheese, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, pepperoni, black olives and onions.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Chicken Alfredo Pizza*

  Alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese and tender chunks of chicken breast.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Hawaiian Pizza

  Papa's famous pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese, fresh pineapple and Canadian bacon.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Bigga Macka

  1000 Island dressing, ground beef, lettuce, diced pickles, diced onions with a blend of American and mozzarella cheese.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Meat Lover's Pizza

  Pepperoni, sausage, ground beef and Canadian bacon.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Sicilian Pizza

  Based with olive oil, topped with mozzarella cheese, sausage and Papa's secret spices.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Bacon Chicken Ranch

  Ranch dressing, diced grilled chicken, crispy bacon bits, diced red onions and mozzarella cheese.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• BBQ Chicken Pizza

  Sweet BBQ sauce, topped with mozzarella cheese and tender chunks of chicken breast.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Chicken Parmigiana

  Papa's famous pizza sauce topped with mozzarella cheese, breaded chicken and sprinkled with imported parmesan cheese.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

• Buffalo Chicken Pizza

  Papa's hand tossed dough topped with Frankie's special buffalo sauce, diced grilled chicken breast, red onions, mozzarella cheese and sprinkled with crushed red peppers.

  • 8"13,10 $
  • 12"18,10 $
  • 14"19,10 $
  • 16"20,10 $

Italian Dinners

All Italian dinners are served with soup or salad and our famous hot buttered garlic bread. Upgrade to a Caesar salad for an additional $1.50.

• Spaghetti or Mostaccioli10,50 $

  Served with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce and your choice of meatballs, meat sauce or Italian sausage patty.

• Lasagna Roll Dinner10,50 $

  Four lasagna rolls stuffed with a blend of ricotta, mozzarella, romano, and parmesan cheese, baked to perfection in Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

  • With two meatballs14,50 $

• Homemade Meat Lasagna12,50 $

  A generous portion of our homemade lasagna, prepared with fresh pasta, ground beef, ricotta, mozzarella and Parmesan cheese.

• Sal's Italian Trio13,50 $

  A combination of two lasagna rolls, with meatballs and a chicken parmigiana filet.

• Cheese or Beef Tortellini11,50 $

  Pasta rings filled with a blend of cheeses or beef and topped with Papa's Signature Marinara or garlic butter sauce.

• Stuffed Cheese or Beef Ravioli11,50 $

  Homemade pasta pillows filled with choice of beef or cheese, topped with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Veal Parmigiana13,50 $

  Hand trimmed & sliced tender veal breaded with Italian seasonings and imported parmesan topped with mozzarella cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce, served on a bed of linguini.

• Chicken Parmigiana11,50 $

  Breaded chicken breast topped with mozzarella and parmesan cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce, served on a bed of linguini.

• Fettuccine Alfredo11,50 $

  Freshly cooked fettuccine noodles smothered with our creamy alfredo sauce.

  • With grilled chicken12,50 $
  • With shrimp13,50 $

• Pasta Primavera*11,50 $

  Maria's Favorite! Linguini pasta served with fresh vegetables, zucchini, broccoli, carrots and red peppers in garlic butter sauce.

  • With grilled chicken12,50 $
  • With shrimp13,50 $

• Penne Pasta Fresca*10,50 $

  Penne pasta sautéed with olive oil, garlic, balsamic vinegar, white wine, fresh diced tomatoes, topped with freshly shredded parmesan cheese.

  • With grilled chicken11,50 $
  • With shrimp12,50 $

• Gnocchi11,50 $

  A Northern Italian favorite! Tender pasta dumplings served with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce and your choice of meatballs, meat sauce or Italian sausage patty.

• Angel Hair Garlic Pasta*10,50 $

  JoJo's Favorite! Tender thin pasta sautéed with garlic butter sauce.

  • With grilled chicken11,50 $
  • With shrimp12,50 $

• Spiedini13,99 $

  A SICILIAN DELICACY! Thin sliced beef tenderloin marinated in olive oil, hand rolled & stuffed with Sicilian bread crumbs, topped with sautéed mushroom & onions. Served with a blend of vegetables. Choice of potato or pasta.

American Dinners

All dinners include soup or salad, cole slaw, hot buttered bread and your choice of potato: beer battered French fries, crinkle cut French fries, baked potato, broasted potatoes or pasta with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce or garlic butter sauce. Upgrade to a Caesar salad for an additional $1.50.

• Beer Battered Cod Dinner10,99 $

  Premium Alaskan Cod battered & cooked to perfection. Served with rye bread.

• Broasted Chicken Dinner*10,50 $

  Fresh marinated chicken broasted until golden brown.

• Sal's Jumbo Shrimp14,50 $

  Super size gulf shrimp lightly breaded & deep fried to golden perfection. Served with cocktail sauce. Served with rye bread.

• Perch Dinner12,99 $

  Filets of lake perch, breaded and deep fried to a golden brown. Served with rye bread.

• Shrimp Basket10,50 $

  1/2 lb lightly breaded deep fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce.

• BBQ Pork Ribs

  Baby back ribs slow roasted & smothered with our own sweet bbq sauce. So tender they fall off the bone.

  • 1/2 Rack13,50 $
  • Full Rack18,50 $

• Chicken Tender Dinner10,50 $

  Tender strips of chicken breast breaded and cooked until golden brown.

Seafood Specialties

Seafood Specialties include soup or salad.

• Crab Linguini Alfredo14,50 $

  Over one-half pound of true snowcrab, sauteed to perfection in our signature alfredo sauce, served over a bed of linguini noodles, with garlic bread.

• Sal's Seafood Sensation15,00 $

  A generous sampling of shrimp, lobster, scallops, and crabmeat sauteed to perfection, served over a bed of fresh linguini noodles in your choice of one of our signature sauces (marinara, alfredo or garlic butter with garlic bread).

• Shrimp Skewers13,50 $

  2 shrimp scampi skewers grilled to perfection served over a bed of angel hair pasta sauteed with garlic butter sauce. With garlic bread.

Sandwiches

Make it a platter for only $2.25, which includes cole slaw and your choice of: Beer Battered French Fries, Crinkle Cut French Fries, Broasted Potatoes or a Baked Potato. Substitute onion rings for an additional 1$. Additional toppings: Cheese, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Black Olives, Onions - $1 each.

• Sicilian Steak Sandwich8,50 $

  A generous portion of hand cut beef tenderloin, perfectly seasoned with Italian spices, breaded and smothered with red & green peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese.

• Breaded Chicken Filet Sandwich6,50 $

  Hand-breaded chicken breast fried to golden brown topped with lettuce and tomato.

• Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich6,50 $

  Marinated chicken breast grilled to perfection topped with lettuce and tomato.

• Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich7,00 $

  Breaded chicken breast topped with mozzarella and parmesan cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Veal Parmigiana Sandwich8,50 $

  Hand trimmed & sliced tender veal breaded in Italian seasonings and imported cheese, topped with mozzarella cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Italian Beef Sandwich7,50 $

  Thin sliced marinated beef smothered with mozzarella cheese, onions, red and green peppers.

• Pizza Burger6,50 $

  apa 's Most Famous! Italian sausage patty smothered with mozzarella cheese and topped with Papa's Signature Marinara sauce. Additional toppings available: mushrooms, onion, green peppers, black olives and pepperoni

• Italian Meatball Sandwich6,50 $

  Homemade Italian meatballs topped with mozzarella cheese and Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Hamburger5,50 $

  Quarter pound burger topped with lettuce and tomato.

• Cheeseburger6,50 $

  Quarter pound burger topped with your choice of mozzarella or American cheese, lettuce and tomato.

• Jumbo Chopped Steak Sandwich7,50 $

  A half pound of ground sirloin grilled and served with butter or Papa's Signature Marinara sauce.

• Fish Sandwich6,50 $

  Premium Alaskan cod, battered and fried to a golden brown. Topped with lettuce and tomato. Served with a side of tartar sauce.