We take pride in our hand selected local seafood, shellfish, and daily raw bar specials. Our first class wine list and freshly crafted cocktails are perfect compliments to our seasonal seafood dishes.
At Carvelli Restaurant Group, we are dedicated to giving each guest a memorable experience while celebrating innovative ways to prepare fresh ingredients. Just ask the locals!
Because it has always been more than just about the oysters for us. From our family to yours, we invite you to celebrate with us!
“Our Oyster is your World.”
Corn Cream, Neuske Bacon, Grilled Sweet Corn, Leeks, Gremolata. (Maine)
Citrus Ponzu, Diced Cucumber, Red Onions, Caviar, Creme Fraiche
Sweet Potato-Date-Raisin Stuffed Ravioli, Citrus Vanilla Beurre Blanc, Asparagus. (New England)
Un restaurante estándar, la comida es agradable, el ambiente y sobre todo la música es buena, el servicio es muy bueno, la cómoda estándar
Husband’s bday in Marco Island. FAVORITE restaurant of the trip! Lobster Thermidor and Espresso Martini were the best!
Food and service was excellent
Best food i ATE while wife and me stayed in Marco island.
Loved everything about it!! Atmosphere, service, food & drinks!! Our new favorite place!!!
Our party enjoyed dinner very much. The waiter, Victoria was professional & made the evening enjoyable. The tasting menu had great choices and the food was excellent. No rushing.
Our dinners were very tasty and large portions, so we took half home and had them the next day for lunch. Wonderful ambiance with an entertaining saxophone player. Our server was very attentive and well trained. Bartender Marcel was very talented while showing off his juggling skills! A great place for a special occasion!
We loved the ambiance, the fresh Oysters on the Half Shell, the service, the vibe, and everything about our visit to Oyster Society.
Very good fresh seafood. One of the best I’ve ever had. Great experience until the last 10 minutes when it became obvious the restaurant choose $$$ over safety. A large group of 32 people were put at one long table and another group of 12 also arrived. They added tables which obviously put them way over 50%. The room became so loud you could not talk across the table. And the large groups did not have any masks as they walked around the restaurant. NOT COVID SAFE
Would put this restaurant in our top 5! We made sure to come back for the Canadian Oysters and Pistchio Seabass. Amazing food, service, wine... love it here!
Everything was amazing cocktails, food & service!!! Greta provided us w excellent service 🙌🏻
We enjoyed a delicious 10th anniversary dinner. The food was amazing. And our waitress was wonderful.
The food was great and the Sunset Menu a good value. My wife loved the Salmon and she is particularly about her fish. I got the Key west Shrimp and while it had a little spice, it was very good.
Exceptional. Food was delicious. Service was outstanding! Well worth every penny spent.
Vacationing on Marco Island and decided a dress-up night. We selected Oyster Society based on the Yelp reviews and pics posted. I would rate this restaurant and 8 out 10. Excellent Martini and Blue Point oysters. The rest of the meal was good.
Great food great service
Last night of vacation wonderful dinner Pre fix meal before six was good value for high quality seafood
This is an excellent option when you want upscale food and atmosphere at a fair price. Service is attentive and knowledgeable about food preparation options.
Food was below average. Hostess was very unpleasant. Waiter didnt seem to care about our complaints.
Everything was excellent!! Service, food and drinks were all outstanding! Oyster Society has become our favorite restaurant on Marco Island!
Our server was fabulous as usual. I’m afraid I can’t think of his name but he remembered us from before Covid...even what we like to drink! That makes the evening extra special. The food was wonderful and we felt comfortable with the spacing of the tables, masks, etc. One of our favourite restaurants on the island.
The Meal was absolutely phenomenal we had the roasted oyster trio and a sushi roll to start and both were delicious. Our meals were outstanding! Living in Sarasota I will travel the 2 1/2 hrs to dine here again. If you are in Marco Island this is a must!
Great food, always delicious. It is on the pricey side but for how great the food tastes it’s worth it!
This is our second time there. Its always on point! Amazing food and drinks.
Our first time, and we loved it! The ambiance is super cool, spaced out per CDC guidelines. The menu us spectacular. Oyster choices were great from both East and west coasts. The seafood and steak options were good. The filet was prepared well and the scallop dish with the pea ravioli was amazing!
Milo our server was on point with his recommendations for both food and wine. His attention to every detail was spectacular!
Simply amazing!!! From the service to the food, all excellent. Happy hour is a must. but be aware - there is limited seating now with Covid - it starts at 4.30 when they open the restaurant and people were queuing up by 4pm!! Shout out to Peter and 'Muracl" (apologies if spelt wrong - always hard to hear under these masks nowadays) our amazing bar staff - to Greta our waitress - perfectly waited - and to the manager who was very helpful and pleasant (Ramona)
We were only on the island for 3 days and we went twice!!!
Its a Marco Must!!!!!
First time visiting Marco Island and the oyster Society was a great place to go have dinner. Food and customer service was fantastic
Anniversary/Wife's birthday trip to Macro Island. Atmosphere is pretty casual, almost like a trendy upscale restaurant you'd find in a fancy mall, but not beach casual. My wife and I dressed up a bit but we saw people in shorts and tee-shirts.
Service was excellent, very attentive.
The food was, well, just fantastic.
1st course app:
Grilled Octopus with a white bean and arugula salad. the octopus was 2 tentacles and part of a head. Perfectly cooked and glazed with something close to teriyaki. We shared that.
My wife had a roasted beet salad. Well presented and well received by my wife (I dont' like beets...they taste like dirt to me)
I had a grilled Chilean Sea Bass with stewed white beans, broken olive puree and pesto. Fantastic...best thing I have eaten in months. Dare I say, the portion could have been a little smaller and I would have been completely satisfied, but that's just me.
My wife had the Lobster Thermador. She said is was delicious but was also fairly large. She did note that the mashed potatoes under the lobster didn't really fit the dish. Almost seemed like it was there as a prop for the lobster.
We shared a caramel tiramisu. It was the perfect sweet end to the meal. Such a unique twist on a classic dessert. Sweet, but not overly so. Very well balanced.
Overall, our experience was fantastic. Had we been staying another night, we would have dined there the next night. Yes, it was not inexpensive and our total bill after gratuity was over $200. However, we gauge value based on the quality of the experience, not not quantity of food, and I would rate this as a high level of value for the cost. If you are looking for a high quality dining experience with really sold service and are willing to spend a little extra for it, this place is for you.
First time there! My new favorite place in Marco!
Went for our Anniversary and they treated us like a king and queen. The food was wonderful!
We went there for my birthday dinner with my husband. Food was really good and customer service was on point.
Have awesome at the dinner great service
It was our second time here in two weeks. Both experiences were very good. Friendly staff, very attentive and we had a nice conversation with Maria. We will be back on our next visit to Marco island.
Staff was friendly and welcoming. The bartender Sean knows his drinks and is personable. the table staff needs some education on the wines. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. The Decor was like out of an old Western saloon. The food was tasty and showed up very quickly. They surprised my wife with a birthday chocolate torte/mousse with a candle. Nice touch! We enjoyed our dinner and would definitely recommend Oyster Society.
It was great
We were on vacation for a few days to Marco Island and went to Oyster Society three times while we were there. We sat at the bar and had incredible service. The oysters and king crab were amazing and the atmosphere was perfect. On Sunday they had a live band that was one of the best we’ve seen. Will definitely be going back the next time we are in town!
Loved this pkace.I will definitely be back.
Oyster Society offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (239) 394-3474.
Oyster Society is rated 4.7 stars by 1535 OpenTable diners.
You can book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size.