Olivia's Cafe - Disney's Old Key West Resort

The food is always very good at Olivia’s. We have been going there for about 25 years and usually visit several times each vacation.

I love Olivia’s for breakfast! However...my husband and I were both craving specific breakfast items when we went to eat at Olivia’s on a Saturday. I was craving the Crab Cake Eggs Benedict. My husband was craving the Banana Bread French Toast. Olivia’s just switched to a “Brunch” menu for the weekends!! Neither item made the menu :(. Thankfully the cook was still able to accommodate us!! I hope that Olivia’s will consider having the breakfast items in addition to the brunch.

Always a good time at Olivia's. They changed a couple of favorites, so we had to explore other options.

Came here for early Mother's Day celebration. It was delicious and offered great service.

Would not recommend. Food was just same old generic Disney. Nothing fresh made and portions were small. Waited far too long for food.

They couldn’t find our reservation and seemed put out that we made it via open table. When we asked to sit outside they said there would be at least a 15 minute wait after making us wait 10 minutes to see if they could accommodate us outside. We opted for inside. When we looked out on the patio there was exactly one table occupied and at least a dozen open. They seemed understaffed. Our server, Spencer was excellent! Joey, who sat us was on the ball and should have been running the greeter stand instead of the young lady who they had there. The steak was over cooked but I waited forever for it so I didn’t want to send it back.
I don’t think I have written a negative review before but I was surprised how far this place has slipped. Current management would be my guess for the cause of the decline.

Made a reservation on Open Table for 715pm. When we get to Olivia’s they advised they don’t check Open Table reservations. Told us 20-30 minute wait. At 30 minutes, told us 5-10 more minutes. What is the point of making a dinner reservation with Open Table.

Great food and service. But would you expect otherwise from Disney?

Lovely meal food was very good. Server and the rest of the staff were great. High on our go back to list. Not many vegetarian items too. Wish there were more.

Best buttermilk chicken with smashed potatoes and green beans/carrots. Yum!