Old Tioga Farm

An exceptional 3 hour dining experience. From the moment you arrive you'll feel like you are in the
countryside in Italy. The food is delicious and the service outstanding.

We had a lovely evening and all the food was delicious! Everything paired so well that we couldn’t pick a favorite course.

Justin and Dillon do a wonderful job with both the food and service. We love this place!

Always impeccably done - service, atmosphere, food - Justin and Dillon and their innovative mission to provide a true Tuscany experience are gifts to our community.

Amazing service and food

As always Old Tioga was amazing. The food, atmosphere and overall experience is worth it. Would recommend to anyone interested in having a unique dining experience.

We had an amazing time dining at The Old Tioga Farm for our anniversary! Booking my next reservation now!

Always Awesome the Food and The Service is amazing

Extraordinary, sublime food, prepared with passion and served with grace. Cannot say enough good things about Old Tioga Farm. It's more than an excellent meal, it's an experience.

As always these two people ( Justin and Dillon ) do absolutely everything with excellence - from food to service, love this place - what makes its so special are the people that put there heart and soul in the kitchen and serving. Couldn’t have been more pleased !!!

This is an excellent restaurant. The menu is prefix and is amazing. The ambiance is wonderful but the real attraction is the food. Amazing!

Everything was outstanding!

As always, Old Tioga never disappoints. The food, service and atmosphere were all absolutely amazing!

I recently returned to the Old Tioga Farm for a dinner to celebrate a friend's retirement. We were not disappointed. The portions are substantial and the food superb. Justin and Dillon are the most gracious hosts and make sure that everything is perfect. I don't know why I waited so long to return. I will be back more often. They are also very accommodating as far as BYOB, even chilling our Champagne for us.

As always it was a very pleasant experience. The food is delicious and service is top-notch!

This place was amazing! Great personal service and really comforting atmosphere. You have to get a reservation really early!

Every visit to Old Tioga Farms is fantastic. The food and service are exceptional.

Service was exceptional. Food was over the top. Cant wait to go back.

Always a wonderful time. The two owners are so wonderful and kind. You can truly tell they love what they do. This is set in their own home, with a small number of seating (Maybe 18-22?). All the cooking is done in their kitchen and you can even see the true farm to table when the cook is running into his garden and pulling fresh ingredients between meals. Lovely 4-5 course dinner with smaller portions but overall enough food. It’s always a good time with friends or as a date. We have never had a bad meal here.

Always awesome

Sublime fine dining.

Always top notch, the best meal anywhere in a LARGE area.

Another great evening with Justin & Dillon celebrating our friends' birthdays. The food and the service is always exceptional.

Old Tioga Farm was a wonderful overall experience! Amazing people, amazing food, and a fantastic atmosphere! We loved it, and will return!

The meal was so fresh , Enjoy the sautéed mushrooms and you could tell the pasta as in the ravioli was homemade. Really enjoyed the opportunity to interact with the chef. The hostess/server/waitress/wife of the chef was very friendly pleasant and attentive And interactive.

Dillian and Justin have done an amazing job curated an intimate dining experience. Each course was simple and satisfying in the most wonderful way. Uncomplicated and rich with the flavor of each local ingredient. It’s a slow pace, about 3hrs, but Dillion does a wonderful job as host. Dinning with a small group would be the ideal company when we visit again, as the conversation between my husband and myself was beginning to fade near the 2hr mark. My only suggestion would be that they serve coffee and tea with the desserts, rather than after. My cinnamon fig black tea was amazing, but I would have preferred it with my torte :) Having said that, it is a uniquely wonderful experience not to be missed... and one of the best meals I will probably ever have.

Amazing food- multi-course, perfectly paced meal in a relaxing atmosphere. Wonderful and personal service. Outstanding evening.

The food was absolutely fabulous!! It was a fantastic dining experience!!

Great farm-to-table italian cuisine is a quaint setting. Terrific value, and Justin & Dillon are the best!

Old Tioga Farm is by far the best meal I have ever had. Never a disappointment! Can’t wait to go again and try foods that I wouldn’t consider eating. The food is always amazing.

This was quite simply one of the best dining experiences I've ever had. The evening was perfect.

Wonderful as always! The food is fantastic and the service is very attentive. Great time all around.

Everything was a taste thrill, Justin and his wife Dillon do a fantastic job and make a perfect team. Can’t wait to see what this great chef is serving next month.