Reservations are not required but encouraged, though we do reserve ample seating for hotel guests and neighbors.
The staff was amazing! It was our anniversary and they gave us complimentary champagne and dessert which was an unexpected surprise. Thanks for making our day ;)
Great food great service. Really enjoyed the experience
The food was good but not worth the high menu costs. The room and the low lighting was my favorite part of this restaurant. Great place to eat then make your way over to the bar in the hotel. It’s a great place for a date or to meet up with a group of friends. Some of my food was a little bit charred and our server seemed to be rushing our time even though we ordered a full meal and tipped well. Really a lot of potential with the food.
We made reservations here for a Saturday night, two couples. They randomly were slammed which put us sitting back one hour. Service was pretty awful and we didn’t eat for about another hour and a half. However, the manager came over and was extremely sympathetic and comped our whole meal. It makes me think what had happened, usually doesn’t. Food was incredible. Given how management handled it, how kind they were to comp our whole meal AND the fact that the food was incredible, I will give them another shot. Everyone has crazy nights!
Ambiance was nice. The room was packed but didn’t necessarily feel loud.
Not a great first experience here. The atmosphere is super cute but that was about it. There was only waitress for the entire restaurant so service was very slow. We were also asked to move tables after already being served drinks and appetizers to accommodate another party which we found to be odd and rude. The prawns appetizer was good but the pizza and pasta were very mediocre.
Food was perfectly average and menu was fairly limited.
Welcoming and quant, Old Rose was an excellent dining experience. Food was delicious and staff was accommodating. The interior of the restaurant was just as tasteful as the food. Beautifully situated on the water, I saw on the benches before the meal. Highly recommend.
Old Rosè is such a beautiful quiet place with great food and music. The service was good overall.
What a wonderful discovery! A beautiful room filled with light and yummy food served by warm efficient wait staff.
We enjoyed a late brunch but we’re encouraged to peruse the dinner menu if wished to have a drink and wait for the change. Although we ordered standard brunch fare, the American breakfast and my friend had avocado toast, each was tasty, fresh and generous!
I’ll return as soon as I can!
Thank you so much for the kind words! We hope to see you soon for dinner! Catherine K. General Manager
Outstanding meal, outstanding location and outstanding ambience. Old Rose nails the West Village brunch experience.
2 of our pastas had absolutely no taste and the third one was mediocre. The fish was just ok. Not sure how they are surviving with so many other good Italian restaurants in NYC! Will never go back!
i visited this restaurant previously and had a good experience. i went back this past weekend (i should state that it was valentine’s day, so that could attribute to the poor experience) and had a horrible time. to start, the waiter was extremely inattentive while the restaurant was essentially dead. we asked him for his opinions on 4 different dishes and he said he would not recommend any of them. we finally did order and we received our entrees immediately as if they were pre-plated and sitting under heat lamps. they served us our appetizers about 45 minutes later, only after we finally tracked down our waiter and asked. a dish that i have ordered in the past and loved, was thrown together and tasted like they had forgotten salt. it’s a gorgeous restaurant, but i will not be returning
Old Rose has a great atmosphere, is very close to the Whitney (our afternoon activity), but had plenty of space, no wait, and great service despite being right near the busy High Line Area. Would definitely love to come back soon!
Service erratic and slow. Food fair.
Delicious and great decor/atmosphere. Will come back again.
Have been here for brunch and much preferred my food then. The dinner was so underwhelming, especially for the price. Gorgeous setting made up for it a bit.
Way too much red pepper!!
Très bon repas de réveillon de Noël avec serveur très attentionné, très joli cadre, ambiance sympa.
Je recommande vivement.
The vibe was nice, pretty decorations, airy and bright, with a lot of space and not too loud which is nice for a New York brunch spot. However the food was not anywhere good enough for the prices they were charging. Like $15 for an avocado toast and the "avocado" was like the guacamole you get from a plastic tub at the grocery store. Would recommend if food were better because the space is really nice.
Fabulous spacious atmosphere and reasonably priced. Vodka pizza and short rib delicious; tatsoi salad too soggy and basic. Would return!
Amazing food! Amazing atmosphere!
Food & staff were amazing, will def go back. Great for groups too.
The atmosphere is so great. Very cosy and old school. The wine wasn't very good and the salad wasn't very good, but the burger was good. And happy hour pricing provides a very good value.
Very pretty location with good food
I reserved a table for a friend's birthday celebration for 8:15PM two weeks prior to our dinner time. Our group arrived a few minutes before the reservation and were instructed to sit in the bar across the hall until the table would be ready in "5 minutes" -- we were not seated until 50 minutes later with no apologies or explanation. The management and waiter did nothing to try and make it right and served half of our party's food cold and uncorked a different bottle of wine than we originally ordered without asking the table if we would mind the substitute. Overall, a disappointing experience as several of us had dined here previously and loved it. None of us will return in the future. If you are looking for modern Italian cuisine in a trendy atmosphere, consider any of the other surrounding West Village establishments for timely and reputable service.
Food was average. Service was soooo slow they ended up comping our meal along with some other tables
We most love the ambiance and good service.
Nothing more to say
So nice! Staff was so friendly and accommodating!
Beautifully presented on Instagram but actually not that great, mediocre food, not cheap for the quality they serve. Shame...
Beautiful space. The reason for my visit was to try the vodka pizza. Looked like cardboard had no taste. After being told about a food allergy, the server neglected to mention the arancini has seeds in it...no allergic reaction thankfully but two comped drinks doesn’t excuse that.
A bit noisy but great.
The food was great, loved the drinks, and the aesthetic of the spot was amazing. I went for a friends birthday and we all loved it. The staff was super sweet as well!
Amazing experience! Such a beautiful restaurant, very aesthetically pleasing. The choice of music was perfection. A taste of every sound. The food was delicious. I really enjoyed my birthday with my girls and the people made me feel so welcome. Thank you so much. You guys really set the bar high. I will continue to come back!
A great place to have brunch--not too expensive and the atmosphere feels great, with awesome decorations and tall ceilings
Just a wonderful place!!! Food was stellar, service was fantastic... definitely recommend Old Rose.
Great time at Old Rose - the service was a bit slow but the food and the cocktails were worth it. We brought a cake and called ahead to know if there were any cake cutting fees. On the phone we were told there was a $5 fee for the cake.
When we got the bill we realized that the restaurant meant $5 PER person for the cake, so it ended up being a super expensive cake, because we were a party of 9. A bit disappointed with that, the rest was fine.
Service was excellent and the brunch was great fair prices.
The restaurant is beautiful and the food was delicious- thoroughly enjoyed the meal!
Waiters and people at entrance were truly rude.
The food is not good, and absolutely not worth the price. Our food came cold. The service is alright. Only went because the ambiance looked nice and it was. The cocktails are okay.
Old Rose is rated 4.2 stars by 280 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.