Old Homestead Steakhouse- New York City
Have made better steaks at home. Temperature was perfect but meat quality was sub par leaving me wondering how a $64 ribeye could be tough and chewy. Weird crowd in here also but service was good.
Great place great food highly recommend this place
Dined here for our wedding anniversary, service was excellent! They gave us a fabulous table and our waitress who was from Romania was so attentive and knowledgeable about the steaks and menu.
We would highly recommend 👍
Great petit filet, music doesn’t make sense...Mony Mony, really?
Excelente comida y un servicio de primera, las porciones son de muy buen tamaño y el barman es muy amable
Service not good at all. Steak - NY Strip - lacked flavor. Sides were average at best in taste.
Excellent food, pro wait staff. A pleasure!
waiter was over confident when ordering dinner . it seem like he wasn't paying attention which he did screw up on the appetizers . gave us the wrong ones . he has the attitude of us being there because the place was great and he was just as great.
Steaks were awesome but the service was legitimately embarrassing. Didnt greet us for 20 minutes, saw our waiter once thereafter. Didnt ask if we wanted desert. Entire section noticed the incompetence. Badd
the food was great!
All courses were delicious and the truffles Mac and Cheese are a dream.
Although the restaurant has high prices, we can fully recommend it.
Great meal (as always). Food is excellent. Service is top notch. Loved our seat at the end of the room upstairs.
Boooombe. Immer gerne wieder. Excellent
Great food! Great service! What more can you ask for?
Steak was great but overall the ambiance and design could have been better.
It's was a promise. which turn into Birthday dinner date with my girlfriend.
Our friendship was forge many Mooney's ago. Let us become a couple in this point in time. Kam
Came in from California and wanted to eat out a world renowned steak house with a great tradition. My wife and I were not disappointed!!
Good size portions, cordial service, kept to reservation, several waitstaff sang Happy Birthday to our celebrants. A $ splurge for us but would definitely return.
This was an annual birthday dinner. We all three had burgers. They were juicy, large , and delicious. We each took home half. Great evening. Always consistent.
Old Homestead is old school. Small steakhouse with great steaks, great service and nice wine list.
Great time! Thanks!
Great food and service
Always wanted to have dinner at the Homestead, being from the west coast and see the restaurant on the food network and always enjoying a outstanding steak, it was a great opportunity while here in New York to check one off the bucket list.
I have been going to this restaurant for years. It is one of my all time favorite. The place to go when friends and family visit.
Old Homestead is always a treat. First class waitstaff and consistently excellent kitchen make this a “go-to” favorite for special occasions.
The steak is really delicious and the staff is friendly. Everything is perfect
I got the ribeye and it was just not a good cut of meat for the price. Service was lacking also. Didn’t feel like an $80 dinner.
Phenomenal food. Not a place to go for a special night with your loved one. Noise was too much. However a wonderful experience.
I've been having dinner at the NYC location several times a year for many years. Always amazing filet they were soo incredibly loud & obnoxious, while dropping the F bomb that everyone in our area upstairs was complaining. It was so disruptive, a conversation could not be had. It sounded like we were at a Superbowl party in a packed bar. Manager was notified but did nothing. A very disappointing evening is the nicest thing I can say.
Great porterhouse for two ! It is a bit loud and the tables are a bit close for my taste
Not the best for a date but the food is top
Perfect steak, perfect service.
Not a romantic restaurant at all. Very loud. Poor attitude on some of the waitstaff. Our waiter seemed troubled if we needed water or anything that we thought should be a simple request.
Always enjoy having lunch here. They have a nice and comfortable dining room that allows for conversation without too much noise. Food variety is always top notch and lunch specials couldn’t be better. Service staff are professional and responsive
The ambiance and the food were fantastic. The service could have been a little better. Seemed like the bartender was new and the drinks were over poured, the waiter seemed to be having a rough day and left without saying he was passing our table to another waiter. Overall it was a good experience
It was great. Excellent fro and service.
Outstanding bone in filet! So fun to be in an historic restaurant that has such amazing food and service
Wonderful food. Unpleasant waiter
50th Bday dinner! Best of everything at this place! Top notch service, friendly, and cozy booth made my bday dinner the best! Love, love, love this place!
The steak tasted funky and it was just a weird experience overall.
Definitely lives up to it's reputation as one of the best in NYC. Always fantastic.