Classic steak house, exactly as it should be. Friendly staff, came to check on us 3x each time was a different staff. Food is excellent. Ordered the prime rib and gotham steak

Food and service were great. Very attentive waiter. Great meal!

Old school place that does not disappoint.

The customer service, the food, and the drinks were excellent!

Wonderful as usual. A great NY experience. I highly recommend

Excellent night out. Food was excellent, staff was nice, no complaints. Had a private room upstairs was a nice touch.

Food & service were outstanding as always. It’s so nice to dine in
such an iconic NY restaurant that still holds up in every way.

Food was amazing first time dear can’t wait to go back

Amazing !!

Food was very good and the service, led by Sarko was outstanding. He welcomed our family and made our total experience excellent!

They need to clean their ice machine…..

Great as always!

Exceptional!

Absolutely wonderful, food was delicious and service was great!

Very good food and service. 100% recommended to steak lovers.

Prime rib for 2 was amazing. Had it medium was charred and crusty on the outside yet still juicy and greasy on the inside. Grilled to perfection.

Waiter recommended a bottle of cab wine to pair taste was very earthy and subtle.

Mac and cheese a bit el dente. Still amazing.

Great NYC experience that was worth the money spent!

The service and food was, as usual, great. But this time around the noise level was unacceptable. I don't know if it is a general disrespect for others or that people forgot how to act in public after a year of being locked up. But the noise level this time around was something I have never experienced before. Between hearing a conversation 4 tables away or a group celebrating a birthday 20 feet away, I couldn't have a father/daughter conversation without repeating each sentence.

Great food. Great service. The Old Homestead is my favorite steakhouse. Perfect!

I was skeptical after reading the reviews, but I was very happy with my experience. Food was great, service was polite and prompt. My only complaint was a table of about 6 across from us that were extremely obnoxious and loud. One particular woman was talking WAY above her indoor voice.

Filet mignon was a little dry. Everything else was great!!

We waited approximately 1 hour for our table. The waiter did not say anything during this period nor did he introduce himself at the onset. My Father’s Day dinner was a disaster . We wanted to leave as soon as the food arrived. Then to top it off our left overs were all packed in the same container.

The tab was very high and it appeared as though other tables were getting service quicker .

I will never come back I promise.

Great food. Highly recommend to one and all.

Food was mediocre. Nothing about this place is memorable. The restaurant was so loud me and my girlfriend left with headaches. We were celebrating my lady’s birthday and that was not even acknowledged. The most impressive item was my side order of onion rings.

This restaurant is surely living off it's caché of being among the earliest and benefits from being on the edge of a food-free zone. Our salad plates sat empty for at least 15 minutes before the waiter graced us with his presence again to remove them. The food was unremarkable, which is not what you expect when spending $150 or more per person. We will not eat here again.

Food was nothing special - Got the steak for 2 - but was on the smaller side. Had to order even more appetizers/sides for filler

Service was abrupt punctuated by poor service. Waiter hovered offer my check. Meal was okay, appetizers were good.

Previous experiences were better but just okay.

Step it up friends. No need for non attentive waiters who are pushy about the check.

The menu had a variety of steak offerings on different serving sizes. The steak I ordered was well cooked to my liking and the side dishes and appetizers we ordered were delicious. The cocktails were also well made. Great place to have a meal while in the city. Would recommend to all in the city wanting a well prepared steak dinner.

Food was lackluster. We were so excited to eat there, but sadly disappointed. The bread was stale and flavorless. The butter was frozen. The salad didn’t have enough dressing. The steak didn’t have enough salt and flavor. The service was fair. Definitely not worth the price.

Food and Service were on point. Indoor seating was very crowded. They accommodated and moved us outside.

Love this restaurant but disappointed they added a 20% service charge without warning .. then suggested on the bill we leave an 18% tip. Do waiters not get the service charge? We tipped but both charges took our bill from $496 to almost $700 for a family of 4. If the service charge is posted somewhere we didn't see it. Makes it hard to visit as often as we'd like.

Legit, probably the best steakhouse I've ever been to. Flawless food every single time. My only gripe - expand the champagne list available by the glass.

The food was very good. Drinks were great. Service was wonderful! Definitely go back.

My first time there. The steak was not tender. The server did not pay attention to our requests. I was quite disappointed. Noise was level very high.

This dining experience was 2nd to none. From the service to the music that was playing, it was Tier 1. The lamb was perfect and the wine selection is impeccable.

Don’t second guess yourself. Best steak in NYC.

Had a great time and the food was fantastic! Perfect spot to celebrate our anniversary

Delicious anniversary dinner with great service!

Went to OH for the steaks which didn’t disappoint but the French fries were dry. They must’ve been in the freezer for a very long time then fried. All in all was a great meal just not ordering the fries next time.

I searched “top ten NYC steakhouses” and found Old Homestead. I was in charge of making plans for my friends b-day, and set the reservation up at this place. I was so embarrassed when we arrived . This place is a run down mess. The food is ok , but the overall experience is an immature , loud and drunk crowd in a run down venue. I would compare this place to a diner.