Menu used yo be better. Slow service. Good not great

Food is great, service is friendly

It was a wonderful night with great ambience, good food and just an overall good time. I think the wait staff worked hard but it took 35+ minutes to get salads and another 30 minutes+ to get our entrees. I think they need more servers to handle the number of diners.

We really like this place. Great food great service and ambiance.

Relaxed and fun. Engaging waiter/service.

Super experience in a rainy night outdoors under their awning. Romantic and lovely.

Great staff and food. A hidden gem.

This is a Hidden Gem! Excellent food and staff. Beautiful quiet outdoor seating area in the back. Chef very accommodating to food preparation preferences.
I recommend mussels and salmon with pureed corn. Panna cotta for dessert!

I cannot rave enough about Nonna Carola! The food, the ambiance, the staff were incredible. We sat outside and loved every minute of our time there. I also went to see the upstairs room for my sister’s baby shower and we are about to finalize our booking! Regina is the sweetest soul and a pleasure to be around. I am really excited about going again for dinner and also excited about celebrating my sister’s baby shower and getting to work with Regina.

This was our first visit, and we were lucky to be seated outdoors, which is wonderful. The four of us all had salads to start … all fresh with light dressings. My wife had an eggplant rollotini appetizer as her entree, which she said was delicious. My friend had the fish in a pepperanata sauce that was one of the best fish dishes he (or any of us) had tasted. Absolutely fantastic. My steak dish was yummy, although not quite as memorable as the fish.

Our server recommended a wonderful red Italian wine that seemed fairly priced. Desserts were excellent.

Overall, the experience was terrific. Nonna Carola is a great addition to the Mamaroneck Avenue food scene, and a restaurant we will 100% visit again. On our way out near closing time, we met Chef Phil who shared his philosophy and plan to frequently change the menu. He’s eager to experiment with flavors and hopes his “regulars” will try out new things each time. We hope to be in that category.

Food and ambiance were both wonderful! The back patio is a gem. We will certainly be back!

Nonna Carola always delivers a delightful dining experience. Sparkling food, beautiful atmosphere, expert service. We love to bring friends here and they are always impressed.

The service is second to none. Food is amazing. Manager constantly checked on me and my wife for our anniversary to make sure we were fine. Also took the time to explain a recipe to my wife . Highly recommend for all occasions.

Very nice location.
Excellent service.
Good in the average….

Great menu. Love some of the new selections. Mussels were spectacular. Gemelli pasta was also a hit. Will be back with the boys soon.

Terrific food. Nice service. Wonderfully space with outdoor dining.

We went for Father's Day and the food was excellent. The space inside is beautiful and tables are nicely spaced. There is also a large patio outside for dining.

Father’s Day dinner went like this price fixed. Appetizers,dessert then entree. Service was non existent. Terrible dining experience

Everything was absolutely delicious! Creative entrees, apps, desserts. We loved how the chef put her original touch on classics, as well as creating dishes that we had never tried before! The outdoor patio seating was calm and pretty. The staff was attentive and helpful.

Enjoyed the aperol spritz to begin. Ceasar salad was
A bit garlicky for my taste. The artic char was delicious.
My husband has the chicken parm he said it was a bit too cheesy for his liking but he enjoyed it.
We had a nice relaxing evening we would go again.

2nd time there. Hasn’t got any better.

Food was delicious as usual! Beautiful night on the patio with great service. Received a glass of champagne for our special date!

This place was wonderful! We’ve been waiting to try it and it did not disappoint. The drinks were great. The homemade bread was phenomenal. We ordered the chicken parm appetizer and cheese platter for an app. Rib eye for me, mussel risotto for my date! 10/10 will def be going back. The vibe and atmosphere was amazing.

Great experience all-in-all. Awesome patio out in the back! Our party of 6 was handled professionally and expediently. Will be back during the week to try the price-fix menu.

Everything from the interior design to the presentation of each dish was memorable!! Ingredients were fresh and I want to go back ASAP!!

Great service and quality food that is well prepared.

It was okay. Portions are small. Very limited menu.

Wonderful food, service, and atmosphere. Will definitely be back!

Would like to see more variety in their menu. So far, same/similar entrees for the past 6-9 months.

My wife and I had an exceptional dinner, with a lot of creative touches. The menu is not huge but has plenty of interesting dishes to choose from. My wife had a mushroom pasta dish with grated, pickled shallots and I had a mussels risotto with crunchy garlic chips and pea shoots. Both were superb. Yes, you pay more than you would in a neighborhood Italian place, but the food is well worth it. We sat comfortably indoors, but the outdoor dining in the back seemed welcoming as well. It was a birthday occasion and this place absolutely fit the bill. We will go again soon.

The food and service are excellent. Lovely outdoor seating. Attention to safety protocols inside.

Food was very good, but the menu is limiting- only a few main choices.

We had a nice Mother's day meal, food was terrific but the only snafu the cheesecake wasn't delivered. Instead of telling us and giving us the option to change our dessert order, we ended up waiting (too long) for someone to explain why no dessert bf the manager apologized, comped a meal, and finally served desserts sans the cheesecake.

Risotto was more like rice than risotto and portion was small.

Very limited menu but the food was prepared perfectly. It would have been great to see more small plate options, but would not complain about experience overall.

It's a beautiful space to have a meal, lovely lighting and colors. Unfortunately, the food and service was fair at best for the price. The portions were small, the pesto pasta dish I had was very dry, there was hardly any pesto and the chicken in the dish was overcooked. It was also way too loud, it was hard to have a conversation. Overall, I was very disappointed.

Bernard the manager was a total professional. He was attentive and so were the rest of the staff
Definitely recommend this restaurant and will be back.

Fantastic experience, and truly exceptional service. The chicken Parmesan roulette was phenomenal.

Lovely time!
Food was unique, craft artisan dishes with flavors I never knew existed!
Service was on point, attentive yet unobtrusive.
Will be back as soon as possible, especially for the dessert!

The food is absolutely delicious. The cheesecake is heavenly. Beautifully decorated modern room. Outside lovely.