Nicky's Coal Fired
Restaurants you may also like
Great. Super service and the pizza was perfect.
Great find! We started with focaccia and ordered 2 pizzas and 2 pastas - everything tasted great! Our server was fantastic. We were seated at a large table (for 8) and another group of 5 was then seated at the other end of our table which was not ideal, but overall we had a fabulous experience and would definitely go back again!
Nicky’s has become our go-to place. The staff is amazing, the food is spectacular and the intimate setting is exactly what makes us feel at home. We love Nicky’s
Great Pizza and apps!!! Had a wonderful date night
I had Mama G's Meatballs and Pear Sorbetto for dessert. Both were outstanding!
Found this neighborhood gem while on vacation. From the appetizers (Brussel sprouts and foccia bread) were delicious. Ordered the butternut pasta and pepperoni pizza and were amazed! The 1/2 carafe of Cabernet was also delicious. Thought we were full, but did squeeze in some gelato and sorbet- yum!
Best pizza in Nashville and an excellent wine list, albeit concise.
The food was excellent and well priced. Nice wines on tap -- especially the Sangiovese. We will be back!
Dakota was a fantastic server and took care of our large group. Can't wait to be back!
We stopped to get a quick bite before a show and loved everything we ordered. The flavors were delicious. We had a pizza, appetizers and a small meatball order and it was plenty of food for 3 ladies.
Excellent food. Excellent service. Very friendly staff. One of our FAVORITE restaurants!
Wonderful service and great food! The rosemary focaccia is the best!
We waited 20 minutes before anyone acknowledged our table of 8 (hard to miss!) but once they made it to our table, the food and drinks were flowing and service was not a problem. The food was good and plentiful.
Nickys is one of my current favorites. Everything from start to finish was delicious and our waiter was attentive and friendly. I will come back again and again!
We had a fantastic time with amazing waiters.
Only mix up was that the party was booked for 7 instead of 2 through OT which caused the Nicky's team some inconvenience. This could have been system related or user error, but we just felt bad for the Nicky's team.
Since we waited a while to be seated, they were nice enough to bring us 2 complimentary glasses of wine.
A busy Saturday night but with a reservation for 6:30 PM we wereseatedimmediately. We had a great server who made very good recommendations. Our cocktails, appetizers and pizza were delicious. Cant wait to return to Nicky's!
Bunch and bar menus are limited prior to dinner.
Maybe the special Valentine’s Day menu threw the place off, but I was expecting a lot more. My husband and I aren’t too picky when it comes to food as long as it’s tasty, but our main courses were not edible. The cheesecake for dessert tasted spoiled and the chocolate cake frozen. Definitely not worth trekking to the burbs for this place.
Amazing food for Valentine's day but ended up spending a little more than expected.
Wonderful atmosphere but tables were packed in too tight. It may have been just for the holiday but I could barely walk in between the tables to get to the seat on the other side.
All in all I was very pleased with the service and experience and will definitely be back
I booked this reservation about 6 weeks before Valentine's Day, so I didn't know about the set menu until a couple of weeks before when the staff called to confirm. Although I hadn't originally planned on the set menu, it was incredible. Great choices for each course and the food was delicious, as always. Friendly staff and attentive, but not overly attentive, waitstaff. We will absolutely be back.
An excellent dinner with wonderful service. We have visited Coal Fired in the past. This is the first tasting menu we have attended. We enjoyed our evening greatly.
Wonderful night as usual. The food is always great. The pie of the week with chorizo, beer cheese, etc... was incredible. The most outstanding item of the night was our waiter, Josh. He truly made the experience better and was one of the better waiters I've had in Nashville in years.
Outstanding food, great sauce, great meatballs, and delicious pasta!
Enjoyed all of the shareable options for a larger birthday party. It was a really great experience!
The food and service were excellent. We would definitely come back.
Amazing! Nicky’s is one of the best places to eat in Nashville. Tony and Caroline are so amazing. Amazing food and amazing service.
Some of the best food in Nashville. Can't sing their praises enough. Overall perfect dining experience.
Nicky’s is one of our favorite Nashville restaurants. There’s always something interesting in the menu and the quality never disappoints.
Excellent service, but we were underwhelmed by the food. The pizza had pooling liquid in the top, and all the toppings slid off. The crust was somehow still crispy and good, but it was hard to eat without a fork and knife, which is just no fun when you order pizza! The meatballs and sourdough were good. Brussels and sunchokes were not as charred/roasted well as I expected from the coal burning oven. Overall the experience was good, but I'll ask for extra-done pizza next time.
The food at Nicky’s Coal Fired is amazing. I grew up on New York Italian food, so I have my bar set pretty high. Nicky’s has the greatest sauce I’ve had in Nashville on both pizza and pasta. I can’t wait to come back and visit!
I love nickys!!! The food is amazing and the waitstaff are always so helpfulialwayd choose the specials.
So yummy! Only complaint was at a very small table next to others so hard to hear my husband and have a private conversation.
Thank you so much for the great vegan option. My family was able to enjoy pizza along side of me!!
Had to choose a red and a white pizza, accompanied by the Brussels sprouts. Couldn't leave without salted caramel gelato and tiramisu. All delicious. We'll be back - a 5th time! Thanks!
needs to hang draperies - way too loud
otherwise great pizza
We've been to Nicky's Coal Fired numerous times since they opened. it is unique destination for great food and service. We've never had any issues and staff go out of their way to help with your order.
The food was absolutely divine! We will be back!
We at at the restaurant for Sunday brunch. I was hoping to try their spaghetti bolognese but they don’t serve it for brunch. The nice waitress offered spaghetti with marinara. We ordered margarita pizza and a side of bacon. Both were very good but my husband was still hungry. We’d recommend this restaurant to others but order more next time.
Consistently great food with excellent service. Nicky’s has become a family favorite...
If I could make one suggestion: add a soup of the day🙂
Nicky's Coal Fired offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (615) 678-4289.
Nicky's Coal Fired is rated 4.6 stars by 569 OpenTable diners.