Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse - New York
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 2:00PM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Mon - Fri 2:00PM - 3:45PM 4:00PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Sat 2:00PM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Very good food and nice localities, but the noise level was outrageously bad - we had to almost shout to each other, which ruined the night out, and we left early.
We enjoyed Nick and Stef’s with the only item that fell short was the clam appetizer. It was not very fell done. Also there was no seafood fork brought to the table which made them very hard to eat. The NY strip and pork chop were done perfectly and very good the wedge salad had just the right amount of dressing and the truffle fries were amazing. The desserts were good but nothing special. All in all it was a very enjoyable night and we will be back.
Nice, quiet and clean steakhouse behind Maddison square garden. The Prix fixe menu is good value by NY standards. Meats had good texture but medium-rare was on the rare side. Crab cakes and lobster bisque has a good flavour. Doughnuts were excellent.
Nice service and great food
Great service and food was good
Great meal and service
Berkshire pork chop was cooked perfectly. Sides are abundant; we couldn’t finish everything but it was all so delicious. In the past we found their seafood is not as successful but we’ll keep coming back for the steaks and chops. Quite noisy, but service is attentive without intruding.
Food was horrible
McDonald’s grade at best
3 steaks and couldn’t get right
great for dinner before Madison Square Garden events...
We really enjoyed our dinner at Nick and Stef’s Sunday night. The restaurant is beautiful and the staff is very friendly and helped us the minute we walked in the door. The food was delicious and we will definitely be back!!
The food was okay, nothing great. Not what you expect from a steakhouse in NYC. I ordered a cocktail and it tasted like the bartender forgot a few ingredients. Our waitress was not very attentive. But it’s a great location right next to Penn station and MSG.
The entire experience was excellent...food, service, environment.
went here over the summer during restaurant week for lunch with friends and found it sneaky good. Wwent with my wife Steff ; yes spelled Steffani and enjoyed dinner before Carrie Underwood Concert. Highly recommend.
Great food and location.
Absolutely love coming to Nick and Stefs! I wish I could come more often. Steaks were all prepared perfectly, raw fish was fresh and tasty! The crab cake is so so so good! The beautiful bottle of Napa wine we had brought it all together for an awesome dinner! Be back soon. Thank you Jeff and Alex!
Always a win
Celebrating 2 birthdays.
Great service, food and hospitality!
Expensive but good
The bacon appetizer was delicious, but everything else was just ok. Not the best steakhouse I’ve been to, but not the worst either. The desserts were tasty and they had a nice wine selection.
The whole branzino was amazing and so was the slab of bacon! Impeccable service as always!
The flatiron steak was practically the usual size of a NY Strip, and cooked perfectly. Loved the peppercorn sauce.
We had a great meal! The service was on point! We would recommend to our friends! Definitely try the house cosmo!!
The food was excellent; a bit of a lag in the waiter’s service was picked up by the maitre’d. The pre-game crowd in this popular sports destination made it a noisy evening but i’ve enjoyed many meals in this restaurant and will definitely be back.
The service was very good but unfortunately the food was just ok. Very convenient location if you need to catch a train at Penn after dinner though.
Great food and service.
Service was fine. The food is awful. This restaurant was decent when it first opened and now it’s among the worst values in the city. So many better spots but the location for an MSG event is great. I won’t return.
Service was excellent!! Food was delicious and drinks were great!!
Great food and service
Overall a wonderful first experience. Waiter friendly and attentive, food excellent and friendly patrons.
Second time was better than the first. Crab cakes were delicious and the rack of lamb cooked to perfection.
The pomegranate margaritas were spicy and sweet, you should always have them on your cocktail menu.
You can never go wrong with the slab of bacon and the ribeye steak - so flavorful! Very attentive service and wonderful ambiance. We're quickly becoming regulars of this place.
The food was great! And the place looked amazing. I really liked it.
It's slipped a bit since our last visit. The filet steak was not as tender as it could have been and the baked potato was a bit too firm. I enjoyed the crisp skin but the potato was underdone.
Always solid, perfect location at the garden. Staff lovely and food spot on.
Great food! Pricey but it is the freshest food I’ve ever had. Would go back and recommend to anyone.
The atmosphere was very nice. Food was good, but service was very, very poor.
Excellent! Will eat there again. Convenient location. Good service & value.
Great experience except that takes are so close that you can't help but start talking to people next to you. Also very loud if that matters to some people.
Had a great dinner before the Queen concert at MSG. Place was crazy busy, noisy, and crowded, but really enjoyed overall experience. Our waitress Rachel was great and took really good care of us. Prices are not cheap, but it's NY. Tables could have been a bit further apart, but again... it's NY....
Oh, yeah, and food was delicious! Fun night!