Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse - New York
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun 2:00PM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Mon - Fri 2:00PM - 3:45PM 4:00PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
Sat 2:00PM - 2:00PM 2:15PM - 4:00PM 8:00PM - 10:00PM
We had an excellent meal. The drinks and the steaks were delicious. The server was very sensitive to pacing the meal, because we were going to a game at Madison Square Garden. Maître d’ was very much on site, making sure everyone was happy. I will return anytime I can.
All GOOD, great Prix Fixe
solid "fast food" Steakhouse near Penn Plaza. Good for lunch meetings. Excellent Lobster Bisque and salads. Filets are pretty good too.
Loved it! Food was delicious- great place for before a concert at MSG
Billy Joel concert. . The staff has you in and out and with great food and service
Food and service was very good. Perfect spot for dinner if attending a show/concert at MSG. They have an entrance to MSG from inside the restaurant. Recommended for a nice dinner
Had reservations and seated right away. Took about 10 minutes for someone to acknowledge us at the table, then another 15 minutes to get a glass of water then another 15 to take our order. Food was good and very expensive
We dined before a Billy Joel concert and the staff handled a massive crowd without a problem. In addition it was Valentine's Day. Nice job!
Very nice place. We were seated promptly, the food and service excellent.
Another amazing experience dining at Nick & Stef's. Family joined us that had never been there before and had the best time. Our server was amazing and very attentive to our requests.
Great business lunch
very nice wine by the glass
Ate here prior to attending the Westminster dog show. The restaurant was packed but we never felt rushed. Food was excellent. Opened with oysters which were perfect and French onion soup which was delicious. Two of us had steaks, perfectly cooked and tender. The salmon and the short ribs were wonderful. Doughnut dessert was great and portion was enough to share for two. Great wine selections. Our server was knowledgeable and friendly, and super attentive. Added bonus-no need to go outside after the meal to get to the Garden, take the shortcut stairway!
We had a delicious meal before attending an event at MSG. The waiter’s performance was disappointing. He was not as attentive as we thought he should have been.
Only real problem was getting our table at the reserved time 6:45. Took about 20 minutes which was a bit difficult as one person had to leave at 7:20.
Food and service were awsome. Could not ask for a better birthday dinner.
Luibov the server was amazing, couldn't of asked for a better server and time.
We went to Nick and Stef's for NYC Restaurant Week. It was the best experience and the staff is exceptional. They take great care to make your dining something to remember.
Delicious food, great location, special menu for Restaurant Week made it easy to order quickly.
Server seemed like she’s rather be anywhere else. Toughest and worst steak I’ve had in a nyc steakhouse. Ever.
I would recommend, food was good, service was good, however expensive and very loud!
I've been here 5 or 6 times always before an event at MSG and it is always a great experience. Never disappoints. They are dialed in.
Nick + Stef J’s now become one of my “Go To” places for lunch. Great food& service.
Great dinner before JT concert! Reservation right on time...Everything was fantastic, especially our server Steve!!! Also the direct entrance to MSG is outstanding!!!!
Well located right at Penn Station, deliscious food but very privey, a special occassion place.
A fine experience
Main reason I go here occasionally is the location- right next to MSG. Fun pre-game environment (before Rangers games for me.)
Food is ok but there are other great steakhouse choices in midtown if that’s your primary need...
This is always an enjoyable restaurant. The Restaurant Week menu was a bit limited so burgers ruled the day and satisfied the palate.
very good location for a business lunch
steak was perfect! great pork chop,
steak salad was a hit
They do a great job of getting you in and out for events at MSG without ever making you feel rushed.
I ate a late lunch with a coworker. Excellent food and service!
Great if you want great steakhouse quantity right in MADISON Square Garden. Cramped but fun.
Ok, as I usually do when I review something, I get a little lengthy but I like to know where I am going and what to expect so why not do the same when reviewing.
Nick and Stefs is a nice restaurant, business casual, I saw sports coats and ties and then I saw Baseball hats ???? Interesting. It is NOT a sports bar and the hats and tee shirts should be left out but hey what do I know ? The establishment is a little dated. The service and food NOT ! Will was our waiter and did not steer us wrong on anything. We started and (YOU MUST) order the hickory-maple bacon as an app. MY GOD ! I ordered the Tomato/Mozz salad and probably should have passed. Being from Jersey and spoiled, you are not getting a Jersey Tomato in JANUARY! Bland but edible. Main course: Wife- surf and turf. Again being from the Jersey shore and spoiled she was hesitant, but NOT DISAPPOINTED ! The filet was like butter and the lobster delightful. I went with the 18oz bone in strip. OH MY ! Wonderful choice, as I am a steak connoisseur, this was cooked perfectly and seasoned better. We split the mashed and they were mashed, can't screw up mashed. Will recommended the cinnamon sugar donuts as a dessert.........Bam ! another home run. Light and delicious! Overall a 8.5/10 for the meal!
Drawbacks: Tends to be over-crowded and bit loud, we were seated as a deuce but next to another almost sharing the table and right next to another 4 seated the same. If you are looking for quiet and quaint move on.
Back to Will, Highly recommend requesting him as a server. Not pushy, tentative, with a great personality.
Total bill with tip and drinks around $250.00, but depends on if you want apps and dessert and drinks..........
Narrowed down the choices for this date to Nick and Stefs and Butcher and Banker, went with N/S and was not disappointed. Give it a try and you'll see why !
Filet Mignon was cooked perfect the lobster mc n cheese was terrific
Great food and exceptional location for the Billy’s Joel concert - Staff was superb!
We had a very quiet corner table. We had the restaurant week menu. We had the short ribs risotto as an appetizer ,lobster bisque and salad. They were all delicious. We all ordered the salmon. It was good but it was a small portion. I had branzini there during the summer restaurant week and it was a very generous portion. Cheesecake and gelato for dessert. It was $5 on the restaurant week menu. A very small piece of cheesecake. Better off with the scoop of gelato if you are ordering off that menu. Service was lovely.
Food was great. Our waiter was very helpful, friendly and attentive. We loved the atmosphere and the convenience to MSG.
Went prior to seeing Sebastian Maniscalco at MSG
Seated us promptly
Service was excelent, food was very good and with a 5 pm reservation they got us out into the secret entrance before 7
Food was good but rushed out from the time we sat down will never go back
Family get together