I totally love this place!!! First time there took a friend of Bill W for her birthday and the Billy Joel show after...great experience right from when the door is opened for you. Seat was in a high traffic area and seated in 10 minutes from arrival not too bad since place was mobbed but I thought the noise was a little loud but it drained out when we seated. Started with the freshest blue points and nice big thick slab of bacon cooked and delivered at perfect time. Ordered everything right at beginning because we had concert to go to but the waiter was a PRO. He timed it all perfect and dinner flowed perfectly. Flirts with the best wild mushrooms I ever had and steaks cooked perfectly. One of the best experiences I’ve had and when done private entrance into MSG...perfect!!! Hit seats and exact time of arrival here comes the “The Entertainer” with his normal opener Miami. Another awesome night but it all started with a great experience and food at Nick and Stef’s.
We originally made a reservation for 8 people but asked to expand to 10 the day of our dinner and the restaurant was very accommodating! They gave us all complete attention and a great evening! Will definitely go back!
We dined on a night that Madison Square Garden was dark and loved it. Great attention from staff, food was outstanding, noise level low even when a business party of 20 arrived. Noise level and comfort are completely different on a night when there is a sports event or concert - reservations in advance will be required for those nights.
Always a great meal with terrific service. Especially good before or after a sports event at Madison Square Garden.
Great flavor on food and great service
Fantastic food and service! Highly Reconmended! I loved my ribeye steak!
Exceptional dining experience, outstanding service, atmosphere conducive to business conversation.
This was my first time coming to this restaurant. i had a wonderful time. The service and food was excellent! The staff was friendly and respectful!
The food was excellent and we about talk and hear each other. The staff was attentive. I would definitely recommend.
Coming in from out of town for a show at MSG. Couldn't get a closer restaurant. Very convenient to MSG. Food was very good. Service was outstanding. Only complaint was the tables were almost stacked on top of one another. Would highly recommend if you have an event at the garden and want a good meal, and are not worried about the cost.
Yum! Great steak, loved the Caesar salad, short ribs were perfection.
Service was slow. Wait staff was poor. Order was wrong for two out of three meals.
We got a last-minute res on the night of a Rangers game. Restaurant was packed but hostesses managed seating very well, kitchen stayed on top of orders, staff were excellent in managing seated customers and turning over tables without feeling rushed. Noise level was very high but restaurant has wisely included a number of abatement and mitigation features in the design of the space which helps greatly. Once the fans depart it is a great dining experience for non-fans. Will return.
I love the relaxed feel of this place – like a comfortable dining room in a friends home. I definitely would return to try more dishes.
Everything was great, waitress very friendly, but spent too much time at our table
First time I have been there. Steaks were delicious. I will be back!
Stopped in prior to a rangers game. The food and service was excellent. Staff was extremely friendly and accomadating.
I used to like this restaurant but this visit disappointed me. The risotto was very good but the steak we ordered were over cooked. My steak was like a rock! After I told the waiter, he answered that flat iron steak is supposed to be chewy. And he said he will tell the chef but nothing happened later. It was really a bad experience and I’m not sure if I want to go back again.
Started at the spacious bar with cocktails and was able to get seated at our leisure which is always nice. The service and food were great, hangar steak was fantastic. Can't beat the convenience to Penn Station either. Great steakhouse!
First time there.....went on our way to a show at the Garden. Would definitely go back