Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
New York Prime - Atlanta
Restaurant and Bar Non-Smoking | Upscale casual dress code | Located in Monarch Tower with complimentary valet parking. Directions: Lenox Road upper ramp between The Whitley hotel and Phipps Plaza; Recommended driving directions: Google Maps or Waze. *Please note, high chairs are not available.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
A New York Tale
Eagle Rare 10yr bourbon, amaro, maple syrup, lemon
Cheese Mashed Potatoes
Jumbo lump, mustard sauce
The salmon was undercooked twice. I kept having to ask over and over for straws for my drink… like I’m pretty sure I’ll never go back… $200 tab for the worst food ever…
We ordered the oysters rockerfeller, live lobster, ribeye, brussel sprouts, mushrooms and sweet potatoes. Everything was so delicious!
Loved the food! Service and food was excellent. Definitely want to go back soon.
Bones has been de throned in our books. Everything was delicious except the champagne wasn’t my favorite.
The ribeye was amazing, so were all the sides and oysters and crab cake. We will def be back
They have decent steak and the shrimp pasta is better if you sub the shrimp for chicken. Service is very attentive… Nice scenery!!
Steve is the best waiter they have super observant super cool
My steak was cooked more on the raw side and the bill was over priced overall a good experience just could have went elsewhere for the amount spent
Seating felt exclusive, excellent tour of the menu, great recommendations, our waiter was intuitive, and the food exceeded expectations. NYPrime is now my favorite steakhouse in Atlanta!
It was our 16th anniversary and I booked the reservation through the app and mentioned our anniversary. When we arrived our waiter greeted us with Happy Anniversary! It was our first time dining there so he recommended food and drink choices that exceeded our expectations. After dinner our waiter gave us a complimentary desert for our anniversary and it was just d as good as our dinner! We enjoyed our dining experience and will definitely dine again!
Will definitely go back
The food was ok. Fish all average. Chicken and steak were better. The bread was bad and cold. The chocolate cake was so large, it would work for 6 ppl. Silly. Expensive and unnecessary. Like the vibe. Pretty place.
Great spot. I would recommend making regular french fires available. The ones that are served are basically sliced baked potatoes. Not exactly good for dipping.
Went for NYE. The food was amazing and service was stellar. Great steakhouse that I will always frequent!
Wonderful service, wonderful food, and wonderful atmosphere! Can’t wait to feature to New York Prim!
We make NYP every year for NYE. They are always consistent delivering a quality experience.
Service was horrible
Steak was undercooked manager never came over to apologize
Jeff was a awesome waiter. Can’t thank him enough for the kind courteous service. Alway enjoy our time at NYP.
Just ok for me. It was very loud. But festive. I think the food was good. I feel like they were definitely trying to rush us out even after we had only been there for 30 minutes. I know they were probably trying to turn the table but it was a special occasion and we kind of wanted to have a nice evening out and not feel like we were rushed.
This restaurant is fine dining and it's pretty expensive, but when I say it's WORTH EVERY PENNY I mean. The food and service are always exceptional. We have been a few times and it is consistent everytime. My husband and I love this restaurant. This is a must try!!!!!
We had a fantastic time dining at New York Prime and We Will Come Back
Great food amd service
Always a wonderful experience from start to finish! Food is delicious and meat always cooked perfectly! You can never go wrong with finishing your meal with the chocolate chip cookie or the cheesecake!
Just a great experience. The staff - from the bartenders to the waiters to the managers - were all incredibly attentive and responsive, and the food was fantastic. Already planning our next visit in a couple of weeks.
Awesome service from Jeff. Had to order another round of oysters because they were the best I’ve ever had. Steak was amazing- better than bacon. Will definitely be back for more.
Delicious food and impeccable service.
Overall, we had an amazing experience, while accommodating our children. Would definitely recommend.
Pricey, but well worth it. Excellent steaks, and wonderful service
We made a reservation for 6 on Christmas Eve and had to wait another 45 minutes for the table, a bit disappointed
We had reservations fo 2 at 8:45. I received a text at 8:40 stating our table was ready. They claimed it was a mistake as they were over an hour behind seating people. That part of their service was terrible! However we were able to find a seat at the bar where Steve took care of us as though we were royalty!! Overall I would rate this experience as 4 star but would have been 5 if they had honored our reservation.
Horrible. Christmas Eve dinner reservation for 6 at 8:00, finally seated at 9:00 at a table that was shoved in the back corner beside the patio door. Every time the door opened the wind blew so hard items on our table blew off. Finally got the mgr to move us outside on the covered patio. Incredibly rude staff starting with the hostess upon arrival. Our server was incredibly arrogant and unfriendly, nothing pleasant about this restaurant at all. The food was mediocre at best. Recommend Hal’s on Old Ivy instead.
Had a reservation at 8pm didn’t get a seat till almost 845, was sat in front of an out side door where every time it would open there would be cold cold air that hit us which was frequent so we requested to be moved which was a little better so the food was ok crab cakes delicious but my lamb chops was charred an dry in the middle for them to be medium rare also my date steak was also charred an dry so when the bill came the receipt was wrong it came to be 282 for stuff we didn’t order then it was corrected which came to be 138 so when it was time to swipe the card my date which paid received a fraudulent alert so we thought it was corrected so today my date checked her statement an come to find out that our waiter tried swiping her car 8 times for 138 dollars which appeared on her statement as 8 chargers so the experience for such a well none steakhouse was such a disappointment.
Waited 45 minutes for a 7 pm reservation. Wouldn’t decant a very nice bottle of wine!
Everything was just excellent! The oysters were big and fresh. Salads were just right. Steaks were as good as I've ever had: done perfectly as ordered. Even the sides were outstanding. Waiter was attentive but not obtrusive. In all a fine night.
Our waiter Steven was amazing!
The experience was great. This was my first time here and I enjoyed everything.
Went for the steak but the oysters rockefeller stole the show. A+ experience, service, and meal.
You can order delivery directly from New York Prime - Atlanta using the Order Online button. New York Prime - Atlanta also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (404) 846-0644.
New York Prime - Atlanta is rated 4.6 stars by 2102 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.