Bring the restaurant to you. Order and pay for food directly on OpenTable.
New York Prime - Atlanta
Restaurant and Bar Non-Smoking | Upscale casual dress code | Located in Monarch Tower with complimentary valet parking. Directions: Lenox Road upper ramp between The Whitley hotel and Phipps Plaza; Recommended driving directions: Google Maps or Waze.
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
A New York Tale
1792 Small Batch bourbon, amaro, maple syrup, lemon
Cheese Mashed Potatoes
Jumbo lump, mustard sauce
Worst experience ever! We asked for medium well steak and it came as medium and cold. Then we asked for it to be cooked to medium well and it came back the exact same way. I think they just popped it on the stove so it'll seem hot on the outside but the inside was still extremely red. My husband also ordered his steak medium well and that was perfect so the difference between both was clear. We spoke to a manager who was extremely rude and defensive. He should be ashamed of himself! Our experience went from bad to worse from just interacting with this terrible human being who was a few words short of calling us out of our name. Shame on him! The manager on the night shift on Dec 4th 2021 needs to be reevaluated. He ended up escalating the entire situation over a 50 dollar steak.
Food overall was really good, obviously can’t go wrong with their steak options. The cheese mashed potatoes were giving “instant”. The reservations were for my daughter and I and we were sat right next to the bar. It was ok at first but then got really busy and loud. I wouldn’t recommend putting parties with children next to a bar.
First they tried to seat us at patio which I specifically asked not to be seated when I made reservation. Hostess seemed bothered, but did sit inside.
Atmosphere was a awesome, disappointed in the food, Steak was ok, sides were salty and some cold and hard. Service was ok server was not as attentive as expected. A bit too dark for dinner.
Too expensive for the value of the food!
Service was great! Food was delicious and served hot and fresh. Be prepared to wait a little extra time from the reservation time. For us, it was about 30-45 minutes.
Staff was working very hard to ensure a great experience. Overall fantastic night.
We were really excited about visiting this place but Unfortunately our experience was disappointing mostly due to poor service though the NY steak was perfect. We asked for bread three times and we got cold bread almost by our main course. We ordered salad to share and we got it on a plate without any options to share it. In the end one the of the Managers brought serving spoons and fixed it. For my main course I ordered lamb chops and the Server let me know that lamp is not available after we finish our starters which was too late and I had to change my order and our main course was served with the delays. I don’t recommend this place and won’t come back there.
We ended up eating at the bar. It was a return trip post-COVID travel ban. Really missed this place. Steven and Andy at the bar are great. Glad to see they are still there.
My husband and I decided on NY Prime for our date night. I’ve dined with them at least twice before but was my husband’s first time. Service was outstanding…from start to finish. We opted for the filet mignon. The meat was cooked to perfection and melted in your mouth tender. I had the Robert Craig Cabernet which paired beautifully with the filet. We finished our dining experience with the Key Lime Cheesecake; it was the perfect size portion for one person and delicious.
The only negative to our dining experience….which wasn’t NY Prime’s fault….was a table of women (IG influencers) that constantly filmed their dining experience, taking selfies, and had a cell phone propped up with a flash light on all the time that shined directly into my eyes. I finally had to switch sides of our table to not have the light in my eyes. They were seated about 20 minutes after us and didn’t have any regards to tables around them. You just can’t buy class…..
Evan was very tentative and kept adjusting heat lamps until we found the right balance.
Food came out quickly and accurate and tasted delicious
Great service. John was excellent. Filet was amazing.
Our server was great. 2 of the 3 entrees were most disappointing. My steak was fatty and overcooked.
The steak fries were just too big. Our plates were not big enough to have one steak fry even on it. Dessert was great. We were sad with our experience and won’t return anytime soon. It’s upsetting because NYP was one of my husbands favorites
We had a great time since Chops and Capital Grille were booked solid today.
The chef should change the type of steak Fries from big chunks of potatoes to thinner slices. They look like large potatos cut horizontally in thirds without any seasoning.
Lobster and shrimp should be broiled or fried and not baked. The lobster was dry and rubbery and the baked shrimp taste average at best.
It was my first time eating at NY Prime steakhouse and will probably be my last.
We celebrated my son’s 18th birthday and Thanksgiving at Prime. Service was outstanding. Food was delicious. Thank you for taking such good care of us!
Thanksgiving tradition and special event destination. Love the staff and the food is wonderful.
Excited for next time.
First time coming to this restaurant abs Steven really made the experience amazing! From the beginning to the end, really took the time out to explain the menu to us, and help us pick dinner options. Can’t wait to visit again!
Had a great experience dining here and by far this is one of the best restaurants I have ever been to if not the best. The food was excellent!!! The service was great. Loved the ambience and good value for the money!
Tried the porterhouse which was better than ever. Split with my wife and it was plenty of meat for us both. And they really know how to cook it.
This was a great experience the food was great the service was great the ambience was amazing New York Prime is my new favorite
Great service and Manager was amazing for accommodating! The butter cake always puts a smile on our face. Thanks for consistent service.
Very nice and cozy atmosphere. The steaks are delicious and cooked perfectly. My wife and I will dine again. We picked this place for our anniversary celebration.
Everyone in my party was pleased with the excellent service and the taste of the food.
Wife and I had filet and sea bass both outstanding. Highly recommended.
The food and service was very good. Our
waiter Kyle was outstanding. My only
complaint is the music. We had to listen to
70's rock the entire meal, and it was to
loud. It was hard to have a conversation at
our table of four. I think some smooth jazz
in the background would be a better
Nat’s everywhere. Server was a bit slow
Everything was amazing food and service we will all definitely be dining here again soon
Really enjoyed having Jeff as our waiter at our first visit to the restaurant. Will definitely go again. Highly recommended.
Food was lovely. However it's so loud for a 4 star restaurant.
Had to swat gnats the whole dinner! Really killed the mood! Not my first visit normally pleasant!
Celebrating my 75th birthday. Food was amazing service was great will definitely be coming back.
I danced the entire I was eating. That is how good my steak was.
Always amazing at NY Prime. The bar is amazing, (thank you Steve!), the wine selection superb and steaks are unbeatable. Best filet ever, perfect cut and temp. Will be back soon.
Food and service were top notch. The one negative was that there were a ton of flies. Really took the enjoyment factor down a notch or two. If they got rid of flies, we would definitely go back 😊
Great food and the service was excellent! The only problem I had was with the broccolini. It was very heavy on the garlic and spicy. We weren't aware that it would be spicy and gave some to our little one. Our server didn't know either, and he was very attentive. Everything else was awesome! Even the valet attendant was very courteous and fast. The customer service is top notch at New York Prime.
Awesome meal will be back soon
Wonder from the start, our service was amazing and food so good.
We came for my husband's birthday, it was a good experience.
Great food and service. Our server was excellent
You can order delivery directly from New York Prime - Atlanta using the Order Online button. New York Prime - Atlanta also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (404) 846-0644.
New York Prime - Atlanta is rated 4.7 stars by 2042 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.