New Amsterdam Burger and Bar
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Diners must wear masks unless eating or drinking
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
- Staff temperature check required
- Diner temperature check required
- Contact tracing information collected
ground turkey served with lettuce, tomato and red onion w/ BBQ honey mustard sauce
served with lettuce, tomato and red onion w/ ranch dressing
This was my first time at this restaurant, and since I'm not a fan of hamburgers, I was looking forward to ordering chicken. I happen to prefer dark meat, but I didn't find it on the menu, so I ordered the grilled chicken breast on blanched farm vegetables instead. And - wow! - it turned out to be the juiciest, most succulent, delicious chicken breast I've ever tasted (and with a great subtle sauce). Topped off the meal with a chocolate peanut butter mousse, which tasted super-dairy but, of course, wasn't. This was the best fleyshik meal I've eaten in a restaurant in a very long time!
Food was excellent. Service good and attentive. Wings were great. Burgers were served medium rare which was our preference (the menu said only medium well). Dessert was disappointing- served in plastic small parfait cups.
Great burgers, salad perfect, fried eggplant terrific!
A million miles better than the old Amsterdam Burger. The food was really delicious - we had the salmon burger which was a beautiful filet of salmon with lettuce, onions, tomato on a nice large roll, and the chili "cheese" burger which was awesome with jalapenos, lettuce, tomato, onions on a large brioche type roll. Kosher veggie cheese doesn't usually melt nicely, but this was perfectly melty and delicious. Doesn't melt like real mozzarella on a burger, but for kosher, this was the best since Pardes in Brooklyn. Can't wait to go back and try another special burger. HIGHLY RECOMMEND IT.
I was disappointed that for such an overpriced meal we could not even get simple wait service and had to go to the counter to make the order. if you are going to downgrade the service in the early afternoon it should be reflected in the price.
As a whole, I felt like I overpaid for what I ordered (3 burgers, 1 fries, and a coke).
:-(. Really disappointed. Took us a hot minute to realize it was kosher. Would explain the exorbitant prices. Drinking out of plastic cups didn’t match with the cost.
One of the better kosher restaurants in NYC. We had delicious "cheese" burgers,salad,a couple of glasses of wine and it was all good. We ate outside;everything was kept clean ,silverware was replaced and we weren't rushed. I can't say any kosher restaurants in NYC are a great value but New Amsterdam Burger has excellent food which sadly, is not the norm. All the servers were available for ordering,delivering the food and check,refilling the water pitcher so service was fine if a little haphazard.Ambiance was lively, not overly noisy and plenty of less than frum diners (e.g. I saw plenty of miniskirts and uncovered heads)
The eggplant appetizer was served hot and with a delicious dipping sauce. The burgers were large and juicy. Everyone in the family enjoyed what they ordered. A great family spot.
Good for A quick bite. Not fancy food was average
Fantastic service and outdoor seating. Celebrated two adult birthdays. Food great. Dr. Steven Huberman, Teaneck, NJ
The food was great. Have the French Fries - perfectly crispy! And if you sit outside, be prepare to see old friends & make new one as everyone is super friendly & nice here!
Outstanding service and great food!
Great place to bring a group of friends! Had an absolute blast!
Burgers and sides were very good. Service was rather slow. The online reservation system said there were no outdoor tables on the patio available after after 4:30, so we ate much earlier than we wanted. However, when we left at 6:00pm there was only 1 other occupied table on the patio—so apparently the online reservation system is meaningless.
The restaurant was very good but open table indicated no outdoor tables but there were many outdoor tables available.
Delicious, excellent, as always.
New Amsterdam Burger and Bar has a nice, friendly, neighborhood vibe. The waiter was excellent and the burgers were great! We were delighted that there was a vegan burger that accommodated a member of our party.
Burgers were over cooked, self service…Woukd not go again.
The prices were significantly higher than what was on this menu. We arrived 15 minutes late, and if that caused a switch in prices, that was unfortunate. $22 for a burger at lunch? That’s absurd. The prices were at least $5 higher. I have no idea how the food really tasted. I was annoyed that the menu was so off.
Excellent burgers! Servers were pleasant and always available.
Great food! Great service and great atmosphere! Waiters are really attentive to what you need!
Very creative menu
My turkey burger was very tasty and the fries were first rate! I ate there on a weekday at lunch and the place was quiet: hopefully the crowds will pick up. I will definitely go back again!
Super .. best burger had in a while. COVID Safe. Recommended
New Amsterdam Burger and Bar is one of the best meat restaurants in NYC. They’re very accommodating with seating along with their highly professional staff. The freshness of their food, especially burgers is unparalleled and will leave your tastebuds in awe. In short, go here and
you will not be disappointed!
Consistently good food with new dishes available from time to time.
Waitstaff anxious to please.
This is our “go to” restaurant whenever we’re in the city.
All around good time, get together with whomever was in town... great kosher burgers
Good although pretty pricey
Overall very good.
Piped music too loud and inappropriate.
Great burgers, they were very busy so service was a little slow but worth the wait. Would definitely go back
Very friendly staff. Excellent food. Owner stopped by our table and was clearly interested in making sure we were happy.
We love the new place
Some of the small tables should be alittle bigger to accommodate 2 people with alittle more room for more food!!
The hostess should be alittle more friendlier and more of a people person
Prices increased too much.
This restaurant is phenomenal! The food is great, the ambience is so pleasant, and the staff is extremely helpful! Highly recommend.
The breakfast burger was amazing, and crispy eggplant appetizer was perfect. Good portion sizes. Well priced.
Great experience. Food was delicious, ambiance & vibe were very cool, and the service was warm & prompt. Can’t wait to return.
A great burger! You do not have to keep kosher to enjoy this place. The atmosphere is cozy and modern. The service was excellent. We loved our burger and fries -- all cooked just right. The potato salad is terrible, so don't bother (unless someone tells you they have a new recipe).
Great ambiance and excellent food. Very accommodating to food allergies and restrictions. Even prepared a special dessert that was gluten free.
The food was good, though I’m. It sure why the prices increased when it’s the same as its prior location...
The waitress was attentive though they seemed to start to push us out, even though there wasn’t a wait
The manager was a little rude upon arrival but then ignored us and the rest of the patrons for the rest of the night... so makenof that what you will
Menu and drink options are limited, and burgers only cooked medium-well. Great atmosphere, and friendly staff. Just know the limitations.
You can order delivery directly from New Amsterdam Burger and Bar using the Order Online button. New Amsterdam Burger and Bar also offers delivery in partnership with Uber Eats. New Amsterdam Burger and Bar also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (212) 362-0700.
New Amsterdam Burger and Bar is rated 4.5 stars by 69 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.