MustangHarry’s underwent a $1.5M renovation in 2017, which expanded and transformed the entire venue with tufted leather banquets, reclaimed wood walls and nooks, and antique fixtures and skylights that capture the rustic charisma of post-industrial NYC with an Irish twist.
The Mustang Burger
our custom blend 10oz burger, classic garnish
blue cheese, caramelized onion, sweet pickles, tomato, market greens, crispy bacon, Mustang sauce, smoked bacon
Garlic Parm Fries
Always a good meal, and they are good about getting you in and out for the game!
This is the perfect place to have drinks or a nice meal before a event at MSG. It is so much fun having drinks at the bar before a Rangers Game.
We were seated immediately. Got drinks right away. The menu had a nice variety and the food was really good. Would recommend, especially if you’re a Ranger fan on game day ;)
Perfect place to eat and get drinks before an event at MSG.
Patrick the GM was extremely kind and accommodating. We had a reservation and even with a full house and a little wait time, he entertained us and made us feel welcomed.
Can’t really comment.
This Irish pub is pretty much on point price-wise with other NYC-Times Square joints. Yes it’s pricey, yes the food is nothing to write home about. The best part is the pub is it’s actually worked and managed by Irish folks. It seems more genuine. Our server was amazing!! So humorous, accommodating when we wanted to watch a specific b-ball game, and helpful when we were choosing what to eat. The bottomless boozy brunch is the way to go. They make the drinks with a heavy hand, which is all I ever ask for. Would recommend to tourists looking for a fun brunch in the hectic city.
We arrived at the restaurant along with the massive crowds to see Billy Joel at MSG. I will say that we were seated promptly at the time of our reservation, despite the crowds and commotion. We decided to order burgers, thinking that was a simple choice and that we’d be served quickly, as we were meeting friends before the concert. Our server came over promptly and took our orders for 2 burgers, a soda, and a glass of wine. What could be simpler? Instead, we waited 45 minutes for our food, as tables around us who had been seated after us were served well before us. Despite repeated requests to our server and a manager, the time it took for our food to come was totally unacceptable. By the time the burgers arrived, we had to rush to eat, and still were too late to meet up with our others friends. We were hugely disappointed, even though the restaurant picked up the cost of our drinks. This was my first visit, and it will be my last. Give me a reason to come back.
Super nice staff, seated us quickly even though we were late and continued to check on us. Can't say enough good things about their hospitality and service!
The service was very good. The food was tasty and good also. However this is basic food and a bit pricey. The place was nice but I found it too dark. You can't read menu properly or see very well. Just a bit too dim for my liking.
It's the go-to place before any show at The Garden! They play the music of the artist performing so it's fun! The service and food are very good!
Great experience! Drinks were very good and our dinners were excellent
Food came out wrong, but it was still really good. Waitress was a little slow & didn’t come back to see if we needed anything.
Very good brunch/lunch before afternoon Rangers game. Veggie omelette, fish & chips, steak baguette sandwich. And mac and cheese on the side. Very good.
Took the family here before seeing a concert at MSG. Great food, ambience and proximity to the garden. Service was excellent and table was ready right on time for our 5:00 reservations.
Favorite place to eat before a concert at MSG. Food is excellent, service quick.
Friendly staff and great good.
Great place before heading to MSG
Sat us in stools with no back, were not accommodating to switch to booth or table, food was very good
Great place to chill with friends and watch the game - good food !
Amazing lunch with my father before a game. Thank you
We went after a game af the Garden. They seated us right at our reservation time so that was great. Our server Gabby was fantastic! She made the evening fun. Food is just okay thought and not worth the money. Salads with protein can run $30.
Maybe, depending on the friend. If you like a noisy sports bar atmosphere, it's fine. Too noisy for a private conversation though. Food is a bit overpriced too.
Open table let me make a reservation for 9:30am; however the restaurant doesn’t open until 11am.
Hello. Mustang Harry’s opens DAILY at 7:30AM for breakfast until 11AM. Sat and Sunday we serve brunch from 11AM to 3PM in addition to your regular lunch menu. On the date of your visit Mustang Harry’s opened our doors 10 minutes early at 7:20AM and put through our first breakfast order around 7:25AM.
Interesting menu but, overpriced for the very average food quality. Service was above average though.
Mustang Harry’s never disappoints!
My husband, son , and I had a fun dinner prior to our MSG Knick VS Lakers game.
Excellent venue. From front door to wait staff are all 5 star
Had a great birthday brunch here for my boyfriend! Their bottomless brunch menu is however outdated on opentable so I suggest calling ahead for specials and pricing.
Family reunion - it was a little noisy when we arrived but they put us at a table in the back which was perfect. We could talk comfortably. They were very patient with us - and kept filling our water glasses long after we ordered our last drink. We didn't feel rushed. I was very pleased with the service - really terrific night. I was so impressed by the service.
Great place for pre/ post game meal or drinks when visiting MSG. Great service and establishment.
From the time you walk in the door being greeted by Luis, until you depart with professional wait servers is a first class experience.
Waited 1 hour for our meal. They used instant mash potatoes. They were gracious enough to take that entree off the bill. Drinks & burgers only. Fun spot
So this was my groups 4th or 5th time going to Mustang Harry’s before an event at MSG. Sadly this time they were inundated with large parties and their kitchen couldn’t keep up. We ordered just apps and drinks and gave up after an hour without receiving our food. The manager was very apologetic and he comped our bill for both food and drinks. We left a big tip for the poor waitress who was run off her feet. Won’t let this last experience deter us from going back.
We arrived at the restaurant and were advised that the restaurant is no longer honoring reservations made on OpenTable. If so, the restaurant should remove itself from the system.
We apologize for any misunderstanding. We do use Open Table for booking reservations, as well as 7rooms and Google. However, for parties larger than 6 you should be promoted to call the restaurant to make a reservation. Again we are truly sorry for any mixup .
Disappointing. Our waitress seemed to have lost our order. We had 1.25 hr before we had to leave for the Rangers game. They served us 1 hr in. Had 3 bites of my burger before we had to leave. No apology. No break on the price. $250 meal for 4 with none of us getting to enjoy our meal.
We were there on a lively Sunday afternoon during a Ravens game. Good food, good service but hard to talk over the game. The filet should have been cut into smaller pieces for my personal taste.
Very busy place, food was good. Waitress was too busy, but still did a nice job. Burger was 8 out of 10. Brussels were good.
Thank you for the good review. Hope you come back soon.
Mustang Harry's is rated 4.2 stars by 605 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.