The bar and restaurant were full with St. Patrick’s day celebrants, but that didn’t deter from the excellent food and service; becoming a favorite restaurant before concerts, hockey games etc. The specials which included Irish favorites were on point with delicious Irish beef stew and Shepherds Pie. The service was very attentive & we had a great time.
Solid place, fun music for Post or pre game at MSG.
Went here for dinner before an event at MSG. Nice atmosphere in the back of the restaurant. Our table was wobbly and server immediately replaced it. We both had salads with shrimp and everything was fresh and surprisingly good. Would go back
Excellent food and great service. Would certainly return. Ideal location for MSG events
I was going to a KNICKS Game with family of 4. Seated quick. Good burgers and salads.
It's a glorified fridays...below average food..loud ...next to garden so it's good for quick average food...yummy hot pretzel..a plus
I come here when come to shows at MSG, Awesome food and service!
Overall a good experience
I will definitely be back my next time in town. The food was delicious.
I had been to Mustang Harry's many times before after sporting events at the Garden. This time, we had reservations, however we were led to a table that was right by the furnace, and it was incredibly uncomfortable. We asked the waiter if he could address the heat, but it seemed that his options were limited to do so.
The food was good, but not as good as I remembered, and it took almost 2 hours to be served, so I found myself apologizing to my friends since it was my recommendation to come there.
Attending the Rangers game with out of town friends. Pre-game service slower than usual but our friends are looking forward to returning.
Great place to have a drink, and have a fun night out.
This place was fine for what we wanted. We had 5 teenage girls with various dietary needs, so this place had enough options for everyone. The food was pretty good bar food with some healthier options. The drinks were good too. We would go back if in need of some easy eats. The waitress was very nice, and caught a mistake on the bill very quickly.
Went with my husband and 3 kids. It was great food and service. Also easy to watch the playoff games. Everything was delicious.
We had a great time at Mustang Harry’s. Our waitress did a fantastic job and we really enjoyed the food. Good for large groups watching sporting events
The food was delicious, service excellent! The upstairs dining area was unusually warm which made it somewhat uncomfortable. Otherwise really great meal!
Went here with a group of 6 prior to a show at the garden. We were seated right away, and the staff was fast, friendly and attentive. The food and drinks were great, and everything came out without delay.
We had a limited time for dinner, and we were all amazed by the how quickly they managed to meet our needs on such a busy night! Oh, shepherd's pie was fantastic!
Great option for dining close to the Garden before a Knick and Ranger game. They get you in and out quickly and solid burgers and pub fair. Great selection of beer and lots of tv's all over
In an area not known for many good restaurants, Mustang Harry’s is a decent place, albeit slightly overpriced. The food is a simple good food, nicely served in a plain environment. While Mustang Harry’s did not exceed our expectations, it did not fail them either. A good place for a quick bite.
Great spot before an MSG event. Loaded with Rangers fans pre-game.
Overall we had a good dining experience. The food was average drinks were good waitress was exceptional!! We will go back and try dinner items instead of sandwiches.
We had the misfortune of getting a poor waitress. I did noticed that she was attentive to her other tables. Another waitress came over to discuss the menu with us but our waitress vanished. We had to waive her down as she walked by our table just to order food and another round of drinks.
Made reservations for two, but we were seated twice because the host was confused about where to put us. Waiter was incredibly slow. Got one order entirely wrong, and the other was poor quality. One meal was inedible...the risotto was so undercooked it was crunchy, and the salmon tasted spoiled. Also forgot to bring the salad dressing for salad and, when asked for a third time, brought over olive oil. Not empathetic to any of this and couldn’t rectify.
This was my 5th time here and was a stark contrast to my other experiences which had been tasty and efficient. But, had this been my first visit I’d never return....though it was so poor I’m considering never going back now.
We went to Mustang Harry's before a show at MSG for lunch. The atmosphere was great and perfect for adults and kids. Apparently some of the staff did not show and so service was a little slow since there was only one waitress helping all tables. Our food was very slow to come out and a couple of the orders were wrong. However, the manager came over at the end and apologized over and over and ended up comping our bill. It was very nice and unexpected. Up until then we were never going to come back. However based on the fact that the food was very fast and the atmosphere was cool, we will definitely go back again.
Perfect quick bite before the game at MSG. Good food, great service in a traditional pub atmosphere.
Very good. Don't like being told I have one hour to eat !!
Went to Mustang Harry's prior to the Andrea Bocelli concert. Service was great, food was good. Definitely a fun place but more for the young. Noise level was where it should be for the crowd that was there. Seating in the back for those looking for a bit more quiet. Would go back again as it is a fun atmosphere.
Great place to grab dinner before a game at MSG due to proximity. Sports type bar & food. Nice atmosphere, decorated nicely for Christmas season. Food & service was great. Note: Don't ask to sit at booth if you are under 5'3", your feet will not touch the foot rest. Yes, we would come again.
Atmosphere, service, food, and drinks were all great! Super great for brunch and good prices for being in NYC
One of my favorite spots in nyc to meet friends and have a bite to eat.
Reservation at 530 on Tuesday in advance of game at garden. Place was a zoo and ridiculously loud. Sat at table for 20 minutes and couldn’t get a waiter so left. Maybe it’s better if there is no event at the garden.
Good food and service. They rushed us! We had a 330pm reservation and about 345 they came over to us and said that this table has a 430pm reservation, meaning....hurry up! If we didn’t have show tickets I would give out up my feet and ordered a few more drinks!🍺
Food is very good. Particularly the buffalo wings. Excellent dirty Martini’s. Perfect, in fact! The server was very good. (The calamari also good but the sauces they serve with it can be better. Try learning how to make a real Italian marinara sauce and you will nail that dish.
Convenient to NY Penn Station, Madison Square Garden and the surrounding area, we visited primarily due to location and positive Opentable reviews. We were fortunate to have just missed the NY Rangers crowd, so we had a nice quiet meal. Food (burger, salad, and fried chicken sandwich) were all very good. Service from our wait staff was excellent, with authentic Irish charm. The front-of-the-house greeter was moody and did not set an example consistent with the restaurant staff. Pricing was quite reasonable for the area. If in the area again, we'd likely be back.
Best place to eat before a game at the Garden. Always great food, fast service and decent value for you dollar.
We had a big party of 12 and the server was very accommodating. He made recommendations and everything he suggested was delicious!
Great location but lacking in service and customer needs. We came in for a family dinner before a concert and it took 40 mins just to get drinks. We left and will never look back. Shame on you!
Excellent atmosphere. Despite heavy traffic, our server was all over it. Great experience from the moment we walked in at 7pm on a busy Saturday night.
Recommend reservations during peak hours.
Unorganized and late seating even though we arrived 15 minutes prior to reservation.
Restaurant was recommended by family member as a good place to eat before attending a concert at MSG. Staff was pleasant, food adequate but french fries were extremely salty, Noise volume was deafening. . . . . . but perhaps thats a generational preference.