Mr. Benny's Steakhouse
South African and Australian cold water lobster tails along with wild Alaskan salmon and Canadian fresh water walleye and lake perch. Along with other Mr Benny"s specialties.
This is one of our favorite restaurants, but we normally go mid-week so we were not prepared for the noise level of a Friday night. The steaks here are juicy and perfectly cooked. The wine list is varied, with selections for every price range. We did not stay for dessert because of the almost deafening noise. It's nice to see the restaurant is so very popular, and deservedly so, but we'll go back to dining on quieter evenings at an earlier time.
Mr. Benny’s is ALWAYS fabulous!!!!
The food and service were amazing. we will definitely return.
Service here was outstanding. We dined with friends and were looking forward to catching up on news. The server took drink orders and left menus as soon as we sat down and then left us time to sit and talk before telling us the specials. The bartender stopped by to see if we were happy with the cocktails. When our appetizer arrived she took our dinner order but did not submit it until we were nearly finished with the appetizer. She checked up on us without being overbearing, allowing us to enjoy the evening. Our meal was excellent. My walleye was fresh and cooked perfectly. My wife had the pork chop special and ended up bringing some home. She said it was the best chop she had ever gotten in a restaurant. The dinners came with choice of soup and salad. We both had salad and the lettuce was cold and crisp. The tiramasu was large enough to split. Overall a great experience.
Lisa was very friendly & had great knowledge of food selection & was very attentive, we will be back....
We had a great time at Mr Benny’s. It was my first time there. Erin was a great waitress. Very friendly and nice. Food was excellent and management made you feel very welcome
Best steaks in the area, great service,
Great evening celebrating a 93rd Birthday!
Outstanding food! Our waitress was very sweet and we had s great anniversary dinner!
All ways great food and the staff isoutstanding
The food was absolutely delicious. We went for my husband's birthday and the food and drinks were delicious. We were seated in the bar area and it was a little noisy but otherwise everything was fine.
Vicki was our server, actually she is part owner and alot of fun, the food was great, service was awesome
Will make this our go to place for now on
The best filet mignon I've eaten in a long time...superb taste and texture as well as perfectly cooked rare. It was like butter melting in my mouth, and you can't beat the price for such great quality Angus either.
My husband had the lake perch with the double baked potato, which he loved both. My son had the New York strip, and thoroughly enjoyed it as well.
Seems to be a very popular place for regulars and the older crowd. The owner came over to talk with us not once, but three times. He was as sweet as can be! We'll be dining there more often and become a regular in no time flat!
Service was wonderful, very friendly. Ribs were good, but a little tough, not tender. Would love to go back and try other dishes that also looked good. Coconut shrimp looked very good.
Spur of the moment dinner. Had a great time at Mr. Benny's. Food was awesome, service was great and drinks were poured mighty fine. Highly recommend this joint, it's excellent.
Guys night out nothing less than spectacular! Great Food, Fun and Laughter had by all.
Excellent as always! Filets were very good, and cooked perfectly!
The ambiance, the staff (especially Laura), the owners all made us feel so welcome without being pushy or intrusive. The food was outstanding! Could not have asked for a better dining experience.
Benny's is our "go to" restaurant for fine dining. The food is always delicious, the owners are personable yet professional, providing excellent service. While it is not necessarily a family restaurant for children and large family groups, it IS a wonderful escape for adults who simply want a quality dinner in
a nice setting.
Price was far too high for food. Steak was undercooked and upcharge for two twice baked potatoes was $10.00. We will probably not go again.
Food, ambiance and service were great! They made my birthday celebration memorable.
Our server was excellent. Between my wife and I, we had the steak filet and the shrimp marinara/bed of noodles. Unfortunately, we found both items to be bland in flavor. We had an appetizer of fried mushrooms, and they too were without much seasoning. We've eaten here before and had enjoyed the food. We looked forward to our return visit but this time around, our expectations were let down. We'll try again in the future in the event the lack of seasoning may have been a fluke. Thanks for listening.
Excellent service by Connie and the rest of the wait staff. Food was excellent. We had the Oysters Nicholas, stuffed mushrooms (on special) and the bone-in filets (also on special). We ordered them rare and they came out perfectly. The steaks melted in our mouth. Finished the dinner with a perfectly brewed cappuccino and a tiramisu. First time diners and we will definitely be back again.
Always great food for the price
Food and service was and always is excellent. We all enjoyed our meal and the friendly staff. Thank you for a great evening.
Service was fantastic, atmosphere was great but food was a bit flavorless. For the price the steaks we ordered were not very good. My husband always orders a bone in rib eye and we never mind paying top dollar, but it really was a bit tough and flavorless.
We had a great time. Lauren was extremely attentive to us. When we go back, I would love to have her again. They would see me once a week if they had Miller high Life, but Miller lite is not a problem
Vicki our server was really amazing and took great care of us. We will be back
Food and service were excellent - highly recommend Mr. Benny’s. They make your dining experience feel like you are their only customer- from the bartenders to the wait staff to the busboys and of course to the chefs - each person makes the meal most enjoyable and delicious!
Disappointing experience this time. MR steak was served burned on one side. New steak served extra rare and cold, thank goodness they left a hot plate on the table so I could at least bring the filet to a rare +. Other filet ordered MR, served medium +, prime rib lukewarm at best. Thankfully had a gift card, otherwise would have been very disappointed in a $210 dinner. Linz meats offers a solid product, shame it's not being prepared properly.
My favorite restaurant!
Excellent restaurant and excellent service from all!
I Love this restaurant everyone was so friendly an my boyfriend enjoyed his birthday.
Mr. Benny's is always a guaranteed phenomenal experience. The staff, dinner and atmosphere is definately top notch.
This was our first time. We received a gift card for Christmas . Just moved into the area. We will be in again. Excellent food and service!
Another wonderful dinner at Mr Benny’s. Food was delicious. Always a treat!
Every thing was absolutely wonderful, no complaints at all.
One of our favorites for many years. Wonderful family owners!
The blacken sea bass was terrible. 1st blacken does not mean burnt. The 2nd mistake was serving the burnt fish in a serving with about a 1/4" of clarified butter.