Nearby points of interest
Nearby points of interest
About Mr. Benny's Steakhouse
Steak and Seafood serving Prime and Black Angus and wild species of seafood
South African and Australian cold water lobster tails along with wild Alaskan salmon and Canadian fresh water walleye and lake perch. Along with other Mr Benny"s specialties.
Mokena, IL 60448
Steakhouse, American, Seafood
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Tuesday - Sunday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm
$31 to $50
AMEX, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
ample parking free
Banquet, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Gluten-free Menu, Non-Smoking, Outdoor Smoking Area, Wine
Mr. Benny's Steakhouse Ratings and Reviews
Mr. Benny's is one of our favorite restaurants for celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, or just date night. The filet's are the best. Great Shrimp cocktails and my husband loves the lobster. Their homemade au gratin potatoes are delicious. Nick the bartender is fantastic and makes the best cosmopolitan I have ever had. Our favorite place to sit is in the bar area in the big booths. Service is always outstanding too.
$ 85.00 Lobster tail, bone dry. Way over cooked. They tried to redo my Delmonico steak twice, ordered it medium rare came out very well done, second time it came out raw with some grill marks.
As it was my dads birthday we tought we would go to a classy steak house, Not so much.
The person that we was told was the owner, told me twice that there is no reason to be upset.
Way over priced, we will never go back.
This comes from an chef who has been in the business for over 40 years.
We went with 3 other couples on a return request from 2 of the couples. Mr. Benny’s is one of our favorites and now it’s one of their favorites too. It’s a pretty restaurant and has such a warm welcoming atmosphere. The menu has something for everyone and everything is delicious. The steaks are always prepared as ordered and have a great flavor. Top quality too. I had the shrimp dejonge and they were jumbo and delicious. Someone else had the sautéed perch and she loved it. They also raved about the lobster, bbq ribs and chicken Tuscany. Rack of lamb was outstanding . The prices here are so reasonable for the quality I can’t imagine going to any other steakhouse. And the price of your entree includes soup or salad, baked potato and vegetable. We’ve even hosted parties there in their private rooms and they were exceptional.
So if you’re looking for a place to impress someone, celebrate a special occasion or just have an excellent meal Mr. Benny’s is the place to go.
We enjoyed our wonderful meal and experience at Mr. Benny’s. If we ever had a special occasion again that we wanted a wonderful place to go again, we will choose Mr Benny’s. Everyone’s steak was cooked perfectly. The oysters were delicious. Absolutely try it if looking for a comfortable place to celebrate a family occasion.
Unfortunately our dining experience was not up to par this time the sea bass was extremely salty on the outside and the filet was charred too much on the outside, resulting in over powering taste on both entrees. Otherwise everything else was impeccable including the service
Been coming here for years. We started going out to find other places (my wife and I are foodies) but started coming back here in the last year or so. This is the go to place when we haven't decided to trek out to somewhere new. We always can count on a really good meal, love the owners, and the old time supper club feel. Sorry about the passing of Benny, he was a legend.
Really wanted to like this place more. Service, atmosphere, and overall experience was great. Not sure if it’s jist how this place does it or if we were just unlucky. Shrimp appetizer was great. My wife got the surf and turf. Ladies filet and lobster tale. Both great portions. But her steak had no seasoning or flavor to it. And $100 for the plate was a little much. I got the 20oz rib-eye. Again great portion but zero seasoning on it. Both dishes and appetizer were cooked perfect. Just disappointed in the seasoning or lack of on both steaks. Might try it again. Also, drink we’re a little on the pricey side as well. $10 for a Moscow mule. It’s Mokena, not Chicago. Service and atmosphere were great tho, which is why we might give it another try.
Never heard of this place before. Needed a place in the area for dinner with friends. Food was very good. Lobster tail was excellent! Steak was good. Service a bit slow.
Bar was full of regulars and was comfortable. Bartender, Nick, was very friendly and great with names.
The menu items were not explained or described at all. As a person with allergies, I need to know what is added to the dish. When I asked the waitress about gluten free choices, she was rude and not very helpful. I would not recommend this resturaunt for people with food sensitivities or allergies.
Mr. Benny's is a regional favorite in Southwest Suburban Chicagoland. Run by the Leonardo family it never fails to please. On this trip, a date night with my wife and I alone, our experience was delightful. My preference is a booth in the bar area with a nice window view. Our entrees of choice were the perfectly prepared walleye, mine blackened, my wife chose the pan fried. Served with complementary salad or soup, it was an excellent value. A good wine list, also reasonably priced allowed us to make the meal complete. Being greeted by owners, Joy, Larry and Nick Leonardo also made us remember why this has been a long standing favorite of ours. Highly recommended.
This is one our favorite restaurants for a good steak dinner. Never had a bad one! Nick makes the best Cosmos every time! My husband gets Lobster here for his birthday every year (special treat) Had my 50th birthday party here years ago. Love to celebrate here or just have a nice date night. Started going with my parents when Mr. Benny's was on Cicero Ave. decades ago. Love this restaurant!
This was our first time at your establishment. From the moment we entered we were greeted in a friendly manner and seated promptly. Our server, Connie, was top notch. She greeted us with a big smile, asked if this was our first time here and asked if we were celebrating anything. We were celebrating our 30th Wedding Anniversary. Our anniversary is September 18th. We enjoyed everything about your place. Connie was so thoughtful. She brought us a little ice cream with a candle in each dish for our celebration. Connie made our dinner a very good experience. We will be back!! Thank You!!!
Please sign in to record your input. Thanks!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.