Mr. Benny's Steakhouse
South African and Australian cold water lobster tails along with wild Alaskan salmon and Canadian fresh water walleye and lake perch. Along with other Mr Benny"s specialties.
New York Strip Steak
Boneless, 16 Oz.
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Steamed to Perfection, 1 Full lb. *Split Open For You
Our server Lisa was outstanding. We had mushrooms stuffed with sausage, the rack of lamb, bone-in ribeye topped with nicely season crab meat all cooked medium, sided with broccoli and a baked potato. Dessert was spumoni and peppermint ice cream and a slice of key lime pie.
Perfect dinner for a birthday. We enjoyed the steak and crab legs.
Roxanne was great and so were the au gratin potatoes
Best bartender Nick always remembers me as his gin drinker, and my ketel one husband. Great food and service, as always.
great customer service , great ambiance, tasy food
Service was amazing. Staff is very polite and hard working. My wife and I got a filets and the steaks were not evenly cooked through.
Always excellent, if a bit pricey.
From the moment you walk in and seated your are treated like one of the family. The service And the attention to detail as your dining is impeccable. And the food well of course it’s amazing cooked perfect and balanced Well with spices
As always this place and service is amazing.
Everything was great! Service was attentive but respectful...great food!
Vickie is absolutely amazing. We always ask for her. She is friendly, open, flexible, listens well, checks in often, makes good suggestions, and even pretends she remembers us!
The appetizer, soup and salad, and main course showed up exactly at the right times. EVERYTHING was absolutely first rate.
Wonderful atmosphere. Service and food was amazing!
Every time I go to Mr.Binneys The food and service is second to none.
Table was ready on arrival, all staff were very attentive, food excellent!
Great food, cocktails, and service!
Always dependable solid and good. Perch is above average.
The steaks are delicious but sometimes have a bit too much char. Every meal is very good and the service is top notch.
Our server was top notch and the food is always great.
Food was excellent. Service was fabulous.
Best service, perfectly cooked to perfection steaks!
We use to go to the one in Matteson, once it closed we were disappointed. We finally made it to this one and we were glad we made our reservation for our 19 Anniversary. We talk with two of the long time employees/manager and we felt like we were home. Thank you to all that waited on us. We will be back for sure.
Wonderful family restaurant. Very friendly and attentive. Definitely going back.
Everyone smiled and greeted us, the recommendations we were given were very good.
Crab legs were amazing as was steak and fried zucchini
We hadn't been their for years and realize we need to go more often as we missed
Food was delicious as usual. The staff was very attentive and polite. Very efficient wait staff. We were greeted by the owners and thanked upon our departure. This is a really great upscale restaurant.
From the moment we sat down, til the moment we left... the staff was extremely attentive. Our server Debbie was very knowledgeable, polite, and just on top of everything. We got lucky and got a seat right by the open kitchen window. Super cool to see the grill master at work. We got the moscow oysters (amazing), wedge salad (was craving this and it HIT THE SPOT), french onion soup, surf and turf (beautiful and delicious lobster tail, perfectly cooked filet), and a perfect delmonico steak. Finished with an excellent tiramisu. Will definitely be back!! The staff, restaurant, and patrons are following all COVID-19 guidelines... THANK YOU!
very good place to eat overall. waitress was very friendly and gave us plenty of time to relax and talk in between courses. restaurant was very clean. would definitely eat there again and would recommend to anyone looking for a good meal.
Our first time there and will go back! Everything was amazing!
Nice family dinner
Out server was excellent! Food is always amazing.
Service was very good. Food was good, not great, but good. Steak was a little under done. Shrimp dejonge was okay
Andy was an excellent waiter. Food was great too!
As usual the food and service was amazing! Our favorite restaurant by far.
Awesome restaurant...first time and thoroughly enjoyed our meal, the staff and the ambiance.
Very great experience
Excellent food & service, we love this family owned steakhouse.
Best friend engagement
Always great food, great people, and friendly service.
Amazing as always! Amazing service and food!!! Best crab legs on the south side!
Celebrated our 48th Anniversary, I had lobster, husband had Filet and Crab leg combo. Everything was delicious! Nice place to go to celebrate a birthday or anniversary. It’s a little pricey, but not as bad as going to Chicago, plus not as far. Will go back!
Mr. Benny's Steakhouse offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (708) 478-5800.
Mr. Benny's Steakhouse is rated 4.9 stars by 584 OpenTable diners.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.