This was our first visit to Mr. Benny's following a recommendation of close friends. We were not disappointed. Both food and service was excellent, and was well worth the 35 minute drive. We will most definitely be back.
Love their au gratin potatoes!! Steak was very good!!
Mr. Benny's is a great steakhouse. The servers, staff and service gets two thumbs up!
We love Mr. Benny’s especially for special occasions! The atmosphere is very relaxing. The Sinatra music is wonderful dinner music! We never feel rushed and the food is fantastic! I highly recommend Mr. Benny’s for any occasion!
Salmon not great. Everything else ok
We were celebrating a birthday the night we were there. Had a wonderful evening, Connie our server was great. This is a hidden gem in a small town...no need to go to Oak Brook or Lombard for dinner. We have been here several times and have recommended to family and friends. For us, it's the kind of place you go to for a special occasion or you just want to treat yourself to a great meal.
Not my first time at Mr. Benny’s. As always, great service, delicious food (their steaks are fantastic). I would recommend Mr. Benny’s to anyone for a great dining experience.
We save going to Mr.Benny's for very special occasions,only. We dress special and feel we are treated that way from the moment we walk in
Strip steak is always a good choice. Great south suburb steak and seafood spot. Never had a bad dinner there!
I really enjoyed my dinner for my daughter’s birthday! She & my grandson also enjoyed their dinner! They both had steak & I had Lake Perch! The food was outstanding & the most important thing I have to mention, our waitress, Victoria was the BEST! I eat out very often, at very nice restaurants & Victoria was one of the best waitress I have ever had!
I will highly recommend Mr Benny’s!!!
First time there, I have to say....amazing! Everything was so good. Our server, our food, table was waiting for us when we arrived! But the thing that set it above and beyond, one of the owners coming to our table to make sure we enjoyed our meal and took 5 minutes to chat with us. When he found out we were there for the first time and it was my wife’s birthday he brought us over a small after dinner drink for free, not to mention to scoop of ice cream and candle the the server brought my wife minutes before. Totally worth the money and will be heading back there for another special dinner in the future!!
Great food, steak is as good or better than we've had at downtown Chicago steak houses and crab legs are fantastic.
Our meal was very good. Steaks were cooked to our request. Our waitress was excellent and attentive.
Service was excellent, enjoyed our 1st time there, will definitely be back.
This was our first time at Mr. Benny's since we recently moved back to this area after being gone for 25 years. I, my husband, son, and his fiance (who came to visit from NY), enjoyed every thing about Mr. Benny's. The warm welcome, the fantastic food, the great service - just everything. I truly enjoyed talking with Nick and reminiscing about my brother, John who frequented there often and befriended especially Nick. Thanks for the great experience. We will see you again.
The hostess was much friendlier than the usual hostess. Made us feel welcomed as if it was her home.
Simply perfect. Food and service were outstanding.
The food was absolutely fantastic and the service was just as good. Nicky at the bar was awesome. We had a great time
Awesome as usual! The food was delicious and the celebratory drinks were much appreciated. Thanks, Larry!
This was our first visit to Mr. Benny's and it will not be the last. Connie, our server, was amazing; gave us plenty of time to look over the menu and ask questions. We never felt rushed. Sausage stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer, Mr. Benny's steak and lamb chops for the entrees followed by tiramisu and coffee for dessert. Before and after dinner cocktails along with wine for dinner rounded out the meal.
Service was terrible. Our server came back less than 30 seconds after taking our order to ask what my boyfriend had for his salad dressing. Then, I asked for a medium well steak and it came to the table extremely rare. When we asked our server if they could cook it longer, she said "oh medium well?" And questioned it and made it seem like what we wanted was wrong. I'm assuming she put it in the computer wrong for the cooks. We then asked to see the dessert menu. Our waitress comes back about 15 minutes later and asks us if we decided on anything. Turns out...she never brought the menu so we had no clue. She said "oops" and hurried to get one for us. Won't be back. Food was mediocre.
We had a lovely Valentines dinner on Tuesday.
Our server Emi was fantastic and made our experience a wonderful one.
Lovely dinner with my husband. Service and food, outstanding!
Usually go here when we want a 5 star experience close to home
The stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer were very good. Although you only get 4 in an order, they hit the spot. The filet was melt in your mouth perfection! Also loved the double baked potato. Even though there is an extra charge, it was worth the price! The atmosphere was great if you want to celebrate a special occasion, not over the top fancy, but just enough to make it feel special. The staff were friendly and continually checking on us to make sure everything was o.k.
Everything was just right. Vicki took great care of us, party of 8 with widely varying tastes!
Service was excellent and our waitress was very attentive!!! She went out of her way to celebrate our anniversary. Food was very good. Overall it is pricey.
Our server was so friendly and offered great suggestions!
Mr. Benny's is one of our favorites restaurants in the area. We frequent Mr. Benny's for dinner with family and friends and it's our choice for special occasions.
We were seated immediately and Peggy, our waitress, welcomed us and told us the daily specials. The steaks were perfect, hot, juicy and cooked just right. Two of us ordered the double-baked potato and we were disappointed. For costing an extra $4.99, they were nothing special, in fact they weren't even quite hot enough.
One thing I wish were different and that's the background music. Frank Sinatra was singing the whole time and that music was playing the last time we came also. I could skip Frank but I wish at least there might be a mixture of music, more variety. Yes, I would go again and I would recommend the restaurant. But I'm not ordering that double-baked potato.
Vegetables were cold. I've always been served a baked potato, tin foil open and potato split. Not here.
Our Waitress Lauren was so warm and sweet knew her specials and we NEVER wanted for anything.
Thank you Lauren for making our first date so special.
service was awesome"Debbie" food was delicious and hot cooked to perfection
Great food, excellent service, personal touch!
Phenomenal food and service. The food was superb, and the drinks were exceptional. A gem tucked away in mokena!
Always delicious! Never disappoints! Love the ambience
Mr. Benny's is one of our favorite restaurants for celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, or just date night. The filet's are the best. Great Shrimp cocktails and my husband loves the lobster. Their homemade au gratin potatoes are delicious. Nick the bartender is fantastic and makes the best cosmopolitan I have ever had. Our favorite place to sit is in the bar area in the big booths. Service is always outstanding too.
$ 85.00 Lobster tail, bone dry. Way over cooked. They tried to redo my Delmonico steak twice, ordered it medium rare came out very well done, second time it came out raw with some grill marks.
As it was my dads birthday we tought we would go to a classy steak house, Not so much.
The person that we was told was the owner, told me twice that there is no reason to be upset.
Way over priced, we will never go back.
This comes from an chef who has been in the business for over 40 years.
Excellent food, great ambiance, our server was knowledgeable and very friendly and attentive. A great experience. We will go again and again.
LOVE LOVE LOVE MR. BENNY'S!!!!!!!! Its not your everyday kinda restaurant since its not cheap but when we go there for an occasion its well worth it! Their steaks are the most tender I have ever eaten!