Mr. Benny's Steakhouse
South African and Australian cold water lobster tails along with wild Alaskan salmon and Canadian fresh water walleye and lake perch. Along with other Mr Benny"s specialties.
We had an outstanding time at Mr. Benny's. We received a gift card for Christmas and put it to good use. For Wine we enjoyed a bottle of 75 and for appetizers we had a shrimp cocktail that was very meaty and delicious and delicious half shelf oysters. We both enjoyed a ribeye steak dinner. Mine was an aged bone in and was enjoyed rare, cooked to perfection, seared on the outside and delicious marbling. Everything from the green beans to the baked potatoe was on point, we also enjoyed the cottage fries which I have never had a potato chip/fry taste so good. Dinner was followed by one of my favorite desserts Italian style Bread Pudding and it is now one of my favorite bread puddings. I highly recommend Mr Benny's. Our Waitress Connie made us feel like family and even gave us a hug on our departure. That hit home for us. Thank You Mr. Benny's, keep it up. (Nina-Joliet, IL)
exceptional - best South Side Steak restaurant - great drinks - fresh salads - incredible steak -
Made reservations by way of open table on line. Very convenient. Service was great and drinks were very good. Meal was excellent and we always recommend coming to your restaurant especially for special occasions.
What an amazing gem of a steakhouse! My colleague and I were looking for places to eat in Tinley Park, saw the write-up in Open Table, so we booked the reservation. I am so glad we did! The ambiance was great, the staff, even better, and the food was amazing!
We started off with an appetizer unique to Chicago; never heard of it, so we tried it, and we loved it. We both had steaks, and both were amazing. Perfectly cooked, juicy, tender, seasoned perfectly, and served with sides that complimented the meat perfectly. Comparing the food to the prices, we got a steal of a deal.
We travel to the Tinley quite often, and will make it a point to visit Mr Benny's on every trip. Thank you for the great service and the amazing food; I'll be back!
Our server, Erin, was great! She was very attentive and let us enjoy our cocktails before ordering. The food was excellent and everyone at our table enjoyed their meal.
First time guest at Mr Benny's and I was impressed. The service was outstanding. Our waitress Erin was so nice she even brought a complimentary dessert to me bc I said I love spumoni icecream but was too full to order dessert. She said it was a small scoop, so I could just try it. I ordered veal piccata and my husband ordered Walley both were delicious. The manager or owner, Larry, came to our table to make sure everything was up to paar. Class place with great food and service without going downtown. Can't wait to return.
Has the feel of an elegant old time supper club. Service is friendly and efficient. Variety of dishes include steaks, seafood, Italian and the food is excellent (this visit we had lamb chops and blackened salmon; also a jumbo shrimp cocktail; they have a great french dressing to which I add blue cheese crumbles). The booths in the lounge are romantic . . . great for celebrating an anniversary. Generous pours of liquor. It's not cheap (check online menu for prices) but we think it is worth the money. Summer time there are table for outdoor dining. They have a big parking lot - parking never a problem.
Sever Connie was wonderful. The shrimp was as the menu reads Delicious. Owners on top of everything with Class. Serverbacks (busboys) on point with every table. Happy and oh so friendly environment.
Mr Benny’s never disappoints! You are part of the family when you dine.
Beautiful dinner, Connie was our Waitress and she was just SUPER. Our Children, Kyle and Danielle Weis had our 50th Anniversary Dinner here in August, and they bought us a gift card for my Birthday Dec 2. We would highly recommend Mr Benny’s to all our friends. Thank You for 2 memorable evenings.
Very Cozy...service and food was amazing !!!
Friends moving away
Great place for prime steaks!
Great service great food perfect anniversary/birthday dinner
This is a place I love to experience every December. It is so festive. Puts me in a really good mood.
As always, just perfect!
We had an amazing time! It was our Anniversary and they brought us out a delicious bowl of ice cream each.
Steak and lobster tail were superb, great ambience and service.
Delicious meal, wonderful service. Steaks were all cooked to perfection even the one that was asked to be well done. Unlike some of the other steak places in Chicagoland everything is not al la carte. This is a positive experience for a meal. We will definitely be back.
Food was outstanding, our server was great! We wanted time to catch up with each other and our server was very considerate of this
This is one of our favorite places! An excellent restaurant for a date, group outing and also wonderful private rooms for a special occasion. There are very few restaurants like Me. Benny’s! They are in a class of their own. A wonderful family run business that never disappoints!
CLASSY RESTAURANT WITH GREAT FOOD AND SERVICE. DECOR IS LUSH YET FEELS INVITING. THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO IF YOU WANT TO FEEL SPECIAL.
My wife ordered the Mr. Benny's Delmonico Steak. It was done to perfection. It was very tender. I don't remember the last time I had such a good steak, yes I ate some of my wife's steak. It was a very large portion. I had the ribs and they were good, but oh that steak. The service was excellent. We were not hurried, nor did we have to wait. We sat at a booth & it felt very intimate. It was my wife's birthday and she was greeted with birthday wishes and ice cream for desert. It was our first visit, but it will not be our last
Food was really good steak was cooked to perfection and service was great.
Mr. Benny's is the absolute best Steakhouse in the area. The service is remarkable and the food is absoultey delicious.
The steaks are cooked to perfection and the wine list very good
They make you feel like family. Great service, Food never disappoints. Wonderful drinks.
Rebecca, our waitress was very knowledgeable about the menu. The food was excellent and the restaurant was nicely decorated for Christmas.
Had a great night and dinner with friends. Have visited Mr. Benny’s for years and never disappoints. Exception restaurant in all ways.
This was our first time here and Connie made it a visit to remember!
Great date might
It was very good service was great will definitely go back!
great restaurant, the owners were visible and made us feel welcomed! Great server, excellent food and and overall an excellent dinner experience.
Fantastic food! The lobster tail is to die for and the au gratin potatoes are yummo! We will be back again. Our server was very attentive and down to earth.
This is an old Fashion Steak House, which is missing in our area. A real gem, make sure to visit as many times as you can.
Wonderful staff & service! Beautiful atmosphere! We will be going back!
Great steaks in an "Old School" atmosphere, right down to the personable owners. The menu is reasonably priced so you won't have to take out a second mortgage to get a huge, tender steak.
Very professional, The food was amazing , steaks are cooked perfect and the lobster tail is outstanding. the waitress was extremely good with menu , also would like to say I will be coming back again soon.
Debbie is great loving this place cant wait to come back again and become a regular
If you want to have a special evening with a great meal and friendly service or just for a late night cocktail with friends, Mr. Benny's is your place. The service was excellent and the food was great.