We will work with you to plan your private event including customized menus, wine pairings and audio-visual needs. Mitchell's Steakhouse at Polaris offers three different private dining options for our guests.View Private Dining Details
Awesome atmosphere, everyone in there was very friendly and welcoming!
We celebrated our daughter’s 16th birthday. They had a birthday message on the menu for her! Our steaks were excellent as well as everything else.
Took grandchildren for an expensive steak four course dinner. Good attention from staff but unfortunately the food was mediocre and certainly not worthy of the expense. The restaurant looked worn. The menu is good but quality of food was not.
greatdrinks, food and service. Server helpful with making choicesv
This place was really great. Super accommodating for our large group and the food was fantastic. Definitely recommend visiting if you are in the area and looking for a great steakhouse. Will definitely visit again if in the area.
The food was ok, nothing to write home about. I've been to better steak houses, e.g The Steer Barn and The Top Steakhouse; their meats are of much better quality than Mitchells for the same price.
It was an amazing steak house!
Friend from out of town!
Wonderful food, service was great. Never disappoints.
Everything was excellent, except it was too dark to see the menu and the food.
Had a party of 7 people. Everyone loved their steaks. The only thing was the scallops were a tad undercooked but that is just a personal preference. Service was very good, a little slow but it was a busy Friday night so understandable. The ambience was really nice.
Celebrating wedding anniversary, had reservation but arrived early and was seated without a problem, staff was pleasant,upbeat,professional,food was hot and very tasty..and We were treated to a dessert of our choice for our anniversary. Thank you for a nice evening.
The bartender was not very attentive.. took longer than it should have to even order our drinks.
The server was great and food was very good!
You always know you will have an excellent meal and receive top notch service.
Our server Victoria, provided excellent service. She struck the right balance between friendly, informative and follow-up.
We enjoyed our meal and would have given it 5 stars except that my fiancé ordered the 10 ounce filet and was given a 7 ounce
Valentine’s Day dinner. Food was great.
Good food; great location and service. Our place for special occassion & some night outs.
Very disappointed. The steaks were overcooked. Finished sides before my entree returned. Host didn't greet us upon leaving. Had to yell goodbye.
I thought it was a really nice place the service was great I would go back and I will tell people to go there
Service very slow, took at least 10 minutes after seating to just get water. Price not worth value.
This was our first Valentines dinner place, and have come back last 3 years of our marriage, great place for our Valentines day
I feel like Mitchell's Steakhouse is skimming off the good name of Cameron Mitchell's.
I received a gift card, Googled Cameron Mitchell's Polaris, Mitchell's Steakhouse what's the first to appear, made reservations and got stuck with a $150 bill. GIFT CARD NOT ACCEPTED
Multiple acquaintances have had the same Experiences for over $500
FYI Cameron Mitchell sold this restaurant and you can no longer use Cameron Mitchell gift cards there. I did not know this until we all paid (3 families with GC). Long waits between courses, mashed potatoes almost cold, filet and cheesecake amazing! Servers walk your food over from a centralized location not that close to our table. It was a lot of back n forth just to get people food. The place wasn’t busy, no reason for some of this.
It was our second time to visit Mitchell's. We had a very nice experience; the food was very good as was the atmosphere. The service was outstanding. I had a Filet and my wife had a Ribeye, both steaks were cooked to request and very good. We shared Calamari and Oysters for appetizers and mashed potatoes as a sider. All were delicious. Overall we had a great meal. We will return again in the future.
Negative Note: The women's bathroom was left ignored by the staff. The toilets were unclean with TP laying all over the floor and two of the three toilets having no TP. There was a single roll sitting on the sink. Not what you'd expect from this type of restaurant.
Some of the best food in the city. We will definitely be back.
For this level of restaurant the matridee was poor, not assisting with seats and not handing out or explaining the menu. The servers were very good, but the length of time between courses was too long. The food was hot and miss. The main courses were excellent, but the side dishes were not very good.
I was pleased with all except when I received the check. I friend asked if she could have some horseradish sauce which she received with no problem, however when I received the check I was charged $4.00 for a small serving of horseradish. The manager finally took it off the check, however that is not the point. The point is, I frequent many fine restaurants in Columbus and have NEVER been charged for horseradish before. When I asked the waitress if I ordered ketchup would you have charged me she said no. My next question was how can you charge me for the horseradish. She said the chef told her to. I feel that this was unprofessional and have told this story to my friends and they put your restaurant on their do not go to list. This is a sad commentary for a Mitchell restaurant.
Hostess had an attitude-when we asked to be moved-tried to seat us by the kitchen. She said she couldn't move us. I asked to speak to the manager and she sat us at another table. She was not friendly at all! Room was too dark to see our menus. Service was very, very slow. Appetizers were very, very small! Food was ok. We will not go back! Best steak place is JGilberts and Mitchells at Easton! Now wonder, Cameron Mitchell sold this location-it sucks
Food was very good! The steak was so tender & cooked perfect. My salad was also delicious. Our waiter was nice even though he forgot our bread & my second glass of wine. He was thoughtful & wished us a happy anniversary.
We did not know until we arrived that they did not accept Mitchell’s gift cards. They should post that they are not associated with Cameron Mitchell
Foods are good.
Stake is awesome.
Dessert is too sweet for me but is American average.
Staff are polite and kind.
Totally nice restaurant, I recommend to my friends.
The service was excellent. Attention to occasion details were greatly appreciated. The filet was very good. The vegetable sides were too cool as served. The Manhattan was really good. Except for the veggies that had been allowed to cool too much before serving, it was a pleasant, enjoyable experience.
Everything was great!
Really disappointing. Cowboy Pork Chop was very thick, really tough, almost unable to cut with a steak knife. Service was descent but slow. 2.5 hrs.
A good steakhouse experience.
First visit and it maybe our new favorite steakhouse! Filet Oscar style was amazing. Service was top notch. We will be back!
We were very disappointed - loud no privacy, sitting on top of one another . Food was mediocre for the price . Service was warm did not go out of their way to see if we wanted more wine etc . We are new to Columbus and we will certainly look for better steakhouse options .
Awful waitress. Didnt clean up appetizer dishes, dirty old glasses etc until we asked. Very slow and never came around to ask about our dinner. Brought bill without a pen so we have to find one from host since she was not around.
Our service was excellent, our meal was delicious, and my husband was given a free dessert for his birthday (also delicious)!