Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Polaris

Food was good. Service was so so. Sat for 20 minutes just waiting for check

Thanksgiving dinner

Jon and Tiffany at the bar make me feel like a regular, unfortunately I’m not. They are great. The food was great. The service was second to none. Vittoro (sp) the manager even thanked me for coming. It was a great experience

My birthday

Great experience, made all the better with Gloria,as our waitress. She is and was amazing! Daughter has peanut allergies she and the Chef went above and beyond to accommodate her. Outstanding Job.

Good after a long day and special time with my son.

13th Birthday with family

Awesome place, service was amazing and the general atmosphere was perfect.

The food was excellent. I don’t know why but my wife and I always get served the wrong steak. She orders hers medium and I order mine well done but they always give me hers. I asked for bone marrow butter and they didn’t bring it with the meal. When I asked for it, the server brought it to me, told me it was extremely hot and just came off the grill but the butter was frozen. Lol. She brought me another container and it was melted.

They quit carrying Crown Royal Reserve which was disappointing.

I enjoy eating here. Food is always great and the service is great 80% of the time.

Dinner was good and so was the service but what was great was seeing Vittorio. Mitchell’s hired a great individual and now that we know he is there, we
will be visiting more often.

Great service! Josh was great waiter!!

Worst steak ever and very overpriced as well. It’s hard to believe they don’t know how to cook a steak. Also, cold to lukewarm is not an an ideal temperature.

Really enjoyed our visit and meal. Location got very busy just after we arrived at 6 p.m... so service got a little slow, mostly due to a 10 top placed right next to our booth. Had hoped for a quiet dinner but noise level - many people and many conversations - got progressively worse as the evening went on. Over all a great experience for a special birthday dinner. Would be concerned about noise levels for a return visit.

Incredible food and staff.

A little pricey for my normal dining out experience but well worth it for the occasional treat. Try the Filet Oscar...amazing!

It was too dark! I liked the atmosphere but it was almost too dark to read the menu. We asked for the lights to be raised a little and management refused. My mom had to use the flashlight on her phone to be able to read the menu, which is ridiculous. It was even hard for me to read it and my eyesight is good.

Terrible management terrible server and unclean restrooms and unclean dining room

Outstanding service and food was great. Definitely pricey but enjoyed the evening.

My wife and I went for our anniversary. The staff went above and beyond to help us celebrate and make our night special. The Waygu New York Strip was by far the best steak I’ve ever had. Highly recommend this restaurant!

Everything was just sub-par. Steak was okay, sides were good, service was SLOW and really didn’t seem happy to be there. Nothing made our experience great, won’t be returning.

Everything was perfect. Timing of courses, food, service.

Great Service, Delicious Food, Wonderful Wine List and Great Desserts!

This was a wonderful place for a true celebration with friends. (It's a little dark for my taste, but I realize that many people like that.)

Wonderful atmosphere - really like the booths in the bar area for an intimate dining experience. Steaks were prepared perfectly. Interesting cocktail menu with some specialty items. Enjoyed every moment. Super classy staff.

We tried Mitchell's Steakhouse to celebrate our anniversary. We each had a different cut of beef, ribeye and Waygu Strip. Both were very good. We also got asparagus and brussel sprout sides. The asparagus was very good but the brussel sprouts were not. They were dry and crunchy. Upon mentioning our anniversary, we were offered a choice of dessert complementary!

It was wonderful! Server was so lovely, food was amazing and an amazing all around first experience!

Great overall experience. Great food, great service.

We always have a fabulous experience at this restaurant.Everyone is welcoming and concerned that we have a terrific dining experience and per usual we did!

We went for our Anniversary. This is a classy place where you can dress nice. Steak is tender and delicious. From salad to desert we enjoyed.

Wonderful meal and service!

The customer service we received was amazing. It was my Dad’s birthday and I asked if they could wish him a happy birthday when we arrived. Not just the server, but 2 other staff members wished him a happy birthday which was awesome. We had special happy birthday menus & they let him pick a complimentary dessert. All of that was wonderful but the best part of the night was our server. Elena. She was perfect for our family & did a wonderful job making him feel special. We had such a great time!

I took my wife here for our first dinner as husband and wife and it was perfect, service didn't skip a beat! The food was absolutely amazing, the best cut of steak I've ever had in my life and my wife was very impressed and happy with dinner. We'll be coming back on our anniversary and many times between then hopefully!

First time and I was very impressed. Food came out a little slow but i think that is by design to keep you drinking. Food was awesome but high priced.

Perfect!!!! Excellent steak!!! Service Outstanding!

We had a great experience at Mitchell’s again.
Made a last minute change from 5 to 7 people.
Food was excellent and outstanding service.

Wonderful relaxing but not too slow

Very nice place!! Will definitely go back! Fancy date night place!

3hr dinner, it took 20min for drinks to arrive. Table next to us left after 25min without service. Restaurant was 75% full and there was no explanation for the slow service. They ran out of dessert for my birthday... dinner was $300 for 4ppl. Definitely not going back. You are better off trying Eddie Merlots next door.

Normally we have exceptional experiences. Unfortunately it was restaurant week and therefore a lot busier than usual. Steak was overcooked, long wait, other order mishaps. Service was great and we made the best of it. I would recommend Mitchell’s at any other time of the year.

Great service and wonderful food!