Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Downtown
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Sealed or wrapped utensils used
- Limited number of seated diners
- Distancing maintained in common areas
- Extra space between tables
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
Pan Seared / Mustard Buerre Blanc Shaved Brussel Sprouts Bacon Saute
Never a disappointment
Steak Oscar wasn't great. Calamari , salad ,Mac and cheese , baked potato and big chocolate cake great! Old beautiful ex bank decorated in weird southwestern colors
Server was great and friendly!!! Very quite and helpful!!!
It truly was a great dining experience. I had only ever eaten mitchells steakhouse one other time at the polaris location, and i felt at both places were very good value for my money. Its a fine dining restaurant with fine dining prices, but I truly feel like the value i get here is worth it from both the quality of food and beverages alike. I would happily come back again for a nice date night.
My waitress was amazing, my food came out perfect and hot/fresh. My Pomegranate martini was amazing👌🏾
We were seated in the back party room with 5 other full tables while the front of the restaurant was wide open and it was very awkward felt like I had to whisper to talk to my girlfriend. The drinks and the service was fantastic.
The food was very disappointing for a Mitchell restaurant. My filet tasted like pure salt I couldn't finish it, the amount of salt was just too much. Overall a below average experience based on past visits to Mitchell restaurants. Will not be my first choice for dinner in the near future.
Food was great and service was perfect! Definitely a great place for a date night!
It was good! Food is always good, but the food took a longer time than usual.
This was a great experience and I recommend this play to everyone
The food was excellent and the meat was cooked perfectly. 'The Regular is a highly recommended cocktail as is the 'Mango Sangria.'
Did not like at all being seated in back room, it was dark, noisy kitchen and workers talking loudly right next to it. Very disappointed in environment. Front of restaurant was very beautiful but we didnt get to experience it. Did have reservation.
I was afraid that since the restaurant was a long-standing icon that it may have had a little "wear and tear", but everything was like new and kept up very well. It was a great new experience for my fiancé that she will never forget.
Great food with great service. Restaurant week deal was outstanding.
Great ambiance and service is outstanding. The food is good but not anything out of the ordinary.
Mitchell's has a good name. But, I was disappointed. Service was just OK, and the food average as well. My $40 sea bass was not fresh. We ordered their "famous" chocolate cake for desert. It was either stale or freezer burnt. In any case it was far from moist. Cake isn't supposed to be hard.
There are a lot of good choices for fine dining in Columbus. Would NOT come back here.
Excellent, great ambiance, food and service. It is expensive, but you get your value. Recommended!
If I could give 0 stars I would. I usually do not post reviews on companies even if the service was bad but the service I received last night 1/28/21 was absolutely terrible. It was date night I decided to participate in restaurant week which we've never done before. We also never been to Mitchells so we decided to give it a try. The inside is very nice I will say that but it went downhill when we had a server who constantly sniffled literally every two seconds while she talked and she barely had her mask up with covid waitresses should really wear medical mask but whatever. I explained to the waiter it was our first time dining there and doing restaurant week and asked if she could explain a few things on the menu which she did. The problem was her attitude was TERRIBLE it was like she had an attitude the moment she stepped to our table. We ordered our food when a different waitress brought my food she set it down so quick and walked away so fast before the plate completely hit the table. My portion of food was so small that it should've been on the kids menu although my 4 year old wouldn't even have gotten full off of it. Finally when our waitress came back (btw she barely came over to check on us) I started off by saying "I hate to be that type of person but I was not expecting my meal to be this small especially for the price we're paying can I please get something else" from there she got so mad that with every word she spoke she shrugged her shoulders everytime in an oh well manner then told me my meal was a "hell of a deal" and that's they can't do nothing about it. I said "well I don't want this plate and I'd like to get the pasta instead" she snatched the plate then walked away. While she's talking she had the nerve to pull her mask down as if she wasn't already sick and sniffling but then her nose was red on top of that. My boyfriend asked her to pull her mask back up due to her sniffles and she got so upset and rolled her neck. See the rest on Google
The service was outstanding and the food was exquisite.
We hadn't been there in a while and went for Restaurant Week. We have to make more of an effort to go downtown to Mitchell's. The steak & shrimp was fabulous!
My food was okay but my daughter had a long hair mixed with her butter. This is unacceptable especially with COVID and just overall cleanliness. Hair nets should be enforced!! This is restaurant week, seem like to me you would want to make it right but nothing was offered but a new steak and plate with the same shrimp. For the price you should have more class.
Best steakhouse in Downtown. We go to Mitchells every time we come to town.
Lovely service and food. Perfect for a romantic evening.
Went to Mitchell’s for my sons birthday spent over $550 and the filets were awful. Filet should cut like butter at med-rare but these where chewy and the cut was tough. There was one server for the whole restaurant who tried but it wasn’t great. We would have complained had it not been for the fact we had gone there to celebrate my sons 23rd. Disappointed doesn’t cover how we feel and we’ve had many a good experience in Mitchell’s restaurants this was definitely a huge let down.
Great service and amazing food!! Felt extremely safe with the COVID restrictions.
Great service, delicious steak, all around one of the best steakhouses I have visited
This is an incredible place to dine. Nicole is always professional and caring. Pick anything on the menu and you will not be disappointed. I come here often, the music in the background are horns and brass, elegant. The pandemic is hurting everyone, please go and support this restaurant, you will be glad you did.
Our waiter Ben was very patient and helpful! The food was astounding and the atmosphere was welcoming!
The steak was absolutely delicious! I shared a meal with my boyfriend with a side and it was plenty of food. Our servers were very kind and accommodating with covid and I felt very safe with the staff wearing masks and tables distanced.
Food was good, just service took a little while and he forgot some minor things
Service was subpar for the expeience. The food was fantastic which will be enough to come back!!
The food, the service and the mixed drinks surpassed all of our expectations. Plus what a beautiful atmosphere!
Wonderful food in a special place. Wine list is goo too. Spicy Lobster bites are perfect.
Mitchell’s is my favorite restaurant by far. It has never been a disappointment. The steaks are second to none. They are prepared perfectly. The sides are wonderful and enough for two people. Service is top notch and they remember you. My drink is always made just the way I like it. I use to go to Mitchell’s just for special occasions. I’ve found having dinner solo, at the bar relaxed and causal.
The food was very good but dinner felt extremely rushed! I had no time to finish my salad or to order another drink. It felt like we were being rushed in and out as fast as they could possibly go.
New Years dinner with my family of 6, 4 children under 9. Great service.
Christmas with family. You guys did a great job taking care of our family.
Service slow and manager never stopped over after food was returned. Did not feel valued
The heat was out, it took 75 minutes to get our entrees, and the food was bland.
There are too many nice restaurants in Columbus to settle for the experience we had.
They have been better. Iam giving them a COVID19 pass in hopes that things will get better in 2021.
The staff went above and beyond to accommodate our needs! My son works at the Renaissance and recommended Mitchells over a year ago. We have been many times and it has never disappointed! Great staff and food:)
Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Downtown does offer delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Downtown also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (614) 621-2333.
Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Downtown is rated 4.5 stars by 1915 OpenTable diners.
Mitchell's Steakhouse - Columbus Downtown does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.