Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester
Book your next event with us
- Surfaces sanitized between seatings
- Common areas deep cleaned daily
- Digital, disposable or sanitized menu provided
- Sanitizer or wipes provided for customers
- Waitstaff wear masks
- Sick staff prohibited in the workplace
served grilled, broiled or blackened over your choice of spinach or caesar salad
broiled tilapia, green beans
Mitchell’s really knows how to make a birthday girl (my wife!) happy. Excellent seafood, prompt and thoughtful service in a cozy and cool environment. Definitely going back.
Food was excellent as always. Seevers did great job.
This was an excellent choice for Thanksgiving dinner the turkey was excellent as was the service and whole experience
Thanksgiving dinner had very little thin gravy under meat. I asked for gravy for the mashed potatoes and was told there would be an extra charge. Turkey and dressing were ho hum and the veggies too hard. Our dessert order was taken with the dinner order. At dessert time we were told they were out of the crime brûlée which two of four of us had ordered. No new option was added to replace it. Apple or pumpkin pie was the only choice. We would not have ordered the turkey meal had we known up front. The lobster bisque was good as always.
I ordered the Thanksgiving dinner. The turkey was tasteless and had lots of fat around the edges. The seasonal vegetables were barely cooked so I found them inedible. The portion size of the rest of the sides was smaller than expected for the price. My slice of pumpkin pie was missing part of the crust and I would have like whipped cream on it, which was not offered.
Wishing I’d gone somewhere else for Thanksgiving!
It was a terrific Thanksgiving Dinner - everything was delicious and the quantity was generous. Service, even with limited staff was good.
Thanksgiving dinner was good. They had a pre fixed turkey dinner option but also their normal seafood options. They have a pretty extensive gluten free offering so I always have options. We sat in the bar area this time instead of the main dining room and it was a bit quieter, but I think that was because the bar was not super busy. Always a very friendly staff. Thanks for being open on Thanksgiving.
On Thanksgiving Day, reservations in advance. Everything was excellent. highly recommended for an upscale dinner out.
Great experience. Highly recommend!
Had a great T’giving at Mitchell’s! Service was great and so was the food.
Devon was a wonderful server and provided great recommendations.
First of all the place was not even half full and NOT understaffed from a server standpoint. I have no clue about the kitchen staffing but the food was cold but edible. I asked for the check when we got the main course because I didn’t want to stay any longer than necessary. Obviously I won’t be going back
Very small portions of fish and chips. Fries were cold. Took a long time to get our food so we didn’t want to return anything. The bright spot was our server he was very friendly.
My wife and I would frequently eat here about 10 years ago. We used to love this place but moved away. We were in town for a birthday and decided to visit again. The service was top notch, but the food quality and taste were horrible. We will not be returning.
It’s been awhile since we’ve been here, we will not ever return. It’s feels and is “old school “. So drab and boring inside and the menu. Fresh feeling places like Seasons 52 are simply 100% better. My culinary tastes have evolved , I’m moving on. Oh? And the service was terrible and slow.
Me and my wife had date night and are server Charlotte made it great we her excellent service
We had a very enjoyable dinner with our daughter and her friend visiting from Denver. Everyone’s meal was excellent and the service was efficient and friendly.
We had received a gift card from friends last Christmas and used it to celebrate our anniversary. We couldn’t have celebrated at a better place and enjoyed it more.
My party of 4 had overcooked shrimp
Salmon had no flavor
My carrot cake for dessert was dry
At least the iced tea was cold
I have been a regular at this Mitchell's and am sorry to say that I won't be back for awhile. The waiter was absolutely super and attentive. But there was no warm sourdough bread, which is a big draw for me, and the entree was not good. We were seated by the kitchen entrance and could hear wait staff yelling. All in all, not a good experience--except for the waiter!!!
The food was very good as usual. The server was new and did a really good job!
Hoping poor service and food selection is COVID related. Took a family member there for a birthday. They were out of many menu items and the service was just bad. I still tipped her 20% as I don’t know that it was her fault.
I used to love Mitchell’s and considered it a go-to for special events. Probably won’t be going back.
Went last Saturday with my wife after a very disappointed time in july where the food was sreved very cold. I thought well I'll give them another try. Quess what? The food was again extremely cold. Like it was pre cooked and then heated in a microwave oven. I was really disappointed because I specifically told the waited about the previous experience with the cold food and asked that the food to be served hot. This is unfortunate because my wife and I like the place. I will not go there anytime soon.
Food was well prepared and tasty. Server was polite and attentive
I have dined her often and am always happy that I came. The food and presentation
are delicious and eye appealing. The service is wonderful. The staff goes the extra mile to make you feel welcome.
Dinner for wife’s birthday. Service was outstanding! Food was great as always. Will definitely be back
Awesome wait staff.
Food was good. I got the Sea Bass and it was great.
Great food wonderful experience and service we will be back for sure our server tyrone he was wonderful!
Main courses were pretty good. Appetizers were nothing special. Shrimp app was rubbery.
Service was slow but, we get that.
Upon arriving for our dinner reservation my husband and I were told that we could not sit at the bar and wait or a table. It was because they were understaffed. We were told we could come back in 30 minutes. when we weere leaving the manager approached us and told us we were to be seated and a sever would be taking care of us immediately. We were suprised!
We had a wonderful dinner and our waitress was extreamly attentive. We are not quite sure what happened, but Mitchells went out of their way to make things right.
We have been patrons for many years and understand the help shortage due to Covid. We will continue to frequent Mitchell's in the near future.
Ordered the lobster, which was cold. The overall quality of our appetizers and main entrée was just horrible.
The food was mediocre at best.
Unfortunately this was a bad night for Mitchell's. We waited over an hour and a half and were served only a bread roll and salad. That was only after we flagged down another wait staff and asked what was going on. Our original wait staff disappeared. We had a show to catch so we had to walk out without eating. The most aggravating part of the night was that the manager, who knew this was happening, said nothing to us on the way out.
Food was good. Portions were small for the price you pay. Not a good overall value
We book for an Happy Hour. It was great service and the crew was very attentive.
We will come back.
The server was very good. The food was also very good, especially the Shanghai seafood sampler.
Our dinner was perfect in every way!! The service. The food. Incredible. It’s our favorite spot.
After sitting for 15 min we ere asked if we anted bread. The fish was not cooked all the way through. The food was luke warm and not hot. The portion size did not match the price.
I felt really bad for our waitress she was covering 2 areas & brought me the wrong food unfortunately I was in a rush because I was paged into the hospital so had to get my food to go.
The hostesses were kind and inviting. Most notable was the stellar experience provided by our server, David. His smile, knowledge of the menu and overall pleasant attitude really made for a fantastic dining experience. Kudos
You can order delivery directly from Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester using the Order Online button. Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester also offers delivery in partnership with Postmates and Uber Eats. Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester also offers takeout which you can order by calling the restaurant at (248) 340-5900.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester is rated 4.1 stars by 2067 OpenTable diners.
Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester does offer gift cards which you can purchase here https://www.landrysinc.com/giftcards/default.asp.
Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable. Due to local restrictions, this restaurant may not be accepting reservations at the moment.