Mitchell's Fish Market - Rochester
Book your next event with us
Instantly increase your points with dining rewards
See availability for bonus point tables
Sun - Thu 4:00PM - 5:30PM 8:30PM - 11:00PM
We enjoyed all items we ordered. I did not order an entrée, only the spicy shrimp appetizer and the Titanic Wedge which my husband and I shared. He enjoyed the salmon. I enjoy fish at this restaurant only if they do not melt butter on top of it.
We went for our 28 anniversary and we really enjoyed it everything was really good and the ambiance was really nice.
The only thing I would say to improve on .
1. Is to add a different kind of bread other then just sour dough.
2. to put brighter lighting in the woman bathroom was way to dark like a lot of light were out.
Other then that was a really nice evening.
Eat there often but this was a huge disappointment! We waited 15 minutes for our reservation even tho there were many empty tables. It took 3 requests and 20 minutes just to get water. We waited over 1/2 hour for our food to arrive. One of my party was served water in a VERY badly broken glass. We never saw a manager. They usually stop by the table at least once!
Filet Oscar was perfectly prepared. Lobster bisque was great. Excellent service.
Great menu choices and staff was excellent! We will definitely be back.
Waiter, drinks, and food were slow. Food was good except for the rubbery shrimp.
Good food, good setvice
Salmon was good but not as flavorful as I expected. Fish and chips were good. Appetizers tasty but everything is a bit overprices
Fish selection was lacking and I was told the Ahi Tuna can pre-seared so they couldn’t prepare it without salt. Service was super slow and the food was mediocre.
GREAT dining experience!! Good food!! A bit pricey!!
Service excellent. Crab stuffed flounder average, to sub average. Flounder bland and stuffed crab was mushy, tasteless, and had an unattractive gray hue.
They must have change something in the kitchen because the food was the best that we have had in a long time 😀
Great place to visit I And my wife enjoyed our dinner!!
This restaurant has a very good happy hour menu and friendly bar staff. The food in the dining room was good and the service was very good
Great place fror a date night or girlfriend get-together.
Overall it was good but menue could be more creative.
Over priced for the quality delivered; Landry’s destroyed the brand. Sad.
Our service was great but my tacos were not very tasty. The shells were hard and not that appetizing. We was surprised because I order them at the bar for happy hour all the time.
Had a nice evening with friends and enjoyed the food and wine.
Everything was good. Air con too cold.
The restaurant was packed on a busy Saturday night when we arrived but were able to get seated at a table right away. Three other tables around us were seated after we arrived, and all three of them received their food and left before we even received our meal. The food itself was delicious upon arrival, but by that point we were all getting slightly irritated and hungry. We were in one of the tables in the middle of the dining area, and unfortunately with little space between tables my mom kept on getting bumped whenever a server or patron squeezed by in the aisleway. Overall, it was not our favorite experience at this restaurant (we have had some delicious and memorable meals there), but hopefully next time will be better.
All in all a very nice evening. However, there was a backup at the bar so it took awhile to get our cocktails. However, the waiter warned us and brought hot bread to the table.
What a great lunch visit. Steven our server was great. Food was outstanding
Our server didn’t have a clue - very likely poor training because other staff who attempted to address our concerns seemed less than well-informed. A bit frustrating and distracting.
We were celebrating a birthday. We were greeted warmly and were escorted to a comfortable booth. Our server was Timothy. He reviewed the menu and the daily specials. The service was prompt and the food delicious. We shared a piece shark fin pie for dessert. We highly recommend Mitchell’s for any occasion.
Fantastic as always. New menu items around the impossible burger were a pleasant surprise.
Dylan was a fabulous host and server. Answered all our questions and was very patient with us. Very attentive.
Dinner was fabulous.
This is on the list of ‘go to places’ cuz they always provide good service and delicious food. Pleased with consistency overall.
Food is not what is used to be like. When it first open it was great. But a slow decline since then. We returned after a two year hiatus expecting improvement but we were disappointed and worse than ever. Every entree was bland. Gordon's Fish Sticks would have been a better option.
Salmon was sent back twice.
Bbq sauce on the bbq bacon wrapped shrimp was awful.
I was done with my meal befor my dates salmon came back
Other than that it was fine
Waitress combined our bill with another table. Didn’t notice till we left. They failed to correct the bill, which was overcharged by $200.00. We tipped on a $400 bill, which was only supposed to be a $250 bill and they refused to change the tip. We left 20% tip, but they kept tip same based on wrong bill. I will be disputing the charge with my credit card company as I feel this was an intentional scam by the server and restaurant.
Our food took a very long time to come out and was cold. It was an expensive meal that wasn’t that great.
We’ve been dining here for almost 10 years, but we seen a slow decline in quality of food and service. I don’t foresee us dining here again.
Food was good and once the server came over the service was good. It did take the waitress
Over 5 minutes to greet us and that was very frustrating. And the bartenders were arguing about something in front of everyone and it took a while to
Pay for a drink.
We enjoyed the evening although it didn't start off too well. We had made a reservation for 4 adults for a birthday in a booth. I guess we should have specified what booth we wanted but we didn't know it was necessary. WE were given a horseshoe booth which is hard for conversation. There were 2 ordinary booths for 4 empty but had been specifically saved for other parties.
food was great
This is the second visit in a row that our meal was served cold. The first time we sent it back to be reheated and still came back cold. The second time we thought that would not happen again because for years we never had a bad meal but it happened again. They have some issue going on that needs to be fixed.
I believe the waitress was new and might if needed some help. Asked for items and never received. Appetizer arrived with meal. Sat for 35 min with only our drinks, no bread till I asked someone else.
Very good food
Baby with grandma and grandpa...date night for mom and dad! We had a 6:45 reservation and were not seated until 7:25. It was a bit disappointing, but both managers on staff that night came to our table and apologized for that. Food is always excellent!
The food was salty and overcooked